Fact of the Day: Monday, December 12, 2005 MOPping Up Kyoto Proponents Grasping At Straws In Wake of Montreal “Non-result” Montreal… Through Rose-colored Glasses A story in Greenwire today, “U.N. conference sets process for further emission cuts, global dialogue,” focused exclusively on the perspective of officials still promoting the failed Kyoto Protocol and their special interest allies, but failed to make clear that the final agreement coming out of last week’s meeting in Montreal was only an agreement to hold more meetings: “After two weeks of negotiations, including two consecutive all-night sessions, proponents of the Kyoto Protocol say the landmark agreement is alive and well as most nations agreed here to set new targets after 2012 and others agreed to start talking about long-term action to curb climate change. ‘Many naysayers going into these negotiations said Kyoto is dead, but what we discovered is that both industrialized and developing countries want its framework continued and expanded,’ Phil Clapp, president of National Environmental Trust, said in an interview. … As the talks ended around 6 a.m. Saturday, Richard Kinley, acting head of the United Nations Climate Change Secretariat, declared, ‘This has been one of the most productive U.N. Climate Change Conferences ever.’” Fact: Kinley’s statement is overly optimistic. Perhaps the greatest success coming out of the Montreal COP 11/MOP 1 was that the United States held its position against engaging in the Kyoto Protocol and committing to mandatory targets under its scheme, thereby by protecting the U.S. economy and American jobs. Despite what Phil Clapp says, Kyoto has failed because the overwhelming majority of nations that signed on to it nearly a decade ago are not meeting their targets, a point driven home time and again throughout the two weeks of deliberations. Kyoto’s proponents, at best, are trying to make lemonade out of lemons and avoid the embarrassment of not having delivered anything of substance in Montreal. Beats MOPing around until Nairobi next year. What Others Are Saying About Montreal… and Beyond – Peter Kammerer, “It’s all global yawning to me,” South China Morning Post, December 9, 2005: Excuse my glazed eyes and bored expression, but I have just been reading about the United Nations’ climate change conference in Canada. My conclusion is that although no one knows why we yawn, there is a good probability that it has something to do with global warming. I am no scientist, so whatever I am about to say should be taken with a pinch of sarcasm. Nonetheless, try this test: look at the person sitting nearest to you, stare into their eyes and say, clearly and succinctly, “Global warming”. Then yawn. The yawn is guaranteed to be returned – proving my point. … The two-week meeting in Montreal was the first annual UN climate conference since the 1997 Kyoto Protocol to curb global warming took effect last February. The talks in Canada featured the usual unsuccessful efforts to get the same two nations, the US and Australia, to sign up. They claim that industrial growth would be stifled by promising to reduce emissions of gases, like carbon dioxide, to an average of 5 per cent below 1990 levels by 2012. Instead, they have embarked on their own series of conferences, starting with the inaugural meeting of the six-nation Asia-Pacific Partnership on Clean Development and Climate in Sydney, next month. US President George W. Bush’s administration says that when it comes to cutting back on pollution, it prefers to deal with other governments on a one-to-one and regional basis, through voluntary approaches and in financing new energy-saving technologies. There will be talks and more talks to iron out the details, it says. The thought of two rival sets of meetings, summits and conferences on climate change gives me this twitching feeling at the back of my throat. I don’t know what is causing it, but I suspect a yawn is coming on. – Bronwen Maddox, “Trail goes cold in search for climate deal,” The Times [London], December 9, 2005: The Montreal conference on global warming looks like ending tonight with no big agreement: nothing approaching the status of the Kyoto Protocol, and possibly nothing at all. That is not a tragedy. It is more like a success. One of the fortnight’s achievements is to have drawn attention to the difficulty of enforcing the Kyoto Protocol itself, never mind drafting a successor, given that so many countries are on course to breach it by an extravagant margin. It has also been useful to have spent time discussing other, less restrictive kinds of regional treaty and industrial targets which might be tolerable to the United States, India, China and Brazil. The pity is that this may be drowned out by the storm of righteous accusations directed, inevitably, at the US above all. – “Don’t despair – Don’t despair; Global warming,” The Economist, December 10, 2005: …But the holes in the [Kyoto] treaty are so huge—America didn’t sign up, and developing countries do not have targets—that even with Kyoto in place, at their current rate of increase, global emissions look like increasing by 50% between now and 2030. In consequence, the global environment ministers’ meeting in Montreal this week to discuss better ways of implementing Kyoto was a rather cheerless affair. As The Economist went to press, there was some discussion of whether America would deliver a last-minute concession; but nobody expected much of real substance to come out of the meeting. … . – “Changing science; Climatology,” The Economist, December 10, 2005: As delegates from around the world meet in Montreal to discuss climate change, what science should inform their deliberations? The climate changes. It always has done and it always will. In the past 2m years the temperature has gone up and down like a yo-yo as ice ages have alternated with warmer interglacial periods. Reflecting this on a smaller scale, the 10,000 years or so since the glaciers last went into full-scale retreat have seen periods of relative cooling and warmth lasting from decades to centuries. Against such a noisy background, it is hard to detect the signal from any changes caused by humanity’s increased economic activity, and consequent release of atmosphere-warming greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide.…[T]here are still a number of uncertainties. For instance, the solar hypothesis is not yet dead. A few researchers who agree the data show a warming trend nevertheless argue that this may be caused not by man but by nature, in the form of minute increases in the sun’s heat output. That output is known to vary during the course of the 11-year sunspot cycle, as well as over the longer term, and although such changes have not been matched to temperature changes in the way that rises in the level of greenhouse gases have been, they may still be making a contribution. Another issue is that a second type of pollutant, aerosols such as the minute sulphate particles that form when sulphurous fuel is burned, promote the formation of clouds. These reflect sunlight away from Earth and thus oppose the effect of greenhouse gases. Some have seen this as a possible counterbalance and, indeed, such “dimming” has been noticed in several parts of the world. However, yet another study published this year suggests the dimming is going away as anti-sulphur pollution-control measures kick in. Perhaps the most important uncertainty, though, is that caused by a lack of enough good-quality, long-term, internally consistent data. Even the industrialised parts of the world, Europe and North America and their adjacent seas, have been studied properly for only a century and a half. Too much climate science relies on drawing conclusions from patchy information. It is therefore a nice irony that only under the presidency of George Bush, the bête-noire-in-chief of many environmentalists, has a unified Earth Observation System of satellites, ocean buoys, terrestrial weather stations, balloons and aircraft started to take shape. Though the system involves some 60 countries, the moving spirit is America’s National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.