Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

Will China Follow This Time?

From the Inhofe EPW Press Blog

www.epw.senate.gov/inhofeblog 

 

 

A mantra repeated endlessly in the cap-and-trade debate is that unilateral U.S. action on climate change will spur China (and other developing countries) to follow suit.  This mantra is spoken with metronomic regularity, despite China’s unequivocal opposition, stated over and over again, to accepting mandatory emission cuts.  Such opposition should be no surprise: China has amassed a long and ignominious record of divergence on issues in which the United States has taken the lead. 

EPW Policy Beat delved into the historical record to find examples of China going its own way, regardless of U.S. example and leadership.  In some cases, China stands in defiance of international trade rules and basic norms of justice and human rights. 

 

This list should give pause to cap-and-traders who believe that unilateral U.S. action necessarily translates into China adopting Waxman-Markey, or anything remotely like it.  As Bob Stallman, president of the American Farm Bureau Federation, put it, “We all support leadership by the United States. But don’t forget one thing: leadership only occurs when people are following you. If they’re not, then it’s the economic equivalent of unilateral disarmament.” 

 

Human rights:  Last year, in the “2008 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices,” the State Department was sharply critical of China’s human rights record.  “The government of China’s human rights record remained poor and worsened in some areas,” the report said.  Chinese authorities, according to the report, “committed extrajudicial killings and torture, coerced confessions of prisoners and used forced labor.”  The report also accused China of “severe cultural and religious repression” of minorities in Tibet and other regions.  

Workers’ Rights: In 2004, the AFL-CIO filed a petition with the United States Trade Representative, which contends that the Chinese government’s "persistent pattern of repressing labor rights" has created "a huge pool of cut-rate labor that has displaced as many as 1.2 million US jobs."   According to the petition, the United States loses 930,000 manufacturing jobs and 1,235,000 total jobs as a result of the denial of workers’ rights in China. http://www.aflcio.org/issues/jobseconomy/globaleconomy/upload/china_qa.pdf 

International trade law:  According to an article in worldtrade.net, “Since the midterm elections, the United States has launched an assault on China using WTO litigation.”  According to the article, in February 2007, the U.S. filed three cases in the WTO against China. The cases covered China’s tax rebates to domestic firms, constituting illegal export subsidies; intellectual property violations; and restrictions on the import and distribution of films and DVDs, in violation of GATT.  http://www.worldtradelaw.net/articles/malawerchinalitigation.pdf 

In March, the World Trade Organization (WTO) formally ruled that “several aspects of China’s legal regime for protecting and enforcing intellectual property rights are inconsistent with China’s obligations under the WTO Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS Agreement).” 

According to United States Trade Representative Ron Kirk, “the United States brought this dispute against China because of concerns that Chinese law does not adequately provide for the protection and enforcement of copyrights and trademarks on a wide range of products.”  Moreover, Kirk said, “I am particularly troubled by reports that Chinese officials are urging more lenient enforcement of IPR laws, motivated by the financial crisis and the need to maintain jobs.  China needs to strengthen its approach to IPR protection and enforcement, not weaken it.”

Free speech: According to the “2008 Country Report on Human Rights Abuses,” the State Department found that China limits the rights of citizens to privacy and freedom of speech, assembly, movement and association.  Also, Amnesty International has claimed that China “has the largest recorded number of imprisoned journalists and cyber-dissidents in the world.”

Currency manipulation: According to the Telegraph of London, “China has begun to devalue the yuan for the first time in over a decade, raising fears that it will set off a 1930s-style race to the bottom and tip the global economy into an even deeper slump.”  Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner, in his confirmation hearing, noted that, “President Obama—backed by the conclusions of a broad range of economists—believes that China is manipulating its currency.”  (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/3546471/Chinese-economy-1930s-beggar-thy-neighbour-fears-as-China-devalues.html) 

###