Environmental groups profess with absolute certainty that mercury control technologies are widely commercially available, relatively inexpensive, and more than capable of achieving consistent, reliable, emissions reductions in a just three years, for all coal types and plant configurations. The testing and demonstration phase is over, they say, and those contending otherwise are either unaware of what’s happening in the real world or simply shilling for industry. So how dare the Bush Administration, and its fellow travelers in Congress, oppose a 90 percent reduction of mercury emissions by 2008. Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who could be classified as mercury-obsessive–said last year, “My own levels of mercury are so high–I had them tested recently”–claims that a 90 percent standard in three years “would have cost less than 1 percent of plant revenue, and the great thing about it is that it works…” The Sierra Club, in testimony last year before the EPA, confidently asserted that, “Compared to technologies for other power plant pollutants, mercury technologies are not very expensive.” Just in case the message wasn’t clear, the National Wildlife Federation, in one of its seemingly endless parade of mercury “studies,” last week “refuted” the notion that, “protective mercury standards are either technically impossible or prohibitively expensive,” and concluded that, “deep, 90% mercury control, is achievable and affordable, even in states that rely heavily on coal for electricity generation.”

 

 

FACT: A new report by the Energy Information Administration provides compelling proof that mercury control technologies are not commercially available and that a 90 percent standard by 2008 is highly impractical, unrealistic, and excessively costly.

 

In the 60-plus-page report, titled “Analysis of Mercury Control Strategies,” EIA notes the significant uncertainty associated with mercury removal. “At this time,” EIA wrote, “there is significant uncertainty about the degree to which mercury can be removed from some coals,” and “it could be several years before these technologies are fully commercialized.”

 

What of the “achievable” 90 percent reduction by 2008? Not quite: “Whether current ACI [activated carbon injection] systems for coal plants would meet the analysis request requirement for a ‘commercially demonstrated technology’ for deployment in the 2008 timeframe, particularly if 90-percent removal is required, is unclear.”

 

Is a 90 percent, command-and-control standard by 2008 “not every expensive”? Seems it is expensive: in 2010, electricity and natural gas prices would be 22 percent 26 percent higher, respectively. And resource costs could reach $358 billion, or nearly 7 times the cost of implementing Clear Skies, which would reduce mercury, sulfur dioxide, and nitrogen oxides for $52 billion.