Posted by: Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov (202)224-9797
As the House prepares to vote on the largest tax increase in American history, otherwise known as the Waxman-Markey bill, and as President Obama tries to persuade his House allies to vote for same, EPW Policy Beat took another trip down memory lane. We landed in 1993 as the House was voting on the Al-Gore-backed BTU tax. As we and others have stated before, the historical and political parallels between the BTU tax and Waxman-Markey are striking: members fearful that voting for an energy tax would have political repercussions at the ballot box; members fearful of voting for a bill that would then die in the Senate; members fearful that an energy tax would be regressive, harm consumers, destroy jobs and slow economic growth; members fearful of a man named Gore pushing an energy rationing scheme that harms the heartland; and Democratic congressional leaders and Administration officials (read: Gore) desperately searching for exemptions and last-minute deals to shore up support. As the proverb goes, “the more things change, the more they stay the same.”
The following excerpts speak for themselves:
-
“Energy Tax Hits Consumers More Than Oil Firms,” Los Angeles Times, May 27, 1993: “Seeking to regain his populist footing, [President] Clinton complained that oil producers were ‘trying to wiggle out of their contribution to deficit reduction’ by seeking to strip the energy tax from his budget plan. But a close look at the proposed energy tax — now at the center of the congressional debate over Clinton’s program — shows that it was not designed by the Administration to soak Big Oil, but to hit consumers.”
-
“Parties and Elections in America,” by Lois Sand Maisel and Kara Buckley: “Today’s members of Congress remember all too well how House Democrats were persuaded by [President Bill] Clinton to support an electorally unpopular position for the sake of their president’s agenda. Democrats in the House uneasily went on record in support of a controversial new energy tax (the BTU tax), as part of Clinton’s 1993 economic plan, only to see Clinton drop the proposal when it was clear he did not have support of Democrats in the Senate. Many of those House Democrats who reluctantly voted for the BTU tax bill were left vulnerable going into the 1994 elections, the historic mid-term elections in which Republicans took control of Congress.”
-
Former Clinton Budget Chief Leon Panetta: “We were pushing the House of Representatives to adopt this budget with the BTU tax. The votes that we’re grabbing at that point are basically saying to us — and these are some of the conservative votes — "The last thing I want to vote for is that BTU tax. But if I vote for it, you damn well better stick with it in the Senate. Don’t you dare sell out on that issue on the Senate side, because then you’re going to screw us.” (http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/clinton/interviews/panetta2.html)
-
Grist Magazine: “The House passed a budget bill with the BTU tax in it without any Republican support, but it was later dropped in order to get the overall budget plan through the Senate. Republicans then bashed Democrats who had voted for the tax, using the issue effectively in the 1994 elections, which resulted in the first GOP House majority in 40 years. Republicans this year are banking on using the climate bill the same way, putting pressure on freshmen Democrats and those in vulnerable seats.” (http://www.grist.org/article/2009-05-15-gore-rallies-grassroots/)
-
Tax History Project: “To increase support for the tax, the formal administration proposal — part of the administration’s first budget — contained several provisions to provide relief to powerful constituencies. The version of the B.T.U. tax that squeaked its way through the House was even more complex and had more special rules than the administration plan.” (http://www.taxhistory.org/thp/readings.nsf/ArtWeb/5DDB79194769C2BF852574D5003C28D5?OpenDocument
-
“Overcoming Political Barriers to Reform in Energy Policy,” by Josh Busby: “In the first proposal of the Btu tax, coal and natural gas were taxed at the same rate, even though coal is more polluting. This was a way to avoid incurring the wrath of West Virginia Senator Robert Byrd. The Clinton administration made a tactical mistake by then modifying the plan in April 1993 to further appease coal interests. Once this move had been made, other interests piled on in an effort to seek exemptions from the tax while the oil and gas industry opposed it outright. Even though the House voted in favor of the remnant of the Btu tax, influential Democratic senators like David Boren of Oklahoma and John Breaux of Louisiana vigorously opposed it, and the Clinton administration withdrew it before a vote.”
###