In Case You Missed It… The Morning Call [Allentown, Penn.], Op-ed Don’t impose mercury limits that will cost Pa. jobs August 17, 2005 Union families, electric generators, and the coal industry support reducing mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants. But let’s do it in a way that makes a real difference in reducing health risks and without threatening our jobs. A recent proposal by the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) for Pennsylvania to adopt its own mercury limit ignores a fundamental fact about mercury emissions — they are a global problem and travel hundreds and thousands of miles. Globally, power plant emissions make up about 1 percent of mercury emissions. … Businesses, consumers and workers within the Commonwealth would be disadvantaged if the Department were to implement a state-specific mercury rule that is more stringent than the federal rule. This is particularly true now that Pennsylvania’s electric industry has been restructured and in-state generation facilities must compete with power producers in neighboring states. The higher costs resulting from a Pennsylvania-specific rule would likely result in more power being generated in those neighboring states. Emissions from those out-of-state plants, including mercury emissions, would then be transported into Pennsylvania, negating any potential environmental benefit to the Commonwealth. And how much environmental benefit can be expected from a Pennsylvania rule compared to the federal rule to begin with? Available research data suggests little or none at all. In its regulatory impact analysis of the federal mercury rule, EPA found that completely eliminating mercury emissions from power plants produced negligible additional reductions in deposition compared to the reductions produced by the federal rules. This is because the federal rules result in very large decreases in the type of mercury that is most readily deposited onto land and water surfaces — reactive gaseous mercury. Given these considerations, coupled with the fact that emissions from Pennsylvania’s power plants represent a tiny percentage of the mercury we can be exposed to, we believe any reasonable person must ask whether any incremental environmental benefit can be expected from any Pennsylvania unilateral approach to controlling mercury emissions from power plants. Let’s reduce the health risks from mercury in ways that make good scientific and economic sense, and that minimize job losses, by adopting a federal approach to controlling mercury emissions. Edward D. Yankovick Jr. is international vice president for District 2 of the United Mine Workers of America, George Ellis is president of the Pennsylvania Coal Association, Donald C. Siegel is international vice president for the International Brotherhood of Electrical workers, and Douglas L. Biden is president of the Electric Power Generation Association. Click here for the full text of the op-ed.