“French President Jacques Chirac yesterday said he had won key U.S. concessions on global-warming policy, despite a Group of Eight accord that effectively killed the 1997 Kyoto treaty’s restrictions on greenhouse-gas emissions.” (James G. Lakely, “Chirac claims win over U.S. on Kyoto,” The Washington Times, July 8, 2005) Kyoto Dead as G-8 Concedes to Bush Administration Climate Approach Jacques Chirac would say yesterday’s virtual abandonment of the Kyoto Protocol by the G-8 leaders was a victory. As much a victory as Waterloo, perhaps. But Mr. Chirac needs a political victory badly and opportunities have been lacking. The statement that the G-8 produced on climate change is hardly an embrace of the Kyoto Protocol and mandatory emissions reductions as Mr. Chirac would ordinarily champion, but is, in essence, a rejection of Mr. Chirac’s “first component of an authentic global governance” and EU commissioner Margot Wallstrom’s “level playing field” at the expense of the American economy. Today’s G-8 Communiqué states: “While uncertainties remain in our understanding of climate science, we know enough to act now to put ourselves on a path to slow and, as the science justifies, stop and then reverse the growth of greenhouse gases.” While not perfect, that statement repudiates Kyoto, which relied on “certainties,” and represents a dramatic shift in approach. There are indeed a number of scientific uncertainties in climate science, far from the manufactured, so-called “consensus” touted by climate alarmists and extremist special interests. The statement also reads: “Those of us who have ratified the Kyoto Protocol welcome its entry into force and will work to make it a success.” They have a lot of work ahead as there’s been little success. Why the shift in approach? Because Europe cannot meet its Kyoto targets. Recall Robert Samuelson’s Washington Post op-ed last Wednesday, June 29th: “Considering Europeans’ contempt for the United States and George Bush for not embracing the Kyoto Protocol, you’d expect that they would have made major reductions in greenhouse gas emissions — the purpose of Kyoto. Well, not exactly. From 1990 (Kyoto’s base year for measuring changes) to 2002, global emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2), the main greenhouse gas, increased 16.4 percent, reports the International Energy Agency.” Samuelson itemized those increases: France, a 6.9 percent increase; – Italy, 8.3 percent; – Greece, 28.2 percent; – Ireland, 40.3 percent; – the Netherlands, 13.2 percent; – Portugal, 59 percent; and – Spain, a 46.9 percent increase over 1990 levels Samuelson notes that Germany’s emissions decreased 13.3 percent – due to the closure of “many inefficient coal-fired plants in eastern Germany; that was a huge one-time saving” and points out that Britain’s 5.5 percent decline was the result of an earlier government decision “to shift electric utilities from coal (high CO2 emissions) to plentiful natural gas (lower CO2 emissions).” The U.S. increase amounted to only 16.7 percent. Unfortunately, natural gas is not so plentiful in the United States due to restrictions on domestic exploration prompted, ironically, by environmental extremists. The failure of EU nations to meet targets under Kyoto further demonstrates the lack of will or ability by those claiming to be the biggest supporters of reducing greenhouse gasses. Catherine Pearce, global climate change spokeswoman for Friends of the Earth, is correct to ask: “If Britain and the rest of Europe cannot get it right, then how can anyone expect the US or developing countries to?” (John Vidal, “Europe fails to cut greenhouse gas emissions,” The Guardian, 6/18/2005)