Editorialists at the Los Angeles Times wrote in the paper’s April 14th edition that the Bush Administration’s proposed New Source Review reform (which would restore clarity lost during the Clinton years over what constitutes “routine maintenance”) “would let plants use rhetorical ruses to slink past environmental restrictions.” This is, the paper declared, “free-market” philosophy run amok. Besides, they aver, “there’s no evidence that fewer rules will lead to better breathing.”
FACT: The Bush Administration is trying to reform the Clinton Administration’s extreme definition of routine maintenance, which, before Carol Browner’s tenure, allowed plants to forgo the costly, burdensome NSR permitting process for minor activities, including those that increased energy efficiency, improved safety, and that didn’t significantly increase pollution.
As for the lack of evidence that fewer rules lead to “better breathing,” the LA Times editorialists should read about, among other things (including NSR reform), the 1990 Acid Rain trading program, which eliminated complex, command-and-control requirements in favor of a simple market-based trading system. The President’s Clear Skies initiative is based on that very system, which has led to 100 percent compliance and unprecedented reductions of sulfur dioxide emissions over the last decade.