Posted by Matt Dempsey matt_dempsey@epw.senate.gov

Dismal Outlook For Climate Bill As Congress Returns From August Recess

“Recipe For Disaster” – “Democrats Skeptical” – “Climate Bill Slog”

Inhofe EPW News Round Up

Reuters – U.S. Senate Democrats Skeptical About Climate Bill (09/10/09) – WASHINGTON, Sept 9 (Reuters) – Several U.S. Senate Democrats, including a top leader, on Wednesday questioned whether it would be possible to vote on a climate change bill this year, especially with healthcare reform eating up so much of the lawmakers’ time. "It’s a difficult schedule" with many members already "anxious" about healthcare reform, Senator Dick Durbin, the second-ranking Democrat, told Reuters when asked about prospects this year for a bill to cap emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. President Barack Obama is engaged in the toughest fight of his presidency in trying to win passage of expanded healthcare. Obama also has called on Congress to approve legislation this year to control climate change by reducing pollutants from utilities, oil refineries and factories. Besides the need to pass the complex healthcare bill this year, which Durbin said was "first in the queue," he also noted the need to tackle legislation imposing stricter rules on the U.S. financial industry.Durbin said it was unclear whether the climate bill or financial industry reform would be a higher priority in 2009. With most Senate Republicans expected to oppose a climate change bill in the 100-member Senate, nearly all of the 60 seats controlled by Democrats would have to line up in favor of the legislation for it to clear procedural hurdles.

Inside EPA  – Senators Offer No Firm Plan For Passing Cap-And-Trade This Year (09/10/09) – Senate leaders have set no firm deadline for committees to finish work on climate change legislation, a revelation that comes amid increasing talk that the chamber may be unable or unwilling to act on a controversial cap-and-trade plan before the end of the year given a host of other competing concerns. In interviews, Democratic lawmakers were split on whether the Senate can or should even try to enact climate legislation ahead of December talks in Copenhagen aimed at crafting a new global climate change treaty, and none put forward a clear plan for how the chamber will tackle the issue. Given the dwindling amount of time left for lawmakers to address the topic this year, some senators suggested Congress may be better off passing piecemeal measures, such as a utility-only cap-and-trade scheme, or simply leaving the issue for EPA to handle. In late August, Senate Environment & Public Works Committee Chair Barbara Boxer (D-CA) and Sen. John Kerry (D-MA), chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, announced their climate bill would not be introduced until at least the end of this month, the most recent in a series of delays for the bill’s introduction…The lack of a firm deadline — or a public consensus on the plan even from committee chairmen tasked with drafting aspects of the bill — may be an indication Senate leaders are not fully committed to holding a vote on climate legislation before the end of the year.  Senate Energy & Natural Resources Committee Chairman Jeff Bingaman (D-NM), for instance, said in an interview that “there hasn’t been a lot of discussion” within the Senate about the climate and energy agenda for the rest of the year, evidence the health care debate has been dominating lawmakers’ attention. That said, he didn’t rule out that there would be some form of action. “My expectation is that we are going to move forward,” he said. “Once health care is done, that is next up on the agenda.”

E & E Publishing – Cap and trade in Senate limbo as Obama Makes All-Out Push on Health Care (09/08/09) – President Obama’s energy and global warming agenda stands at a major crossroads as lawmakers return today from their monthlong summer break amid an all-out push to pass health care legislation. Senate Democrats originally intended to roll out their version of a cap-and-trade climate bill this week, but they have since delayed that schedule until later this month in part because of the brewing battle over health care. Gone is the immediacy for action on global warming, and there is even talk that passing a climate bill this year has faded to third place on the administration’s agenda behind financial reform legislation that responds to last year’s Wall Street meltdown. Asked last week about prospects for the Senate climate bill, White House spokesman Robert Gibbs changed the subject and instead predicted a "major push" from Obama and Congress to pass a bill that heads off any future financial crisis.

Politico – Baucus Makes a Grab for Climate Bill (09/11/09) – For liberal Democrats unhappy with the way Max Baucus is handling health care reform, here’s another dose of bad news: He’s got his hands on climate and energy, too. Behind closed doors, Sen. Baucus has been staking his claim on major aspects of the climate bill, including financing for a cap-and-trade system.

NYT – Nations Remain Divided on Global Warming Policy, U.S. Negotiator Says (09/11/09) – The Obama administration’s senior negotiator on global warming warned Thursday that developed and developing nations remained deeply divided in talks on reducing greenhouse gases and that time was running out before United Nations treaty negotiations in December.

Cap-and-Trade: Recipe for Disaster, Economist Says (09/10/09) – If you liked what Enron, AIG, and the Federal Reserve did to the economy, you’ll love cap and trade. That’s the thrust of a new paper from Louisiana State University economist Joseph Mason. Cap-and-trade programs, like the one passed by the House and simmering in the Senate, pose a couple of big problems, he says: They don’t work, and they can gum up the rest of the economy.

The Hill – Climate lobby urges Democrats to Reject Pressure to Accept Modest Energy Gains (09/09/09) – If healthcare poisons the well for climate change, some observers expect Democrats to settle for more modest environmental gains. Ditching the cap-and-trade piece to pass a so-called renewable electricity standard and stronger energy-use standards could give Democrats a partial win and President Barack Obama at least something to show off at the climate talks in Copenhagen, Denmark, in December. But it would also threaten to fracture Democrats and their base of support, in much the same way the public option is threatening to split the party in the healthcare fight.

Reuters – Senate Agriculture Chair Lincoln Sees Climate Bill Slog (09/10/09) – WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Senate faces "a heavy lift" if it tries to pass a climate change bill this year, the new leader of the Senate Agriculture Committee, Blanche Lincoln, said on Wednesday. Lincoln, a second-term Democrat from Arkansas, succeeds Tom Harkin of Iowa, an advocate of public nutrition and land stewardship programs. Lincoln is a staunch defender of crop subsidies and founder of a Senate group that focuses on hunger. She will be the first woman to head the Agriculture Committee. Senate Democrats announced her selection after Harkin opted to become chairman of the Health Committee. The formalities of the turnover are expected to take a few days."All I’m saying is I think it (passage of a climate bill) is a heavy lift for the Senate" in a session filled with major legislation, she said.

NYT – Health Care to Be a Stumbling Block on Road to Copenhagen  (09/08/09) – The Senate’s newest round of delays on global warming legislation has some current and former climate negotiators worried about prospects for a global emissions deal this year in Copenhagen. Environmental activists insist that Sen. Barbara Boxer’s (D-Calif.) announcement that she will push back introduction of her climate bill in the wake of Sen. Edward Kennedy’s (D-Mass.) death is insignificant. But others said that Democrats’ desire to realize health care reform — which Kennedy called "the cause of my life" and which at least one senator has suggested renaming in Kennedy’s memory — makes it all but certain that climate legislation won’t see the Senate floor this year. "Even if Senator Kennedy had been alive and well, health care probably wouldn’t have been able to pass until the fall. With his unfortunate passing, it means the debate will be prolonged," said Stuart Eizenstat, who was the lead U.S. negotiator on the 1997 Kyoto Protocol. "The Congress as an institution has difficulty doing a lot of things at the same time," Eizenstat said. Climate change this year "is going to be a casualty. We will not have a bill signed by the president by Copenhagen."