Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

EPW POLICY BEAT: CHINA AND THE "CLEAN ENERGY RACE"

From the Inhofe EPW Press Blog

www.epw.senate.gov/inhofeblog

Picture two runners, call them China and America.  They are running in a race.  China is ahead of America, but America wants to get ahead and win.  Right in the middle of the race, someone puts a massive weight on America’s back, clearing the path to victory for China.

According to Silicon Valley attorney John Doerr, who testified last week at an EPW Committee hearing, there is, in fact, a “clean energy race” between China and America, and China is “cleaning our clock.”  Doerr’s plan for winning the race?  Throw the massive weight of cap-and-trade on the back of America’s manufacturers and let China run free.

Doerr described China’s commitments to “develop and own clean energy technologies and markets” as “breathtaking.” Examples include cars that are more than “one-third more fuel efficient than U.S. cars,” investing “ten times more than the US on clean power as a percentage of GDP,” and the fact that China “is expected to become the world’s largest wind manufacturer this years.”

All of this is quite interesting, but Doerr’s argument suffers from a fatal flaw: China’s “breathtaking” commitments are occurring without cap-and-trade.  Moreover, Doerr glosses over the crucial fact about manufacturing wind turbines and solar panels: making them is energy-intensive, which means significant costs for energy use.  According to a paper by DOE’s Robert Garland, “manufacturing processes are amongst the most energy-intensive industrial systems.”   “Energy costs,” he concludes, “are therefore a major driver for many plants in the United States.” 

So what would happen to manufacturing under cap-and-trade?  In a study last year, the National Association of Manufacturers found that the Lieberman-Warner cap-and-trade bill would cause energy prices to skyrocket.  As a result, in 2030, chemical manufacturing would lose $88 to $107 billion; primary metals would lose $78 to $92 billion; and stone, clay, and glass would lose $37 to $45 billion. 

So Doerr’s logic is curious: place a cap on carbon, make the energy that domestic manufacturers use more expensive, and then hope to secure investment in new technologies while competing against a country that has no cap and fewer environmental regulations.  Hand the ribbon to China.

Finally, Doerr asked the question, “What do Amazon, Ebay, Google, Microsoft and Yahoo have in common?” Doerr asked.  “They are all American.”  Yet he laments that, when it comes to wind turbines, of the world’s manufacturers, only one (GE) is American.

Ebay, Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo have something else in common: they came about not because of regulation, or anything like cap-and-trade—they arose from the creative minds of entrepreneurs trying to meet a market need.  This is something Doerr should know.  In 1974 he joined Intel, just as the company invented the legendary 8080 microprocessor, and he later became a leading Silicon Valley pioneer.  He faced nothing like the behemoth of cap-and-trade, and his success was rewarded by the free market. 

If one hopes for a new Silicon Valley of clean energy technology—which we do—it won’t happen under the most burdensome regulatory scheme since the New Deal.  By removing barriers to innovation and opening access to our domestic energy resources, America can compete and win the race. 

###