Fact of the Day: Friday, October 28, 2005 The True Cost of CO2 EPA’s Clean Air Modeling Relies on Low Assumptions for Natural Gas Prices, But Also Unrealistically Low Prices for CO2 Trading Members of the Environment & Public Works Committee participated in a briefing yesterday by Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Steve Johnson on additional modeling of pending clean air legislative proposals. Following the briefing, Senator Inhofe issued a press release stating, “I would note that the modeling seems to make some unrealistic assumptions about the future cost of natural gas. With those low assumptions in mind, I’d urge caution in jumping to conclusions about the electricity costs transferred to the consumer in the proposals we’re considering. With a low domestic supply of natural gas due to current regulations and the hypocrisy of environmental special interests who advocate clean air but strongly oppose domestic exploration, we can realistically expect that natural gas prices will stay at their current high levels, if not increase even more.” As with the assumptions related to natural gas, EPA’s modeling also seems to make similar unrealistic assumptions about the costs related carbon dioxide (CO2). John Stanton of the National Environmental Trust took full advantage of these unrealistic numbers today in a New York Times article pointing out that the EPA analysis shows controls for carbon dioxide in Senator Carper’s Clean Air Planning Act would cost only US $1 per ton. Fact: The trading price for CO2 emissions in Europe closed today at 21.98 Euros (US $26.51) per ton (up .18 over yesterday’s price, with a 30-day high hovering around 24 Euros [US $28.95] per ton according to pointcarbon.com). (source: PointCarbon.com) That figure is more than 20 times the value assumed for CO2 control costs in EPA’s analysis of the Clean Air Planning Act, which assumed that one could purchase unlimited carbon permits from outside the power sector at a low price, not the real prices in today’s markets. If that assumption doesn’t hold (and based on the EU’s experience, it would not), the costs of the Clean Air Planning Act’s CO2 controls would skyrocket. Furthermore, the Reuters article, European Countries Trade “Emissions Credits”, shows that the cost of CO2 on the market has tripled just this year. As EPA stated in its press release yesterday, the “Clear Skies cap and trade approach will give states the most powerful, efficient and proven tool available for meeting new, tough, health-based air quality standards for fine particles and ozone. Most counties will be able to meet the new standards without having to take any new local measures beyond the Clear Skies power plant reductions. The market-based trading approach will substantially cut the overall cost of compliance that is passed on to consumers and shareholders.”