Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov (202)224-9797
With green jobs being so much in vogue, EPW Policy Beat had occasion to review a recent ad by the estimable “Repower America,” a group whose raison d’être is, as Al Gore urged last July, to “repower” the nation with 100 percent clean electricity within ten years. Repower America is a project of the Alliance for Climate Protection, whose chairman of the board is Al Gore. Here are excerpts of the ad as recounted in a press release from the group, followed at intervals by our critique:
Repower America: “Let’s talk numbers,” says the ads’ narrator, noting state-specific unemployment and foreclosure statistics. “We need to turn things around. And we can’t afford to wait. Right now, Congress is debating a clean energy jobs plan that will jumpstart our economy, reduce carbon pollution, and break our dependence on foreign oil.”
POLICY BEAT: The “clean energy jobs plan” referred to in the ad is the Waxman-Markey draft climate bill. The bill looks very much like the Lieberman-Warner Climate Security Act rejected by the Senate last year, which, according to the American Council for Capital Formation (ACCF) (http://www.accf.org/media/dynamic/1/media_190.pdf), would destroy up to 4 million jobs and reduce GDP by $669 billion.
Repower America: “If we repower Ohio with clean energy, it will jumpstart our economy, reduce carbon pollution, break our dependence on foreign oil and create 80,000 clean energy jobs in new industries for Ohio workers. That’s right, 80,000 new jobs that can’t be shipped overseas.”
POLICY BEAT: As Repower America suggests, let’s talk numbers. According to ACCF’s analysis, the Climate Security Act would destroy up to 143,000 jobs in Ohio. Even if one concedes that a carbon mandate would create “80,000 clean energy jobs”—a concession not easily made—there would be a net loss of 63,000 jobs. This is looks very much like Spain, as recounted in a remarkable new study (http://www.juandemariana.org/pdf/090327-employment-public-aid-renewable.pdf) of the green jobs experience there. The study, conducted by Dr. Gabriel Calzada, an economics professor at Juan Carlos University in Madrid, found that each renewable job created by the Spanish government destroyed an average of 2.2 other jobs, while each “green” megawatt installed in Spain destroyed 5.39 jobs in non-energy sectors.
Repower America: The spot concludes, “We’ve got to make a choice: Try our luck with business as usual, or invest in a clean energy future. The smart money’s on clean energy.”
POLICY BEAT: “Smart money”? The study calculated that, since 2000, Spain spent $774,000 to create each “green job,” including subsidies of more than $1.3 million per wind industry job. It found that creating those jobs resulted in the destruction of nearly 113,000 jobs elsewhere in the economy, or 2.2 jobs destroyed for every “green job” created. “The loss of jobs could be greater if you account for the amount of lost industry that moves out of the country due to higher energy prices,” Dr. Calzada said recently in an interview with Bloomberg News.
Repower America: Maggie Fox, CEO of the Alliance for Climate Protection, noted the urgent need for action. “Make no mistake, we have a real opportunity before us to lead the world in a new direction and create jobs. But we have to act now,” said Fox. “Passing comprehensive energy legislation that rewards innovation and job creation, rather than polluters, will jumpstart our economy and create millions of clean energy jobs in manufacturing, trucking, construction and other core industries that are hurting across the Midwest and other states.”
POLICY BEAT: According to ACCF, Lieberman-Warner, a bill that Al Gore praised (http://www.hillheat.com/articles/2008/06/02/al-gore-praises-boxer-lieberman-warner-bill) but said needed to be “stronger,” would result in the following: “Some major economic sectors will be adversely hit by emission caps. By 2020, primary metals output would be reduced by between 15% and 19%; stone, glass, and clay products would be reduced by between 10% and 12%; motor vehicle manufacturing would be reduced by between 6% and 14%; and paper products would be reduced by between 5% and 7%. In addition the general shift away from coal would result in a 35% reduction in coal production and electricity production would fall around 12%. These losses would be significantly higher by 2030 and would have a lasting impact on the economic base of the US.”