Posted by: David Lungren  David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

EPW FACT OF THE DAY: FREE-MARKET?

It is convenient for green opponents of free-markets to assume the banner of Adam Smith when speaking of cap-and-trade.  This preferred mechanism to reduce greenhouse gases is so effective and so efficient, they argue, because it is “market-based” or “market driven,” a veritable invisible hand that decides how and when reductions are made.  To paraphrase Smith, it is not from the benevolence of the power plant owner, the refiner or the manufacturer, that we expect emissions reductions, but “from their regard to their own self interest” under a cap-and-trade system.  Moreover, Smith wrote, “We address ourselves, not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities but of their advantages.”

One such champion of markets is Fred Krupp, president of Environmental Defense, who stated earlier this year that his organization “believes the most powerful cost control measure is a robust cap-and-trade program since markets do the best job of controlling costs over time.”  “A cap-and-trade program,” he continued, “will unleash entrepreneurs to find new low-carbon technologies and better ways of reducing emissions.  With such a program we are creating performance-based demand across the board, across the whole economy, to reduce greenhouse gases http://energycommerce.house.gov/Press_111/20080115krupp.pdf.”  And during a July 16th hearing on climate change policy in the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, a prominent Senate supporter of cap-and-trade summed up the approach thus: “I am not going to pick the winners and losers.  The marketplace is going to do it.”

FACT: When it comes to writing legislation, however, these cheerleaders of markets sing a different tune.  Take the Waxman-Markey bill as a salient example.  The centerpiece of Waxman-Markey is a cap-and-trade scheme, but a significant portion of the bill is a liberal litany of mandates, including, but not limited to: a renewable electricity standard (Section 101); performance standards for new coal plants (Section 116); greater efficiency in building codes (Section 201); lighting efficiency standards (211); appliance efficiency standards (Section 212); auto emissions standards (Section 221); and industrial plant energy efficiency standards (Section 241).  Or, as a recent Washington Post editorial put it, the bill “contains regulations on everything from light bulb standards to the specs on hot tubs, and it will reshape America’s economy in dozens of ways that many don’t realize …”

These provisions are just some of “complementary measures and policies” mentioned by green groups as necessary adjuncts to cap-and-trade legislation.   One such “complementary measure” was mentioned recently by David Doniger, climate policy director of the Natural Resources Defense Council.  According to a report in BNA, Doniger said he believes that cap-and-trade legislation should “preserve EPA authority to set emissions limits for coal-fired power plants under Section 111 of the Clean Air Act.”  In an even more astonishing statement—which seems to contradict Krupp’s statements mentioned above—Doniger said “the emissions trading program alone may not be strong enough to control emissions…because it also would allow plants to comply by obtaining offsets generated by emissions reductions at other sources or through agricultural practices that sequester carbon.”

###