Posted by Matt Dempsey matthew_dempsey@epw.senate.gov (11:30am ET)

Democrats’ Inconvenient Gas Price Problem

 

EPA Analysis Projects Climate Bill Will Raise Gas Prices 53
Cents Per Gallon

 
The news media finally appears to get it when it comes to
global warming cap-and-trade legislation. The environmental trade publication
Greenwire ran an article written by Ben Geman on April 23, with the title
asking the excellent question, “Should lawmakers pushing global warming
legislation want high gas prices?” (LINK – Subscription
required) The article correctly noted, “Most experts agree that placing a price
on carbon dioxide — either through a tax or a cap-and-trade program — will
create new costs for consumers.” [Also see: Is
the Media’s Environmental Reporting Improving?
]

The article continued: “A U.S. EPA analysis of the
Lieberman-Warner bill last month projects significant increases in consumer
power and gasoline costs, with the latter increasing about 53 cents per gallon
in 2030 and $1.40 per gallon in 2050, though EPA did not study in detail a
recent law that increases auto mileage standards and expands the national
biofuels mandate.”

As record gas, energy, and food prices continue to soar and
American families continue to face growing anxiety over an economic downturn,
the costly and symbolic Lieberman-Warner global warming cap-and-trade bill is
set to debut on the U.S. Senate floor in June. With the U.S. acting
unilaterally, the bill will not have a detectable impact on the global
temperatures, but it will (as correctly noted in the Greenwire article) have a
very detectable impact on gas and energy prices for already suffering
Americans.

As more and more elected leaders join the chorus to call for
some type of relief at the pump, Greenwire asks a rather inconvenient question.
“If curbing greenhouse gases — and fast — is needed to stave off the worst
effects of global warming, are high fuel costs such a bad thing?”

Senate Environment and Public Works Chairwoman Barbara Boxer
(D-Calif.) weighed in, "As far as I’m concerned there is no silver lining
to high gas prices." Democratic Senator Frank Lautenberg (N.J.) claimed
the question was not fair. “That is kind of perverse thinking in my point of
view," Lautenberg said "High gas prices are punitive for the entire
population, but particularly on the more modest income earner. That is not a
way to drive a positive point of view,” Lautenberg added.

But “punitive” costs on lower income families and those with
fixed incomes is exactly what the Lieberman-Warner and cap-and-trade approach
is all about. A November 2007 report from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO)
warned cap-and-trade energy "price increases would disproportionately
affect people at the lower end of the income scale." (LINK)

In March, Roy Innis, chairman of one of America’s
oldest civil rights groups, the Congress of Racial Equality, warned that
mandated carbon controls like those advocated by Lieberman-Warner bill would
disproportionally impact minorities.

“We are slowly destroying the energy system we have, and we
are promoting an expensive, environmentally harmful, illusory energy system
that exists only in theory and environmental rhetoric,” Innis said on March 19.
“Worst of all, we are harming our poorest families; we are rolling back the
civil rights we struggled so long and hard to achieve; and we are sending many
minorities to the back of the energy and economic bus. This must not, and
cannot continue,” Innis, the author of the new book Energy
Keepers Energy Killers: The New Civil Rights Battle
, said. (LINK)

“These policies cause widespread layoffs, leaving unemployed
workers and families struggling to survive, as the cost of everything they eat,
drive, wear and do spirals out of control,” Innis said on April 22, 2008. (LINK)

An April 23 article in Roll Call, noted how many Senators
“remain opposed to major cap-and-trade legislation that they describe as a
massive tax increase that will send jobs overseas and hit families with higher
costs.”

Senator George Voinovich (R-Ohio) was blunt about the impact
of proposed cap-and-trade legislation on states with an already shrinking
manufacturing base. “It’ll kill us. Are you kidding me?” Voinovich said. “But
let’s not do something that makes us kill our economy and does not have any
real impact,” Voinovich added.

“I don’t think the science is there yet,” said Senator Tom
Coburn (R-Okla.). “Cap-and-trade is a tax increase.” The article reported that
“Coburn complained that the Lieberman-Warner cap-and-trade bill has so many
carve-outs, ‘they bought off everyone.’”

“All we need is two or three more years of not doing
something stupid and the science will regain the debate instead of the
political activists, and we’ll have policies based on science and not emotion,”
Coburn added.

 
Read More:

National Review Online

Pelosi Premium Pain
Democrats want more expensive energy.

By David Freddoso

Link to Article 

House Republicans sent out an email to celebrate the second
anniversary of Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s (D., Calif.) promise that she had a
“common-sense plan” to reduce gasoline prices — details of which she has yet to
release. Their release included the gory details on how today’s fossil-fuel
prices compare to those of two years ago: a barrel of crude oil up to $117 from
$64; heating oil at $3.31 per gallon, up from $2.71; gasoline up to $3.56 a
gallon from $2.96 (remember when we used to complain about gas flirting with
the $3 mark?); and diesel fuel up to $4.14 from $2.87 per gallon.

Republicans have taken to calling this phenomenon the “Pelosi Premium.”

Now that may be unfair: Party control of the Congress (or the White House, for
that matter) has very little to do with short-term oil and gasoline prices. The
big factors today, for instance, are a weak dollar and surging demand for
petroleum in emerging markets like India
and China.

Still, it hasn’t helped that Democrats have routinely blocked oil exploration
on public lands. President Clinton’s 1995 veto of a bill allowing drilling in
the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge in 1995 is probably now costing us about a
million barrels of oil per day. In 2006, Pelosi’s Senate Democrats blocked an
effort to drill the Outer Continental Shelf for what the Department of the
Interior estimates to be 8.5 billion barrels of known oil reserves and 86
billion barrels undiscovered.

All that said, the real problem — and the reason Pelosi really does deserve
blame — is that Democrats’ political goal of reducing carbon emissions continues
to trump their populist rhetoric on gasoline prices. The two stances are
impossible to reconcile. Try as they might to blame oil companies for the pain
Americans feel at the pump, Democrats want higher prices for gasoline — and for
all forms of energy that emit carbon. Economic barriers against CO2 emissions
are a requirement for environmental progress in the Democrats’ view, and this
is the entire purpose of the carbon cap-and-trade system they will put before
the House this summer — to create economic disincentives for emitting CO2.

Last summer, Senate Environment and Public Works Chairwoman Barbara Boxer (D.,
Calif.) said
as much
in a conference call with reporters and environmental groups. Her
exact words were:

[E]veryone has told us, including business leaders, that to
drive the investment in these technologies that are going to solve our
global-warming challenge, we need to have clear limits on carbon pollution.

Democrats know that business leaders will be unwilling to
invest in other technologies as long as hydrocarbon fuels remain the best
economic option to power their industries. Even with oil prices at their
current levels, investors view other approaches as money-losers. Therefore, we
must raise the price of fossil fuels in order to make clean alternatives
competitive.

According to the Department of Energy, transportation accounts for about
one-third of U.S.
carbon emissions. Therefore, higher gasoline and diesel prices are a vital part
of any serious emissions-reduction program. It hardly matters whether the
higher prices come through an excise tax (which benefits the Treasury), a
carbon cap-and-trade system that hits oil producers (which benefits
companies as General Electric), a dramatic increase in world demand for
petroleum (which benefits oil companies), a weak dollar (which benefits
exporters) or even conspiratorial price-gouging. Each of these five phenomena
has the same effect: each raises an economic barrier against the emission of
carbon dioxide. And each does so at your expense, because the costs are inevitably
passed along.

High gas prices are bad for the economy, but the point here is not to make
moral judgments about the trade-off between high gasoline prices and reduced
carbon emissions. The point is that Democrats have taken a dishonest public
stance with false promises of lower gasoline prices that they never intended to
honor. Democrats are shedding crocodile tears for the end consumer of
petroleum. If they say they hate to see you eaten alive by Big Oil, it is only
because they would prefer to devour you themselves.

Without any government intervention, high oil and gasoline prices are already
prompting Americans to conserve energy and providing greater incentive at the
margin for investment in alternative sources of energy. A new government report
from the Department of Energy this month shows that gasoline use is actually
down 0.2 percent so far this year — the first such decrease since 1991, and
good news if you worry about carbon emissions. Normally, gasoline consumption
rises each year with the number of cars on the road, but high gas prices are
clearly having a positive environmental effect. This summer, when prices rise
still higher, so will the barriers to fossil-fuel pollution and incentives to
conserve oil and to invest in new technologies.

If “greedy oil companies” are indeed to blame for the current high prices,
Democrats should thank them for saving the planet instead of cynically (and
absurdly) scolding them for “price-gouging” in an attempt to deceive voters. It
makes little difference to your bottom line, to the economy, or to the
environment whether you are shaken down by carbon taxes and regulations or by
an oil producer. The end result is the same — less atmospheric carbon dioxide.

Curbing carbon requires economic pain. You can judge for yourself whether that
will lead to environmental progress. In the meantime, we ought to drop the
pretense that Democrats have or ever had plans to give Americans cheaper
gasoline.