As the New York Times reported today, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, because of a lack of funds, will temporarily stop designating tracts of land as critical habitats under the Endangered Species Act. Craig Manson, assistant secretary of the Department of Interior who oversees the Fish and Wildlife Service, said bluntly, "We are out of money, or will be in a few days.” Kieran Suckling, executive director of the Center for Biological Diversity, which proudly describes itself as “Nature’s Legal Eagles, said the Bush Administration has “engineered a budget crisis.” What’s going on here? Where did all the money go?

 

FACT: To pay for the flood of ‘critical habitat’ litigation brought about by environmental groups, whose legal war has undermined the very species they want to save. Big Green litigiousness is not a new phenomenon, of course, but one that also vexed Jamie Rappaport Clark, former head of the Clinton Fish and Wildlife Service. Clark said in 2000 that critical habitat lawsuits have “turned our priorities upside down.” More ominously, she said those lawsuits were creating a “biological disaster.” In testimony before Congress, the Clinton Fish and Wildlife said, “In most circumstances, the designation of ‘official’ critical habitat is of little additional value for most listed species.” So, one might ask, what’s the point of these “citizen suits?” Mr. Kieran Suckling, noted above, said it best: “You know what is so important about the spectacled eider [a sea duck]? That designation will be the only thing standing between George Bush and the oil rigs” (Sacramento Bee, April 24, 2001).