Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
EPW News Round-Up from House Ag Hearing
From the Inhofe EPW Press Office
Vilsack Declines to Endorse Far-Reaching House Bill – Oklahoman – June 12, 2009 Link
WASHINGTON — Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack declined Thursday to endorse a far-reaching House bill to curb greenhouse gas emissions. An Oklahoma congressman said it would "destroy” farmers’ livelihoods. Rep. Frank Lucas, R-Cheyenne, repeatedly pressed Vilsack at a hearing to take a stand on the bill. At one point, he asked Vilsack, the former governor of Iowa, whether he would vote for it if he were a congressman representing Iowa. Vilsack didn’t answer the question directly. He said it was up to lawmakers to write the bill and that more work could be done to improve it. But Lucas, the top Republican on the House Agriculture Committee, said House Democratic leaders weren’t allowing any more work to be done on the bill and that they may bring it up for a vote later this month.
Democrats and Republicans Denounce Waxman-Markey Climate Change Bill in House Ag Committee Hearing – Oklahoma Farm Report – June 12, 2009 Link
The House Agriculture Committee held a hearing Thursday on the much talked about Waxman-Markey climate change and energy legislation. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Committee Chairman Henry Waxman want to push the bill through rather quickly. But, Ranking Member, Frank Lucas, said – the most important thing we can do for our agriculture community is allow the legislative process to work, to take the time to understand the consequences of our actions. Lucas said here we are today with our first public hearing to consider a bill that is written to last forever. This is a bill that is enormous in size and consequence that has the potential to permanently damage the standard of living for every man, woman, and child for decades to come. Lucas pointed out that the cap-and-trade part of the bill – creates a national energy tax that will do more harm to production agriculture, American industry, and our standard of living than it will do any good for the environment. As for its affect on agriculture, Lucas said – I cannot support a bill that will damage an industry that consistently provides America and the world with an abundant and affordable food and fiber supply. The lead witness in the hearing was Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack, who was in front of the lawmakers for just over three hours. He not only was told that this bill was unacceptable by the Republicans, but House Democrats got their licks in as well. In fact, House Ag Democrats and Republicans told Secretary Vilsack there will be no climate change bill – or none agriculture can live with – unless the Administration forces changes in the pending measure approved by the House Energy and Commerce Committee.
Ag Committee Gives Climate Bill the Cold Shoulder – Agriculture Online – June 12, 2009 Link
Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack was grilled for hours Thursday by a House Agriculture Committee that seems united across party lines in opposing the current form of a climate change bill written by the House Energy and Commerce Committee. And none of the farm group leaders who testified to the committee said their organizations would support the bill, either, unless agriculture and forestry are allowed to sell carbon credits, or offsets, to industries with large greenhouse gas output. And, if the bill is changed to include agricultural credits, all oppose putting the Environmental Protection Agency in charge of it. Vilsack said that he believes farmers and ranchers will have the potential to benefit more from carbon trading than they will be hurt by rising costs for fertilizer and fuel that will come with a law designed to lower the release of greenhouse gases.
House Ag Chairman: EPA Stay Out of Agriculture – Top Producer – June 12, 2009 Link
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) needs to stay out of farm policy, says House Ag Committee Chairman Collin Peterson (D-Minn.). Without that concession in the final draft of any climate change bill, he will not support it, Peterson said in an exclusive interview with Top Producer on Wednesday morning. With current language in the The American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009 (ACES), Peterson’s opposition to the bill is echoed almost universally by agricultural groups. ACES, sponsored by House Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Henry Waxman (D-Calif.) and fellow Democrat Ed Markey of Massachusetts, who chairs the Select Committee on Energy Independence and Global Warming, was introduced in late March. So far, work between the Agriculture Committee staff and the Energy and Commerce Committee staff has not produced the results Peterson wants in order to put his support behind the bill, which House Speaker Nancy Pelosi wants resolved by the Fourth of July. At issue is the Supreme Court ruling mandating reduction in greenhouse gas emissions under the Clean Air Act. Without legislation, this means the EPA will regulate emissions. The current language in ACES also grants this authority to EPA, and Peterson is unbending in his opposition to this provision.
Cap-and-trade Faces Ag Foes : Farm Interests ‘left behind,’ Herseth Sandlin says – Argus Leader – June 11, 2009 Link
A climate-change bill that won approval from the House Energy and Commerce Committee isn’t getting the same reception from rural lawmakers.When members of the House Agriculture Committee hold a hearing today, many of them – Republican and Democrat – are expected to pick apart a measure driven by urban interests, one that they say practically ignores farming interests.Rep. Stephanie Herseth Sandlin, D-S.D., said she’ll vote against the bill unless it undergoes major changes. Other rural Democrats, such as Minnesota Rep. Colin Peterson, who leads the agriculture panel, also have indicated their opposition, potentially dooming the "cap-and-trade" initiative championed by President Obama "Cap-and-trade holds the potential for some real economic opportunity for South Dakota," Herseth Sandlin said. "But I share some of the concerns of my colleagues that if we move on this too quickly and we don’t structure and design it appropriately, certain interests, including agriculture, will be left behind." The Energy and Commerce Committee approved the climate change bill last month, 33-25, on a mostly party-line vote. Several other House committees, including Agriculture, are expected to hold hearings on the measure. The proposal would cut greenhouse gases by 17 percent during the next decade. Companies, particularly coal-burning power plants, would have to spend money on technology to reduce global-warming emissions or be forced to bid for pollution allowances from emitters. Those allowances would be well below new standards set by the Environmental Protection Agency.
Lawmakers in Farm Belt Try to Steer Climate Bill – The Wall Street Journal – June 12, 2009 Link
Farm Belt lawmakers said Thursday that the climate legislation in the House may not get the votes to pass unless it is made more farm-friendly. The warning, sounded by Agriculture Committee Chairman Collin Peterson (D., Minn.), presents a new obstacle to the White House’s effort to get a bill passed this year. The objecting lawmakers — both Democrat and Republican — used a hearing of the House Agricultural Committee to call for changes in the bill that, if adopted, could steer more money to farmers who engage in environmentally friendly practices. The lawmakers are also seeking to blunt potentially tough new regulation of the biofuels industry. The move follows successful efforts by lawmakers from industrial and coal states to win free pollution permits for coal-fired power generators and other industries under a system proposed in the bill that would also cap greenhouse-gas emissions.House leaders want a full House vote on the Waxman-Markey bill in the next few weeks so they can turn their attention to health-care legislation. The timetable could give lawmakers who object to provisions in the more-than-900-page bill leverage to demand further changes. Thursday’s hearing also previews the struggle ahead in the Senate, which has yet to take up climate legislation and where rural states have even greater influence.
Also See:
EPW POLICY BEAT: DOWN ON THE FARM – Inhofe EPW Press Blog – June 11, 2009 Link
In March, the House Agriculture Committee sent a lengthy questionnaire on various aspects of climate change policy to members of the agricultural community. The committee cast a wide net, having sent questions to “a diverse group, including commodity, conservation, forestry, research, energy, business, and nonprofit interests.” The questions covered everything from allowance allocation, offsets, commodities trading, and regional economic impacts (the responses are posted here: http://agriculture.house.gov/inside/pubs/Questionnaire-P1.pdf). That last topic piqued our curiosity, as it is incontestably clear that cap-and-trade harms consumers in the Midwest, Southeast, and Great Plains—regions that are heavily rural and coal-dependent—much more so than denizens of the East and West coasts. In reading through the answers, one finds serious concerns from farmers about what cap-and-trade would mean for rural communities. The following response from the American Farm Bureau Federation on this topic illustrates why members representing rural districts are leery of, if not outright opposed to, cap-and-trade: it will raise prices for farm implements, fertilizer, fuels, and food—all of which could stifle agricultural production, destroying jobs and devastating rural communities.
###