Lords’ Economic Affairs Committee Raises Doubts In January 2005, the British House of Lords’ Economic Affairs Committee announced an “Inquiry into aspects of the economics of climate change” and issued a “call for evidence.” Today, the Committee released its report, “The Economics of Climate Change,” confirming the numerous uncertainties in climate change science and the problems associated with the work of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Some key points from its abstract (emphasis added): “We have some concerns about the objectivity of the IPCC process, with some of its emissions scenarios and summary documentation apparently influenced by political considerations.” “The Government should press the IPCC for better estimates of the monetary costs of global warming damage and for explicit monetary comparisons between the costs of measures to control warming and their benefits.” “We are concerned that the international negotiations on climate change reduction will be ineffective because of the preoccupation with setting emissions targets. The Kyoto Protocol makes little difference to rates of warming, and has a naïve compliance mechanism which can only deter countries from signing up to subsequent tighter emissions targets. We urge the Government to take a lead in exploring alternative “architectures” for future Protocols, based perhaps on agreements on technology and its diffusion.” Political considerations certainly have had an influence in international climate science. Consider Royal Society president Lord May of Oxford’s comment on June 7, 2005 upon releasing an 11-nation joint science academies statement: “The current US policy on climate change is misguided. The Bush administration has consistently refused to accept the advice of the US National Academy of Sciences (NAS).” NAS president Bruce Alberts noted in a letter to Senator Larry Craig (R-Idaho) that NAS had not seen the Royal Society statement prior to its release and expressed his dismay, stating that it did “not represent the views of the U.S. National Academy of Sciences.” From Russia With… Rejection Last Friday, July 1st, Russian scientists came to some similar conclusions as the House of Lords, rejecting the Kyoto approach as “scientifically ungrounded” according to the Russian news agency, RIA Novosti. The news report states that “Russian scientists said they still considered the Kyoto protocol was scientifically ungrounded, and would be an ineffective way to try to achieve the aim of the UN convention on climate change. They also said it was harmful for the Russian economy.” Yury Izrael, chairman of the Russian Academy of Sciences’ council-seminar on the Kyoto protocol, also stated that Russian Academy of Sciences president Yury Osipov’s signature on the recent joint science academies statement was “a misunderstanding.” The story also reported that “academicians asked Osipov to recall his signature.”