Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

 “Ticking Time Bomb” – “Blood in the Water” – “Wrong Approach”

Democrats Take Aim at Cap-and-Trade 

Inhofe EPW News Round-Up 

 

ROLL CALL: Climate Change Will Be Senate’s Next Battle Royal (7/21/09) – Climate change is the ticking political time bomb on the Senate’s agenda this fall, and Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) has the timer set to go off in late September. With the debate on health care sucking up so much oxygen in the Senate these days, few are paying attention to the cavernous gulf among Democrats over how to tackle global warming and the lack — so far — of a way to bring Members together while also appealing to Republicans. “It will blow up,” one senior Democrat said. With Democrats from the South, Midwest, Plains and Mountain West deeply skeptical of creating a cap-and-trade system for greenhouse gas emissions, Senate Democrats could be even more split than they are on health care reform once the chamber actually begins to seriously focus on the issue. “There’s a lot of opposition to climate change in the Senate,” said a senior  Senate Democratic aide. “You’re going to have to turn a lot of Democrats to get a bill.”

 

Environment and Energy Daily: Battle over health care leaves ‘blood in the water’ for cap and trade (07/22/2009) – President Obama and Capitol Hill Democrats have spent the better part of this year juggling legislation on health care and climate change. The two monster initiatives would be significant accomplishments if either one could pass, let alone both. But for now, each remains a long way from the finish line as Republicans and some Democrats push back against bills that have big price tags and questionable public support. Obama will try to reclaim control over the story line tonight with his fourth prime time press conference since taking office in January, part of a media campaign to keep momentum going on the top pieces of his legislative agenda. It won’t be easy. Advocates for the two bills wonder if the combined pitch has zapped away each item’s own strength. And there is also the Republican Party, which is working to score political points by packaging the entire Obama agenda as a grab for big government.

 

WashTimes: Inhofe Wary of Administrations Apologies Sen. James M. Inhofe, Oklahoma Republican, said Tuesday that Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton’s apologizing for the United States being a major contributor to climate change was poorly timed and will further doom Capitol Hill legislation to limit carbon-dioxide emissions. Mr. Inhofe, a senior member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, repeated the argument that cap-and-trade legislation on manufacturing pollution will only send jobs overseas to India and China. "In an environment like that, to have the secretary of state go over to India and apologize for what old America has done — I’m so tired of people apologizing for us," Mr. Inhofe told The Washington Times’ "America’s Morning News" radio show. Referring to President Obama’s recent statement in Italy that the United States had "sometimes fallen short" of its responsibilities in controlling carbon emissions,Mrs. Clinton said during her trip to India that "we acknowledge now with President Obama that we have made mistakes in the United States, and we along with other developed countries have contributed most significantly to the problem that we face with climate change."

 

ClimateWire: Governors still feeling their way through climate bill:  Colorado’s Democratic governor sidestepped questions from the Senate’s leading agitator on climate legislation about the depth of his support for a behemoth energy effort rolling through Congress. It comes days after another Democratic governor, Brian Schweitzer of Montana, called cap and trade the "wrong approach." The hearing yesterday largely reinforced Democratic assertions that the climate bill known by the names of its House authors, Reps. Henry Waxman (D-Calif.) and Edward Markey (D-Mass.), would fuel new-era energy jobs and reduce carbon dioxide emissions. But the response by Colorado Gov. Bill Ritter underscores the complexity — and cost — that Democrats face in reshaping the country’s economy. The instigator, no less, was opposition enemy No. 1: Republican Sen. James Inhofe of Oklahoma.

 

Listen: President of Democratic Governors Association Calls Cap-and Trade “Wrong Approach” – Bill Maher received quite a shock on his show last Friday when his guest, Governor Brian Schweitzer (D-MT), said cap-and-trade was "the wrong approach." Schweitzer, who heads the Democratic Governors Association, explained that cap-and-trade, "says to the biggest utilities in America we are going to add a trillion dollars to your bottom line we are going to franchise you and only you to be the producers of CO2. I think it’s the wrong approach." Maher was clearly shocked that the Governor wouldn’t go along and endorse cap-and-trade. Maher was exasperated, and asked, "But isn’t it the Democrat approach?" Schweitzer responded by saying "It might be some of the Democrats approach, but I think if you want to get to the root of the problem you establish a price of the cost of that pollution to the rest of society…"

 

Harkin: Unfair to the Midwest – Greenwire reports that Senator Harkin is critical of the Edison Electric Institute recommended allowance distribution for electricity companies because it is unfair to “those of us in the Midwest who have relied on coal or gas.”  He is quoted as saying, “That can’t hold. We need a better allowance for us. That 50-50 split is not fair. Not in any way fair. Why should it be based on sales? Aren’t we trying to reduce emissions? So we should have it more based on emissions, less on sales.”  In the same story Senator Carper (D-DE) is quoted as saying an effort to tinker with the allocations would be a “big mistake.” 

Dorgan: Reduce CO2, yes; cap and trade, no: WASHINGTON — I’m in favor of taking action to reduce CO2 emissions and to protect our environment. But I don’t support the “cap-and-trade” plan now being debated in the Congress.“Cap and trade” is an approach that would have the government set caps on carbon emissions from certain sources, then establish a market in which allowances for CO2 emissions would be bought and sold on a financial exchange. Supporters call it a “market-based solution.” I think it is the wrong solution, and I don’t support it.

Conrad: "Lots of Concerns" "In North Dakota we have more than agriculture concerns, we’re a major energy state as well," Conrad said. "So we’ve got a lot of concerns … they’ve certainly improved substantially from where it was last year by what they did in the House, but it has a ways to go before I can vote for it."

 

Bismarck Tribune Editorial: Senators shouldn’t back cap-and-trade: North Dakota’s sole member of the U.S. House, Earl Pomeroy, voted against the bill. Dorgan has said he will not support the cap-and-trade bill now in Congress. Conrad and Dorgan should immediately stand up and be counted among those who will vote no on cap-and-trade. North Dakota’s congressional delegation should now aggressively use their hard-earned influence to stop the legislation before it does serious damage to the livelihood of the people of North Dakota.

 

Byrd Blasts ‘Cap and Trade’ The Intelligencer / Wheeling News-Register, July 8, 2009 -WHEELING – He is not yet back to work in the Senate chamber, but U.S. Sen. Robert Byrd is opposing "cap and trade" legislation pushed by the Obama administration. The 91-year-old Byrd, D-W.Va., was released from an unidentified Washington, D.C. hospital last week after a month-long stay for a staph infection. He expects to return to the chamber before the Senate begins debate on "cap and trade" – which is tentatively set for this fall, according to Byrd’s office. "I cannot support the House bill in its present form," Byrd said in a statement. "I continue to believe that clean coal can be a ‘green’ energy. Those of us who understand coal’s great potential in our quest for energy independence must continue to work diligently in shaping a climate bill that will ensure access to affordable energy for West Virginians. I remain bullish about the future of coal, and am so very proud of the miners who labor and toil in the coalfields of West Virginia."

McCaskill says House climate bill will sink in Senate, Grist, July 8, 2009 – Sen. Claire McCaskill (D-Mo.) doesn’t think that the climate and energy bill that passed the House last month stands much of a chance in the Senate…She also said she would not vote for the climate bill that the Senate rejected last year, nor would she vote for the House bill (Waxman-Markey) as it stands. "If there is going to be enough support for the bill, it will be a very gradual implementation as we move toward changing to wind and solar and other kinds of energy," said McCaskill. "I’m going to be one of those trying to craft it in a way that is very gradual, that is not going to hurt a state like Missouri that is so coal dependent." She said she will probably make those on the left and right angry in this debate, and will be "working with a group of moderates in the middle" to shape the Senate bill…."We need to be a leader in the world but we don’t want to be a sucker," she said. "And if we go too far with this, all we’re going to do is chase more jobs to China and India, where they’ve been putting up coal-fired plants every 10 minutes."McCaskill has also expressed concerns about the House bill via Twitter, where she posted during the debate, "I hope we can fix cap and trade so it doesn’t unfairly punish businesses and families in coal dependent states like Missouri."

Lincoln said this week that she has "great concerns" with how the bill would affect Arkansas — noting that her commitment is to represent the people of her state, not necessarily to help the caucus get to 60 votes. "I have great concerns with what the House has done, but I haven’t seen it on this side," Lincoln said.

Arkansas State Rep. John Lowery of El Dorado told members of the U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works Tuesday that the Waxman-Markey environmental cleanup bill — if passed in its current form — would devastate South Arkansas, kill jobs, harm school systems and create a disproportionate burden on Arkansans by throwing back economic progress that’s been gained over the last few years, according to a transcript available on the Senate’s Web site.

Sen Nelson (D-Neb): "have to ensure it does not raise utilities rates or include "anything that would adversely impact agriculture."  – And Sen. Ben Nelson (D-Neb.) said that to win his support, the bill will have to ensure it does not raise utilities rates or include "anything that would adversely impact agriculture." He said he has discussed the bill with Sen. John Kerry (D-Mass.) and passed on some of his concerns to Boxer.

Senator Jay Rockefeller "serious concerns": – Jessica Tice, Rockefeller’s state press secretary, said the senator "followed the process in the House on the climate change legislation very closely" and "continues to have serious concerns about the House bill." Tice also said Rockefeller will "continue working with his colleagues to make sure West Virginia’s interests are represented." Protestors gathered at the conference Tuesday said the bill’s "cap and trade" concept is misleading and will only drive up costs for Americans.

Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.): "I just generally don’t like many things about the House bill," added Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.). "But I’m open to discuss how we can move forward to make our energy grid greener. How we can move to the next generation of energy supply, and most importantly how to get American energy secure. That goal cannot be done without increasing traditional oil and gas production." Landrieu did not rule out voting in favor of the Senate climate bill. But she said that her price for support would entail at least setting aside specific allocations for the oil and gas industry, as well as greater domestic energy production."That would move in the right direction, and we’re working on that now," she said.

###