Posted By Marc Morano – 6:22 PM ET – Marc_Morano@EPW.Senate.Gov  

Lieberman-Warner: With Hours to Go Before Debate, Challenges Continue to Surface    

News Round Up

Link to Lieberman-Warner Climate Bill Exposed Page: www.epw.senate.gov/lieberman-warnerbillexposed

Sampling of Latest News on Lieberman-Warner 

Associated Press: Economic cost drives Senate climate debate June 1, 2008

Excerpt: From higher electric bills to more expensive gasoline, the possible economic cost of tackling global warming is driving the debate as climate change takes center stage in Congress.  Legislation set for Senate debate Monday would require a reduction in carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases from power plants, refineries, factories and transportation. The goal is to cut heat-trapping pollution by two-thirds by midcentury. With gasoline at $4 per gallon and home heating and cooling costs soaring, it is getting harder to sell a bill that would transform the country’s energy industries and – as critics will argue – cause energy prices to rise even more. 

CNN Money: Chances dim for climate-change legislation: Business coalition splinters, and without widespread corporate support, the bill headed to the Senate is almost certainly doomed. May 30, 2008

Excerpt: As currently written, Lieberman-Warner might fall short of a 50-vote majority in the Senate, let alone the 60 votes required to close debate, insiders say. […] An influential coalition of Fortune 500 companies and environmental groups that was formed to support climate-change legislation has splintered over the Lieberman-Warner bill that is headed next week to the Senate floor. […]  But other members of the coalition known as U.S. Cap, most visibly Duke Energy (DUK, Fortune 500), a coal-burning utility, are strongly opposed. "It’s going to translate into significant electricity price increases," says Jim Rogers, Duke’s CEO. Without widespread corporate support, passage of the bill – already a long shot at best – becomes even more unlikely this year. President Bush remains opposed. House Democrats have been slow to act. Besides that, a backdrop of rising gasoline prices and the sluggish economy makes it difficult to win votes for a regulatory scheme that will raise the prices of electricity and gasoline. In fact, a key purpose of the bill is to put a price on the emissions of greenhouse gases, as a way to speed the transition to a clean-energy economy and slow down global warming.

 

Washington Post: Climate Bill Underlines Obstacles to Capping Greenhouse Gases. June 1, 2008

Excerpt: All of this has left opponents of the bill, such as Environment and Public Works ranking member and global warming skeptic James M. Inhofe (R-Okla.), gloating. Andrew Wheeler, the panel’s GOP staff director, said in an interview that Republicans will not filibuster the bill this week because they relish the chance to offer amendments highlighting the bill’s effect on energy costs. "People are looking at this; they’re seeing that it’s going to do destructive things to energy prices and gasoline prices," Wheeler said. […] More than a dozen key senators — including freshmen Democrats Sherrod Brown (Ohio), Claire McCaskill (Mo.) and Jon Tester (Mont.) — have yet to endorse the bill. And Senate Majority Leader Harry M. Reid (D-Nev.), who supports the bill, is staying neutral rather than pushing recalcitrant members of his caucus to back it. "Generally, I believe that global warming is a serious issue and that we need to address it," said Dorgan, whose state produces lignite coal as well as wind power. But he added that he is still "digesting" the complicated bill, which he fears would not do enough to spur technology that would enable the country to continue burning coal. "We thought and hoped we’d be in a more serious place, but most people are using it as an opportunity to vet ideas and advance ideas for the debate to come in the next Congress," said Tim Profeta, who directs Duke University’s Nicholas Institute for Environmental Policy Solutions. "Not many people see this as a serious piece of legislation that will become law this year."

 

Washington Post: George F. Will: Carbon’s Power Brokers. May 30, 2008

An unprecedentedly radical government grab for control of the American economy will be debated this week when the Senate considers saving the planet by means of a cap-and-trade system to ration carbon emissions. The plan is co-authored (with John Warner) by Joe Lieberman, an ardent supporter of John McCain, who supports Lieberman’s legislation and recently spoke about "the central facts of rising temperatures, rising waters and all the endless troubles that global warming will bring." Speaking of endless troubles, "cap-and-trade" comes cloaked in reassuring rhetoric about the government merely creating a market, but government actually would create a scarcity so that government could sell what it had made scarce. The Wall Street Journal underestimates cap-and-trade’s perniciousness when it says the scheme would create a new right ("allowances") to produce carbon dioxide and would put a price on the right. Actually, because freedom is the silence of the law, that right has always existed in the absence of prohibitions. With cap-and-trade, government would create a right for itself– an extraordinarily lucrative right to ration Americans’ exercise of their traditional rights.

 

Oklahoman: Senate to discuss measure to control climate change June 1, 2008

Excerpt: Opponents of the bill, including Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Tulsa, could stop the Senate from even considering it, since it will take 60 votes to begin the debate. But they’re not expected to slow it down at first, preferring instead to have a debate about the massive changes to the nation’s energy production and usage that would result from the bill. Inhofe spokesman Matt Dempsey said, "Senator Inhofe supports a full and open debate on the merits of the bill and is confident that when his colleagues examine the facts about the enormous economic burdens this bill will impose on the American people, they, too, will oppose it.”

 

The Times Online: UK CO2 emissions rise faster than EU average despite carbon-trading scheme. May 27, 2008

Excerpt: UK CO2 emissions rise faster than EU average despite carbon-trading schemeDavid Charter, Europe Correspondent Britain pumped out more greenhouse gases last year under the EU carbon trading scheme designed to cut emissions, according to figures released in Brussels. The British increase was 2.2 per cent. There was an overall increase across Europe of 0.68 per cent, or 16million tonnes of CO2. Emissions rose in ten of the EU’s 27 countries, including Germany and Spain, despite the scheme’s target to cut CO2 by a fifth by 2020. Ministers argued that the extra 5.4 million tonnes of CO2 produced in Britain could be more than explained by 59 organisations joining the trading scheme, in which polluters are given carbon credits and forced to buy more if they emit beyond their allocation. They added that when the scheme is revamped next year, there will be tougher controls on the number of credits available. Phil Woolas, the Environment Minister, said that without the new entrants into the scheme, emissions would have gone down by 2.9 million tonnes. “Companies are taking their responsibilities seriously and carbon reduction and trading has become a normal part of their business,” he said. RELATED LINKS Drax to burn imported wood to cut CO2 emissions  An apple a day? Britons throw 4½ million away  Carbon trading turns City green But environmental campaigners said that the figures, combined with plans for more coal-fired power stations, showed that the carbon-trading scheme was not tough enough to meet reduction targets. “The only thing that matters is how much CO2 is going into the atmosphere,” said Robin Oakley, head of Greenpeace’s climate campaign. “It does not sound credible to call the emissions-trading scheme a success when we have seen a proposal for a new coal-fired power station in Kent. It is not sending a strong enough signal to the power companies.” Stavros Dimas, the EU Environment Commissioner, said that the rise in emissions was below the 2.8 per cent rise in Europe’s GDP last year. “Emissions trading is yielding results,” he said. “Studies show that emissions would most likely have been significantly higher without the EU emission trading scheme.” The biggest rises in tonnage of CO2 in 2007 came in Germany (up 8.99 million tonnes), Spain (up 6.79 million tonnes), Britain (up 5.42 million tonnes) and Czech Republic (up 4.21 million tonnes). Yesterday a committee of MPs told the Government to go ahead with a system of personal “carbon credits”. Under the scheme everybody would be given an annual carbon limit. Anyone who wanted to spend more could buy extra credits from low-carbon emitters. The Environmental Audit Committee said it would be more effective than green taxes and would promote behavioural change. It admitted that there would be strong public opposition but urged the Government to be courageous.

 

Forbes: Why Cap-And-Trade Won’t Work. May 30, 2008

Excerpt: Thanks to the aggressive timing of greenhouse gas reduction targets in the Warner-Lieberman bill–which the Senate will start to debate Monday–that calls for 2005 carbon emission levels starting in 2012, the U.S. can anticipate a massive switch from coal to natural gas by the power industry. More critically, the bill, which also calls on companies to reduce their carbon emissions by about 66% by 2050, will drive up both the demand and the price of natural gas (a low-carbon alternative) to unprecedented levels, which will in turn further erode the number of U.S. manufacturing jobs. Limited natural gas supply capacity will pit power-sector purchases in direct competition with demand from the residential, commercial and farm sectors. The problem with the bill, which was originally sponsored by Sen. Joseph Lieberman, D-Conn., and Sen. Mark Warner, D-Va., is this: Simply setting a cap on carbon emissions does nothing to remove the barriers to greater natural gas supply. There is nothing in the bill that will stop a potential national crisis–one that is already getting underway–as companies struggle to obey these carbon constraints. The lack of low-carbon energy alternatives for power generation (at least until new nuclear and coal-fired power plants with carbon capture to reduce emissions become more commonplace) means that natural gas is the default low-carbon energy option. In fact, none of the potential low-carbon energy alternatives except natural gas will be available by 2012, the year the bill first imposes these stringent limits. Energy efficiency and conservation will be helpful, but those measures will not prevent the crisis that will ensue when companies are forced to decrease their emissions. Because natural-gas-fired power generation is setting the marginal price for electricity in a growing portion of the country, as natural gas prices go up, so will the price of electricity.

 

National Center for Public Policy Research: The Lieberman-Warner Cap and Trade Bill: Quick Summary and Analysis. June 1, 2008

Excerpt: The United States Senate will soon begin debate on America’s Climate Security Act of 2007, popularly referred to as the Lieberman-Warner bill after its chief sponsors, Senators Joseph Lieberman (I-CT) and John Warner (R-VA).The legislation ostensibly is intended to cut U.S. industrial emissions of greenhouse gases in an effort to reduce the risk of catastrophic global warming.  Senator Lieberman has estimated the bill would reduce overall U.S. greenhouse gas emissions by up to 63% by 2050.1  The policies the legislation would impose, however, have little hope of meeting this target and would likely have little impact on the climate even if it did.Lieberman-Warner would, however, significantly slow the U.S. economy and increase the cost of energy and consumer products.  It also would disrupt international commerce. BackgroundAmerica’s Climate Security Act of 2007 (S. 2191) was introduced in the Senate on October 18, 2007 by Senators Joseph Lieberman (I-CT) and John Warner (R-VA).  The bill states as its purpose: "[P]rompt, decisive action is critical, since global warming pollutants can persist in the atmosphere for more than a century."  Congress is demanding "prompt, decisive action" even though there is still disagreement among scientists about the level, cause and consequences of global warming.  On May 19, 2008, for example, Dr. Arthur Robinson of the Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine announced that more than 31,000 scientists had signed a petition rejecting the theory of human-caused global warming.  A significant number of scientists, climatologists and meteorologists have expressed doubt about the danger of global warming and whether or not humans are having a significant impact for the worse on the climate.  Others, including renowned scientists, have suggested that there are approaches to deal with global warming that would not necessitate slowing the economy.S. 2191 was approved by the Senate Environmental and Public Works Committee on December 5, 2007 in an 11-8 vote.  On May 21, a substitute bill incorporating America’s Climate Security Act, S. 3036, was

 

Financial Times: UK’s Gordon Brown: Higher energy prices are a ‘legitimate’ way to cut greenhouse gas emissions. May 30, 2008
Excerpt: Higher energy prices are a "legitimate" way to cut greenhouse gas emissions, Gordon Brown’s chief adviser on climate change said on Friday, even as the government faces mounting pressure from MPs to ease fuel taxes. Adair Turner, the chairman of the government’s climate change committee and new head of the Financial Services Authority, told the Financial Times that, as a matter of principle, "everyone accepts that putting a price on carbon is a crucial instrument" to cut emissions. "That will put up the price of energy and there is no way round that. We should not deny that is what these policies do," he said. Lord Turner’s comments underline the growing conflict between environmental policies – which rely on increasing the cost of energy to encourage people to cut their emissions – and the government’s need to respond to widespread concerns over the effects of high energy prices. The timing of Lord Turner’s intervention could hardly be worse for Mr Brown. As Labour on Friday suffered its worst poll rating since records began in 1943, the prime minister remained under intense pressure over his handling of the fuel crisis.

 

The Toronto Sun: Just say it: Kyoto’s a crock, Stephen Harper should call the environmental accord what it is — a train wreck. June 1, 2008

Excerpt: Could Prime Minister Stephen Harper or Environment Minister John Baird please explain what they mean when they say Canada continues to be a participant in the Kyoto accord? How can we be a participant when the PM has said we cannot do what Kyoto requires of us — lower our greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by an average of 6% below 1990 levels between now and 2012? We’re 29.1% above our Kyoto target. Achieving that target is the point of Kyoto. So what, exactly, are we participating in? Yes, the Liberals are hypocrites for ratifying Kyoto and then doing zilch to implement it.

 

Yorkshire Post: Seeing red over ‘green’ taxes. May 30, 2008

Excerpt: SO-CALLED "green" taxes are a con. They have absolutely nothing to do with saving the planet, or changing people’s behaviour. It is all about raising revenue. Governments around the world have realised that environmentalism gives them an easy way of squeezing yet more tax out of hard-working people. And if you object, you are supposed to feel guilty about drowning polar bears. "Green" taxes also impact most heavily on the poor. This isn’t an accident, it is a deliberate policy. Take, for example, motoring. The only way of reducing the numbers of cars is by forcing the less-affluent off the roads. This is what increases in fuel duty and car tax are partly designed to achieve. Of course, some people will simply give up driving, but for many, they have little choice – particularly those with large families, or who live in a rural area, or who need a car to get to work. Tough, say the environmentalists, pay up and stop moaning. Think of the polar bears.Same with air travel. The green agenda is to stop the less-affluent from flying by making it so expensive that only the rich can afford it.

 

Washington Post: Duke Energy CEO on Senate global warming bill: ‘Only the mafia could create an organization that would skim money off the top’ like this bill does. May 31, 2008

Excerpt: "This is just a money grab," said James E. Rogers, the chief executive of Duke Energy. Rogers says he supports a cap-and-trade system but argues that this bill raises too much revenue from coal users while diverting too much of it to other purposes. "Only the mafia could create an organization that would skim money off the top the way this legislation would skim money off the top," he said. Duke, with customers in Ohio, Indiana and the Carolinas, relies heavily on coal-fired plants.