For months Russia has waffled on the whether to ratify the Kyoto Accords. So when word came last week that Russian President Vladimir Putin and his council decided to move their nation towards ratifying Kyoto, observers where quick to ask why now?

FACT: President Putin’s decision to ratify Kyoto has nothing to do with improving Russia’s environment and everything to do with politics. Putin knew he could accommodate European powers by beginning the process to ratify Kyoto. A Reuter’s article makes this point clear quoting Russian Economic Development Minister German Gref saying, “The protocol hardly has any real impact on improving ecology. It is fairly symbolic.” The reporter added that Graf believes, “the cabinet aimed at setting a good international precedent rather than focusing on economic or environmental concerns.”

 

Just how much will the Kyoto Accords help stop climate change? Not much! A Reuter’s article reports scientists need at least a 70 percent reduction. The article explains, “But without the United States — which withdrew in 2001 — and with loopholes designed to entice Russia and Japan into ratifying, Kyoto may ultimately only cut emissions by as little as one percent, some analysts say.” Even Greenpeace’s Steve Sawyer admits just how little of a difference saying “The 5-percent (the originally proposed reduction) was a baby step; this is an even more baby step.”

 

Considering the limited environmental impact, how much will the Russian economy be forced to suffer? According to Andrei Illarionov, Russian President Vladimir Putin’s top economic adviser, “We should call the Kyoto Protocol an interstate gulag,” and further stated, “In the gulag, though, you got the same ration daily and it didn’t get smaller day by day. In the end we had to call the Kyoto Protocol an international Auschwitz.”

 

Here in the United States Kyoto faces bipartisan opposition. Following negotiations with then President Clinton, the United States Senate sent the President a clear message passing a unanimous resolution against the Kyoto Accords. Even Democratic Presidential candidate John Kerry voted against implementing the Kyoto Accord. On July 25, 1997, the U.S. Senate sent President Clinton a clear message in passing the Byrd/Hagel Resolution by a vote of 95 to 0.

 

While Kyoto supporters may soon celebrate implementation of the Kyoto Accords, they along with everyone else understand implementation means insignificant environmental progress. Signatories to the Kyoto will be forced to suffer economic hardship while seeing only minimal if any movement in reductions of greenhouse gasses. Russia’s steps yesterday should in no way be seen as a victory for the environment and must be seen for what it is: political appeasement.