Posted by matthew_dempsey@epw.senate.gov (2:56 ET)
Lieberman-Warner Debate Just Two Weeks Away
New Inhofe White Paper, Web Page Detail Harmful
Impacts of Lieberman-Warner Bill
Link
to White Paper
Link
to Lieberman-Warner Climate Bill Exposed: www.epw.senate.gov/lieberman-warnerbillexposed
In
just two weeks, the United States Senate will consider global warming
cap-and-trade legislation before the United States Senate that, if passed,
would drastically increase energy costs at the gas pump, in the grocery store,
and in our homes – all for no environmental gain. Yet despite the enormous
financial burden this bill would impose on American families and American
workers, the Senate has yet to fully examine this bill. To help facilitate the
debate and provide information to the American people about the severe economic
ramifications of this bill, Senator Inhofe announced yesterday, May 15, 2008,
the release of an EPW Committee minority white paper incorporating all of the
most recent government and private group sector economic analyses of the bill.
In addition, Senator Inhofe also announced the launch of a new webpage ( www.epw.senate.gov/lieberman-warnerbillexposed )on the minority portion of the EPW Committee
website that now serves as a central hub for all information exposing the flaws of
the Lieberman-Warner bill.
The
page will be updated frequently over the next two weeks and throughout
consideration of the bill. A sampling of the latest news now included on the
new web page is included below:
Platts: US
Senate Republicans continue offensive against climate bill (5/15/08): Excerpt: US Senate Republicans
Thursday sought to preempt upcoming floor debate on the leading climate bill as
the top Republican on the Environment and Public Works committee released a
white paper saying the measure was too costly. The senator, Oklahoma Republican
James Inhofe, used a series of recent government and private analyses pointing
to heavy economic dislocation and a severe reduction in projected economic
growth if lawmakers approve the carbon-cap bill as-is. "This legislation
will cripple the national economy while destroying jobs and raising
electricity, heating and gas costs to every single family in the country,"
Inhofe’s paper said. The senator added that the poor would be hurt the
most…Inhofe is known as one of the most vocal manmade climate change skeptics
in Congress. He will lead Republicans on the chamber floor when the bill debate
begins June 2. He also created an extension of the committee web site to
criticize the bill. The white paper builds on one of Inhofe’s most frequent
arguments – that the bill would do little to stop emissions from rising in
rapidly industrializing countries like China. Inhofe argued that millions
of jobs lost in the US
because of rising energy costs would be shipped overseas to countries with no
emissions cap. The Energy Information Administration recently predicted that
economic growth would be 0.2% to 0.6% less than anticipated levels by 2030, a
cumulative $444 billion to $1.3 trillion of lost growth potential. Opponents of
the bill point to studies from the EIA and others indicating that the system
would hit the coal industry severely while boosting more expensive nuclear
power, natural gas and renewable resources. Inhofe questioned the feasibility
of building new nuclear power plants as well as coal-fired power plants with
carbon capture and storage, something he believes is further away from
commercialization than many people hope. Instead, the US should have
a voluntary policy based on technological development with tax incentives,
Inhofe said. "That path involves investment incentives to energy
efficiency, well-funded research and development and an open mind about all
sources of electric generation including nuclear and the further exploration of
natural gas," the white paper said.
BNA:
Inhofe
Warns of Skyrocketing Energy Costs, Economic Impacts of Lieberman-Warner Bill
(5/16/08): Excerpt: With Senate debate over a proposal to cap U.S. greenhouse
gas emissions only weeks away, the Senate Environment and Public Works
Committee’s top Republican May 15 issued a detailed policy paper warning that
the measure would trigger increased energy costs and devastate an already
struggling U.S. economy. The Senate bill
(S. 2191), which would put mandatory limits on emissions through 2050,
"would drastically increase the already skyrocketing cost of energy at the
pump and in our homes as well as cost millions of American jobs–all for no
environmental gain," Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.) said in a press
statement. "Yet despite the enormous financial burden this bill would
impose on American families and American workers, the Senate has yet to fully
examine and debate this bill," the committee’s ranking Republican said.
Inhofe, perhaps the Senate’s leading climate skeptic, has long questioned the
validity of research linking the burning of oil, coal, and other fossil fuels
to global warming. He is expected to lead the effort to defeat the bill, which
is slated for debate on the Senate floor June 2. The bill, introduced in
October 2007 by Sens. Joseph Lieberman (I/D-Conn.) and John Warner (R-Va.),
would result in an "American-only cap-and-trade system" doomed to
failure, "with environmental symbolism bringing no benefits at an enormous
cost," according to the Inhofe paper, The Economics of America’s
Climate Security Act of 2007 (S. 2191, Lieberman-Warner Climate Bill). The
senator also announced the launching of a website, http://www.epw.senate.gov/lieberman-warnerbillexposed,
that he said would act as an "online resource center that will serve as a
central hub" for "exposing the flaws" of the Lieberman-Warner
bill as it heads to the Senate floor.
INVESTOR’S
BUSINESS DAILY: Cap-And-Trade
Folly (May 15, 2008): Excerpt: But they have politics to think about, as well as
invitations to Georgetown cocktail parties that probably are not being sent to
GOP Oklahoma Sen. James Inhofe, who in his skepticism of global warming
is performing a valuable public service
[…] It’s no surprise that the most expensive of the three is the
Warner-Lieberman bill. The Environmental Protection Agency reckons it could
cost as much as $3 trillion a year in lost GDP. In an economy of roughly $14
trillion, that’s a significant loss. But even the Bingaman-Specter legislation,
the least costly of the three, would hit the economy for about $1 trillion a
year. Much of the pain would be caused by increases in gasoline and electricity
prices. The Science Applications International Corporation calculates that
Lieberman-Warner by 2030 would boost gasoline prices from 60% to 144% while
electricity prices would be up 77% to 129%.Hit hardest by higher energy prices:
The poor. The National
Center for Policy
Analysis points out that energy costs consume 15% of the poorest households’
income while the average household spends 3% on energy. Who is going to feel
the pinch more? The Congressional Budget Office estimates that even a 15%
reduction in carbon emissions by 2010 — a third of the cut required by
Lieberman-Warner — through a cap-and-trade scheme would trim the disposable
income of the poor by an additional 3.3%. The hit for the richest Americans:
1.7%.All this economic wreckage done in the name of reducing environmentally
benign greenhouse gases by men who should know better — and likely do.
CQ: Nuclear
Power Still a Sticking Point for Senate’s Climate Change Bill (5/13/08): Excerpt:
Senators who are rewriting a global warming measure may decide to leave a
contentious issue — how to treat nuclear power — out of their latest version of
the legislation. With the Senate gearing up for debate in June on the climate
change bill (S 2191), sponsors are working on a substitute amendment that
probably will include significant changes intended to secure the 60 votes
needed to overcome a likely filibuster. One priority for several Republican
senators is to offer incentives for the development of more nuclear power
plants, which do not emit greenhouse gases. In a speech Monday on the campaign
trail, Sen. John McCain of Arizona,
the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, cited the importance of
nuclear power in dealing with climate change. But many environmental groups
object, citing the potential risks of nuclear plants and the difficulty of
disposing of the high-level radioactive waste they produce.Environmentalists
have a powerful ally in Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., who chairs the Environment and
Public Works Committee, which approved the bill in December without any
specific incentives for nuclear power. Boxer said that the nuclear issue may be
resolved on the floor, rather than in the upcoming substitute language. “I
think most of that should probably be done by amendment,” she said. That could
pose political risks of its own, if proponents of nuclear power win adoption of
an amendment that some Democrats could not support. Boxer pledged earlier this year
that she would pull the bill from the floor if the Senate adopted any
amendments that “weakened” the bill.
Washington
Times: Senate
climate bill to cut ’emissions per capita, to 19th-century levels’
(May 16, 2008): Excerpt: The Climate
Security Act, sponsored by Joe Lieberman and John Warner, would cut emissions
of carbon dioxide — the main "global warming" gas — by 66 percent
over the next 42 years. With expected population growth, this means about a 90
percent drop in emissions per capita, to 19th-century levels. Other regulatory
dictates are similarly unjustified. The Justice Department has ruled that the
Interior Department has until May 15 to decide whether or not to list the polar
bear as an endangered species. Pressure to pass impossible-to-achieve
legislation, like Lieberman-Warner, or grandstanding political stunts, like
calling polar bears an "endangered species" even when they are at
near record-high population levels, are based upon projections of rapid and
persistent global warming.
Business
& Media Institute: Senators
Inhofe, Sessions blast massive costs of global warming legislation
(May 15, 2008): Excerpt: Oil is trading at
record levels, in excess of $120 a barrel. Leading Republican Sens. James
Inhofe (Okla.) and Jeff Sessions (Ala.) both told the
Business & Media Institute (BMI) energy prices would drastically increase
if the Lieberman-Warner Climate Security Act (S. 2191) is signed into law. “The studies show it would be directly
affected, would be a $1.50 a gallon, in addition to what it is today,” Inhofe,
the ranking Republican on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee,
said to (BMI). […] Sessions, a member of
the Senate’s Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, went a step further. He
cited sources that suggest the increase could be as much as $5 a gallon. “[L]et me tell you what’s heading down the tracks,”
Sessions said to BMI on May 14. “In a few weeks, we expect that the
cap-and-trade legislation that’s been voted out of Sen. Barbara Boxer’s
(D-Calif.) Environment and Public Works Committee will be on the floor and
according to the Environmental Protection Agency it will increase gas prices by
$1.50. The National Association of Manufacturers says it will increase it as
much as $5 per gallon.” Sessions proposed that money should be spent on energy
investment versus a regulatory bureaucracy to enforce the provisions of the
Lieberman-Warner bill.
WorldNetDaily: Climate-control
absurdity (May 15, 2008) Excerpt: Think energy is expensive now? Wait until
Congress plugs in the "Climate Security Act of 2007." That’s the
leading piece of legislation on Capitol Hill designed to combat "climate
change." Lawmakers have cooked up an expensive solution to a hyped-up
rallying cry against a "problem" that scientists can’t even agree
exists in the first place. Of course, Congress is doing what Congress seems to
do best – pass laws in response to the latest craze. In this case, if the
politicians are successful, you may find yourself nostalgic for the days of
$3.60 gasoline. And that would be only the start. The overall economic costs
could be staggering. Economists at The Heritage Foundation rolled up their
sleeves and got under the hood of current proposal. They’ve run the numbers –
and what they found will make all Americans want to buckle up. If the Climate
Security Act becomes law, it would thrust our economy downhill in a hurry.
[…] So how would Lieberman-Warner affect
our economy? Start with something we can all relate to: personal income. Under
the bill, income in the U.S.
would drop significantly, starting in 2012, from a decline of more than $30
billion that year to $121.9 billion in 2016. Or, to put it another way: All
other things being equal, by 2016, the annual household income for a family of
four would fall by $1,494 – about what that family pays now for two months of
food. Gross domestic product would start to take a nosedive in 2012 as well. By
2030, GDP would be $436 billion less than it would be if the bill hadn’t become
law. Energy prices would spike, too. Heating oil would go from $2,120 annually
per household in 2012 to $2,728 by 2030. Over the same period, electricity
would rise from $1,213 per year to $1,860, and natural gas would go from $1,090
to $1,393. By 2030, the Heritage researchers write, "the total energy bill
for the average American consumer has gone up $8,870." How would
Lieberman-Warner affect employment? The Heritage analysis shows that annual job
losses exceed 500,000 before 2030 and could approach 1 million. Factory jobs
would decline sharply; we’d lose 2.3 million jobs in durable-goods
manufacturing in 2029 as the changes forced the economy rapidly away from that
sector.
National
Association of Manufacturers: The
Consequences of Lieberman-Warner ( May 13, 2008 ): Excerpt: Various groups and government bodies,
working independently of one another, have examined the bill’s potential
consequences and reach similar conclusions: With its emission limits and
injection of government control into the marketplace, Lieberman-Warner imposes
dramatic economic costs. We’d say it wreaks havoc.
Björn
Lomborg: Global
warming – Money for Nothing (May 13, 2008): Excerpt: When it comes to
global warming, we have plenty of hot rhetoric but very little cool reason.
This matters immensely, because the Kyoto protocol is already among the most
expensive global public policies ever enacted, and the follow up in Copenhagen
in late 2009 promises to break all records. We better get it right, but right
now we’re more likely to pay for virtually nothing. A good example is the
European Union’s newly instituted policy of cutting CO2 emissions by 20% by
2020. Of course, it is always easier to promise than to deliver – a concern
that is especially relevant in the EU. Yet, even if the promise is kept, will
the benefit outweigh the cost? Curiously, but not surprisingly, this is not
discussed very much. A 20% reduction in the EU’s CO2 emissions, vigorously
enforced throughout this century, would merely postpone temperature increases
due to global warming by two years at the end of the century, from 2100 to 2102
– a negligible change. Yet the cost would be anything but negligible. The EU’s
own estimate is about €60 billion annually, which is almost certainly a vast
underestimate (its previous estimate was almost twice as much), since it
requires the EU to make the reductions in the smartest way possible. […]
The same money could triple the global development aid budget. It could easily
provide clean drinking water, sanitation, education, and healthcare to every
human being on the planet, while increasing CO2-reducing R&D 10-fold. The
EU’s goal of a 20% reduction by 2020 is an incredibly expensive way to signal
good intentions. But wouldn’t we rather do real good? The EU believes it is
showing the way, but if the world follows the Union, it seems that we are more
likely simply to become lost.
CNBC:
Report: EU risks missing
Kyoto targets, goals unrealistic (May 14, 2008):
Chief Executive Officer Bernotat said the European Union will probably not meet
the 2012 carbon dioxide emission targets of the Kyoto Protocol because
consumers are using too much energy, Die Zeit reported. Bernotat said in an
interview with the weekly newspaper he is sceptical that the German
government’s longer-term emission target of one-quarter of energy consumption
coming from renewable sources by 2020 can be met. The projected annual increase
in energy efficiency of 3 percent contrasts with a current improvement rate of
0.8 percent, he said in the interview to be published Thursday. The CEO also
expressed doubt that 15,000 MW of off-shore wind power capacity can be erected
by 2020, which is also part of the government plan. E.ON, Germany’s largest
utility, has internal plans to increase the share of energy coming from
renewable sources to one quarter by 2030, Bernotat said. ludwig.burger@thomsonreuters.com
lb/kf1 COPYRIGHT Copyright Thomson Financial News Limited 2008.
Rightsidenews: Another
look at Carbon Credits and Cap and Trade Costs (May 15, 2008): Excerpt: According to the respected National Center
for Policy Analysis (NCPA): "Cap-and-trade proposals advocated by the
three candidates and under consideration in Congress would harm the U.S.
economy, disproportionately hurt the poor and fail to produce promised
environmental benefits. Cap-and-trade policies place a limit, or cap, on
greenhouse gas emissions but allow companies and industries that fall below
those limits to sell or trade remaining emissions to those that exceed their
limits." The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has said": "The
potential market value of those emissions could reach $300 billion per year by
2020." Furthermore, the CBO estimates that even if cap-and-trade proposals
reduce emissions 15 percent by 2010 (and there are a growing number of
scientists who dispute claims that reducing carbon dioxide emissions would have
any benefit at all), it would reduce the disposable income of lower-income
Americans by 3.3 percent compared to only 1.7 percent for the richest
Americans. NCPA Senior Fellow H. Sterling Burnett, co-author of the NCPA
analysis, has predicted "Cap-and-trade bills will substantially raise
prices for gasoline and electricity, inflict severe economic losses on the U.S.
economy and lower living standards for lower-income Americans." Analyses
by Science Applications International (SAIC) and the EPA also show that the
bills would have a severe impact on the country: "The legislation referred
to as the ‘Lieberman-Warner’ bill, proposed by Senators Joe Lieberman (I-CT)
and John Warner (R-VA), would increase gasoline prices by 60 to 144 percent and
electricity prices by 77 to 129 percent" according to the SAIC. The EPA
estimates the bill would "increase gasoline prices by as much as 53 cents
per gallon by 2030 and $1.40 by 2050".
UK Lord Christopher Monckton, former Prime Minister
Thatcher advisor: The
cost and futility of trading hot air: Why carbon ‘cap-and-trade’ is an immoral
non-solution Excerpt: The truth is that “cap and trade” does not
work. The European Union’s carbon emissions are rising yearly, while those of
George Bush’s US are falling yearly. In the EU, “cap-and-trade” has already
been tried twice and has spectacularly failed twice, at huge cost. The
environmental result: nil. Europe’s emissions continue to rise. There have been
similar failures elsewhere in the world. A recent analysis by the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency of the Lieberman-Warner bill projects that
costs of electrical power and gasoline would rise very sharply. Gasoline would
cost about 53 cents per gallon more in 2030 and $1.40 per gallon more in 2050.