Posted by Matt Dempsey matthew_dempsey@epw.senate.gov (3:24pm ET)
TURNING ESA INTO GLOBAL WARMING POLICY
EPW Hearing Reveals Special Interests Motivations Behind Listing the Polar Bear
“If the
polar bear is listed, the ESA [Endangered Species Act] will become a climate
change law,” writes
Senator John Barrasso in an excellent blog post on The
Hill’s Congress Blog. The result, Senator Barrasso warns, means that
“…anything thought to contribute to global warming could be shut down — even in
Wyoming.”
Amazingly, these efforts come as
worldwide
polar bear population numbers are at or near all-time highs, especially in
comparison to 40-50 years ago. A majority of populations are considered
stable and some are
increasing.
Yet turning
ESA into climate change law is exactly what Democrats and their liberal special
interest allies have in mind, as revealed during the April 2, 2008 Senate
Environment and Public Works hearing on listing the polar bear under ESA. The
implications of such a policy would lead to drastic increase in litigation and
anxious “creative” lawyers ready to find ways to shut down energy production.
William P.
Horn, former Assistant Secretary of the
Interior for Fish, Wildlife and Parks in 1985-1988 (responsible
for the ESA program) and with
experience serving on the Board of Environmental Sciences and
Toxicology of the National Academy of Sciences, addressed these ramifications of
turning ESA into a global warming law, stating at the hearing:
“Does someone go to court and say a
locality, by allowing activities that produce greenhouse gas emissions, is
therefore causing arctic sea ice to melt harming the polar bear, i.e. taking the
polar bear, is that local government now culpable under the ESA for allowing
that activity to go on. We’ve got 4 or 5 precedents along that line that I
would anticipate “creative” attorneys to take and run
with….
“If the Service has to consider all of
these things and if emissions and their cumulative impact are causing climate
change which is causing sea ice melting, which is in turn harming the bears, the
FWS is going to be obligated to consult on virtually every activity that results
in greenhouse gas emissions.”
Senator Inhofe, concerned about these
tremendous implications, asked Mr. Horn to comment further about how the FWS
could establish a link between greenhouse gas emissions in one part of the
country –say Oklahoma or Wyoming – and relate it to any impact on polar bears in
Alaska. Here
is the exchange:
Senator
Inhofe: Based on
your experience, do you agree that it will be difficult to legitimately
establish links between greenhouse gas emissions in one part of the country to
effects on a single polar bear population, maybe in Alaska?
Mr.
Horn: Someone
comes in to build a particular new highway interchange in some location….How
does it [FWS] determine that the emission attributable to that highway project
are the ones that are essentially causing the sea ice to melt, and how do you
make that connection? Can you even, is that connection even capable of being
made and is the FWS the agency to do that. I think the answer is no.”
Sen.
Inhofe: My
concern would be that there are activist judges that would be trying to force
this, this link. Do you agree with that?
Mr.
Horn: Yes.
Kassie R. Siegel with the Center for Biological
Diversity, asked to address this point head on by Senator Barrasso during the
hearing, did her best to come up with a “creative” answer.
Sen.
Barrasso: Could you a little bit address some of these issues
about emissions under Section 7? Is it the intention of your organization, if
there is going to be a coal-fired power plant planning to be constructed
someplace, if the polar bear is listed, that then you would say, ‘well, we need
to use all of our legal abilities to attempt to block that construction?’
Ms.
Seigel: It is extremely important that the FWS carry out the
Section 7 consultation process in order to protect polar bears…We also believe,
however, that the FWS has to address the fundamental problem here, which is
greenhouse gas emissions, and that the Section 7 consultation process is the
appropriate venue to do that for major sources of greenhouse gas emissions….We
think the section 7 of the ESA is part of the solution and has an important role
to play.
Sen.
Barrasso: That was a creative answer, but I’ll take it as a
YES.
These groups also made it clear they want to use the
polar bear to stop oil and natural gas production, not only in Alaska but wherever it
occurs.
Ms.
Seigel: I would like to note that while global warming is the
primary threat to polar bears, they are threatened by other things as well, such
as oil and gas development….Section 7 will clearly be very successful in
addressing other threats to polar bears.”
Furthermore, in comments filed with the Fish and
Wildlife Service, Greenpeace and the CBD urged the Service to force
greenhouse-gas-emitting projects, even those not in Alaska, to account for
potential affects on the bear before they can go forward. They write,
“It is simply not possible to fully discuss the threat to
the polar bear from global warming without…regulatory mechanisms to address
greenhouse gas emissions.”
The revelation by Ms. Seigel and other
liberal special interest groups of their intent to use ESA to shut down all
energy development lead Senator Craig (R-ID) to remark, “But as a father and a
grandfather, I, too, am passionately concerned that we make our public policy
work, and we don’t attempt to use some [policy] as a surrogate and a block for
others.”