Posted by Matt Dempsey (matthew_dempsey@epw.senate.gov (10:20am ET)
Updated with media coverage: John Tierney March 3 blog post: Global-Warming Skeptics Convene in N.Y. Andrew Revkin’s March 2 New York Times Article: Skeptics on Human Climate Impact Seize on Cold Spell; Andrew Revkin’s March 1, 2008: Cold Weather in a Warming Climate; Newsbusters: Is Winter 2008 Making Climate Alarmists Question Global Warming?; Thomas Sowell, Feb 29, Cold Water on ‘Global Warming’
Hundreds of skeptics of man-made global warming are gathering at a conference this week in New York City to “focus on issues and questions not answered by advocates of the theory of man-made global warming.” The Heartland Institute, the sponsor of the conference, states on their website:
“The 2008 International Conference on Climate Change is the first major international conference to focus on issues and questions not answered by advocates of the theory of man-made global warming. Hundreds of scientists, economists, and public policy experts from around the world will gather on March 2-4, 2008, at the Marriott New York Marquis Hotel on Manhattan’s Time Square, to call attention to widespread dissent in the scientific community to the alleged ‘consensus’ that the modern warming is primarily man-made and is a crisis.”
New York Times columnist John Tierney previews the conference this morning in a blog post titled, Global-Warming Skeptics Convene in N.Y.:
"Hundreds of skeptics in the global-warming debate are convening in New York today and tomorrow. The meeting, sponsored by the Heartland Institute, is an assortment of climate scientists, economists and free-market think-tankers — some who have impressive credentials, some of whom are listed in the conference program simply as ‘Scientist” or “Meteorologist.’ Sorting out the wheat from the chaff will not be easy, but here’s one way to start: Check out this report being presented at the conference today. It’s a critique of the report last year from the United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. This new report, which accuses the I.P.C.C. of “errors and misstatements,” is from a group of scientists calling itself the N.I.P.C.C. — the Nongovernmental International Panel on Climate Change. The report was edited by S. Fred Singer, a professor emeritus of environmental sciences at the University of Virginia. It comes with an introduction from Frederick Seitz, a physicist and past president of the National Academy of Sciences and of Rockefeller University, who writes that the report shows “we do not currently have any convincing evidence or observations of significant climate change from other than natural causes.” That conclusion, of course, is hardly the majority view among scientists who study this issue. But what, specifically, is wrong in this new report? What’s right in it? I welcome substantive comments — by which I don’t mean denunciations of “deniers” or “ecoNazis,” or lazy ad hominem attacks and conspiracy theories about who’s being paid off by whom. Let’s stick to the science, or lack thereof, in this particular critique. There are plenty of specific claims and charts to analyze. Have the authors identified genuine problems in the I.P.C.C. report, or are they cherry-picking data?"
Also covering the conference in New York is the Times’ environmental reporter Andrew Revkin. Previewing the conference in a March 2 Sunday article, Skeptics on Human Climate Impact Seize on Cold Spell, Revkin highlights a blog entry posted on the Inhofe EPW Press Blog as his lead. Revkin begins:
“The world has seen some extraordinary winter conditions in both hemispheres over the past year: snow in Johannesburg last June and in Baghdad in January, Arctic sea ice returning with a vengeance after a record retreat last summer, paralyzing blizzards in China, and a sharp drop in the globe’s average temperature. It is no wonder that some scientists, opinion writers, political operatives and other people who challenge warnings about dangerous human-caused global warming have jumped on this as a teachable moment. ‘Earth’s ‘Fever’ Breaks: Global COOLING Currently Under Way,’ read a blog post and news release on Wednesday from Marc Morano, the communications director for the Republican minority on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee. So what is happening?”
Revkin then goes on to discuss the Heartland Institute conference:
“More clucking about the cold is likely over the next several days. The Heartland Institute, a public policy research group in Chicago opposed to regulatory approaches to environmental problems, is holding a conference in Times Square on Monday and Tuesday aimed at exploring questions about the cause and dangers of climate change. The event will convene an array of scientists, economists, statisticians and libertarian commentators holding a dizzying range of views on the changing climate — from those who see a human influence but think it is not dangerous, to others who say global warming is a hoax, the sun’s fault or beneficial. Many attendees say it is the dawn of a new paradigm.”
Senator Inhofe’s EPW Committee Communications Director Marc Morano is a participant at the conference and will be blogging about the conference over the next couple of days. Check back at the Inhofe EPW Press blog [ www.epw.senate.gov/inhofeblog ] for Marc’s blogs as well as additional media coverage of the conference.