The U.S. Public Interest Research Group (U.S. PIRG) released a report yesterday trumpeting the marvels of renewable energy (renewables currently comprise about 2 percent of electricity generation). The report, which condemned the use of “dirty” fossil fuels, found that it is not only possible, but also economically beneficial, to have 20 percent of the nation’s electricity fueled by renewable energy by 2020.

 

FACT: While renewable energy should be part of the nation’s energy mix, U.S. PIRG is, to put it mildly, vastly overestimating its commercial and technological viability. According to the Energy Information Administration (EIA), our electricity mix in 2020 will break down as follows: coal, 44 percent; natural gas 36 percent; nuclear, 11 percent; hydroelectric, 6 percent. Non-hydro renewables will make up only 3 percent of electric generation. Even under scenarios that assume rapid improvements in renewable technologies with correspondingly lower costs to consumers, the figure jumps to just 4.6 percent. In a rather striking understatement, EIA said: “Projections of large increases in renewable energy use should be viewed with caution.”