Posted by: Matt Dempsey (202) 224-9797 Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

 

 EPW POLICY BEAT: THE ‘DE FACTO’ BAN ON NEW COAL PLANTS

From the Inhofe-EPW Press Office 

 

 

Should coal be part of the energy mix in a carbon-constrained world?  It’s not surprising that we think it should.  And we suppose it’s not earth shattering that the Waxman-Markey climate bill answers this all-important question with nuance.   True, the bill supports carbon capture and sequestration technology for new coal plants.  But Congress can’t legislate this technology into existence.  So this “bridge to a low carbon future” is a bridge to nowhere: the bill effectively sends the prospect of new coal plants into oblivion. Why?  In section 116 (beginning on page 60), the bill establishes a New Source Performance Standard (NSPS) for new coal plants that will be, from an economic standpoint, just about impossible to meet.  According to an analysis by ClearView Energy Partners, this amounts to a “de facto ban on new PC [pulverized coal] plants.” 

 

Waxman-Markey establishes performance standards for new coal plants in 3 “tranches”:

 

(1) plants permitted between 1/1/2009 and 1/1/2015 must meet < 1,100 lbCO2e/MWh by

the earlier of either (a) four years after 2.5 GW of nameplate capturing > 5MM tpy CO2 are operating in the U.S; or (b) four years after 5 GW of nameplate capturing > 10MM tpy CO2 are operating worldwide;

(2) plants permitted after 1/1/2015 must meet < 1,100 lbCO2e/MWh; and

(3) plants permitted after 1/1/2020 must meet < 800 lbCO2e/MWh.

 

What does this mean?  ClearView explains: “Using standard industry values of 1850 lbCO2e/MWh for PC combustion emissions (0.83 Mt/MWh) and a 90% capacity factor, the trigger would go into effect at only a 30.5% capture rate in the U.S. or globally, despite the 1,100 lb standard corresponding to a 41% capture rate.”  Moreover, “compliance with 1,100 lbCO2e/MWh standards would imply a maximum capacity factor ceiling of 66.6667%.”  In simple, declarative fashion, ClearView concludes: “We would suggest that this standard will face considerable opposition in the Senate.”  We would agree.

 

Finally, we should mention that we’ve seen this performance standard before…in California.  In 2006, the state passed S. 1368, which requires all baseload generation seeking long-term contracts (5 years or more) with California utilities to meet a GHG performance standard of, yes, 1,100 lbs. CO2/MWh.   According to the bill’s sponsor, “California has not said ‘no’ to coal; rather, we’ve said that we want cleaner coal plants that can provide us energy without producing massive global warming pollution.”  If this is ‘yes’, we wonder what ‘no’ means.

 

# # #