The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is scheduled to make a final decision on proposed revisions in particulate matter air quality standards by September 27, 2006. The process by which EPA scientifically evaluates its national ambient air quality decision is spelled out in the Clean Air Act. During the latest national ambient air quality standards review, however, the process being used has become a controversial issue.
FACT: The EPA is planning on issuing its final rule on particulate matter air quality standards without an opportunity for public review of how the agency is assessing recent scientific studies dealing with PM.
The EPA had a cutoff date of April 2002 for studies dealing with the health effects of PM during the current review, with the exception of a few hand-picked studies. Only after pressure from Senator Inhofe, who wrote a letter in 2005 to EPA Administrator Stephen Johnson noting the dearth of newer scientific studies on particulate matter, did the EPA begin to review newer studies.
“I am not aware of any precedent for ignoring advancements in scientific knowledge over such a lengthy period of time, especially involving decisions that affect public health.” Senator Inhofe wrote in the 2005 letter.
In response to the Senator’s letter, the EPA has reviewed more recent scientific studies and has indicated it will factor in these studies in its final rule. But EPA plans to issue the final rule on selecting appropriate PM standards without allowing public review of how it is assessing those newer studies.
A new report by the Government Accountability Office (GAO), entitled “Human Health Risk Assessment: EPA Has Taken Steps to Strengthen Its Process, but Improvements Needed in Planning, Data Development, and Training”, found additional problems in EPA’s process in the current review.
The GAO report recommended that the EPA improve its use of science in conducting risk assessments. One of Senator Inhofe’s top three priorities since he assumed the Chairmanship has been to improve EPA’s use of science. It is clear from the manner in which EPA has conducted the current PM review that this goal is far from complete.