Showering accolades on their brothers-in-arms, environmental groups hailed the boycott of Gov. Mike Leavitt’s nomination to be the next EPA Administrator, orchestrated by 8 Democrats and 1 Independent on the EPW Committee. Earthjustice, formerly the Sierra Club’s legal defense arm, and whose slogan is “Because the Earth Needs a Good Lawyer,” distinguished themselves from the pack, viewing the Leavitt boycott as equivalent to a patriotic act: “The Senators who refused to be placated by vague answers and meaningless assurances did their constituents, and their children and grandchildren, a real service today. Regardless of party, all Senators have a constitutional duty to ensure that our nation’s laws will be upheld.” (Actually, in point of fact, Senators swear an oath to uphold the constitution, which includes that important clause about advice and consent; interesting, too, that the group has a sudden affinity for the constitution.)
FACT: As is the case with much of the environmental community, Earthjustice, whose sole reason for existence is to file lawsuits, is well-schooled in the fine art of obstructionism, having tied up environmental progress in the courts for years, and now “taking a stand” against instituting a permanent leader at EPA. No group, as the Sacramento Bee reported, has more won more in legal fees than Earthjustice. The Bee noted that an Earthjustice attorney charged $350 an hour, a higher rate than those charged by many experienced attorneys in San Francisco. In one endangered species case, the group submitted a bill of $439,053 to the Justice Department, and settled for $383,840.