Adam Smith could easily have been describing environmental groups when he called universities “a sanctuary in which exploded systems and obsolete prejudices find shelter and protection after they have been hunted out of every other corner of the world.” In a new report titled, “Jobs and the Climate Stewardship Act: How Curbing Global Warming Can Increase Employment,” the Natural Resources Defense Council actually contends that the Climate Stewardship Act, which requires cutting greenhouse gases in 2010 to 2000 levels, would create over 500,000 jobs. According to NRDC, but for “anti-government ideologues” and their “unfounded” fears about climate change regulations, the CSA could become law and “reduce global warming pollution and increase employment.” This of course runs counter to every credible analysis of the bill. But NRDC thinks the bill’s “use of flexible, market-based approaches” would be an economic boon, particularly to the nation’s manufacturing sector. And though the bill, as NRDC concedes, would destroy jobs in coal mining and electrical generation, it mitigates those losses through “direct transition assistance for displaced workers and adversely affected communities.”

FACT: Is NRDC retracting its support for the original Climate Stewardship Act (CSA), which required cutting greenhouse gases in 2016 to 1990 levels? Apparently, because according to the Energy Information Administration, the original bill would destroy 600,000 jobs. As for NRDC’s “findings” about manufacturing jobs, the National Association of Manufacturers described a vote for the amended CSA (2000 levels in 2010) as “a vote unambiguously against manufacturing jobs.” Second, NRDC touts the economic efficiency of the Act’s market-based trading program to reduce carbon emissions. Interestingly, the Congressional Budget Office recently wrote that a carbon tax would be more efficient. Third, the Congressional Budget Office in 2003 noted the limited effectiveness of Climate Stewardship Act’s scheme to help severely affected communities: “The government could use the allowance value to partly redistribute the costs of a carbon cap-and-trade program, but it could not cover those costs entirely.” Finally, CBO found that carbon cap-and-trade programs “reduce the welfare of U.S. residents” in the form of job losses lower stock prices, and higher energy prices.