Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
EPW POLICY BEAT: COAL, CCS AND CRS
As debate proceeds on the Kerry-Boxer bill, there will undoubtedly be myriad attempts to cut deals to secure votes. If the past is prologue, coal will be center stage. The parameters of the "deal" for coal have largely been framed by the extent to which Congress provides financial support (through explicit funding and bonus allowances) for carbon capture and sequestration (CCS). There’s reason to believe much the same will happen again. Yet this CCS "deal" misses the mark. That’s because funding is one mere facet of the intricately (some might say infinitely) complex and convoluted web of regulatory policy issues that could very well engulf, and even overwhelm, the CCS enterprise. And in a cap-and-trade regime, no CCS means no coal.
For the record, neither Kerry-Boxer nor Waxman-Markey comes close to untangling the CCS web. And judging by the posture of each bill’s strongest supporters, the great untangling is unlikely to happen any time soon. Yet, funding CCS without also attaching the necessary regulatory and policy clarifications to build CCS is a fool’s errand, providing no consolation to investors (and ultimately ratepayers) who will assume considerable financial and legal risk. And it’s therefore ultimately no help to coal, which Kerry-Boxer and Waxman-Markey would just as well see driven to extinction.
Consider a January 2008 report by the Congressional Research Service (CRS). CRS constructed a hypothetical CCS pipeline scenario for 11 major coal-fired electric power plants in the Midwest Carbon Sequestration Partnership (Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia). One function served by the CRS exercise is that the real-world implications of actually building the necessary infrastructure to support CCS come into view. As CRS wrote, "Infrastructure requirements and policy implications related to CO2 pipelines become clearer when considering what actual pipeline projects might look like."
It’s worth noting that the CRS study focused mostly on pipelines, leaving aside liability and other practical policy issues. And yet just with this aspect alone, CRS found a wealth of trouble, not the least of which is the state-by-state siting and approval process. "The state-by-state siting approval process for CO2 pipelines," CRS wrote, "may be complex and protracted, and may face public opposition, especially in populated or environmentally sensitive areas." To illustrate the point, CRS cites the August 2007 decision by the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission, which "rejected a developer’s proposal to construct a new coal-fired power plant in the state, in large part because the associated costs of a 450-mile CO2 pipeline to an EOR site in Alberta, over $635 million, were not viewed to be in the public interest."
On top of problems with state-by-state reviews, CRS believes "questions might arise as to the right of easement holders to install CO2 pipelines, compensation for use of such easements, and whether existing easements can be sold or leased to CO2 pipeline companies." CRS further states that "if a widespread, interstate CO2 pipeline network is required to support CCS, the ability to site these pipelines may become an issue requiring new federal initiatives."
Based on the evidence, a large interstate network may be required, and some states may be losers. For example, CRS cites a 2007 Duke University study, which concluded that "geologic sequestration is not economically or technically feasible within North Carolina," but "may be viable if the captured CO2 is piped out of North Carolina and stored elsewhere." Likewise, according to CRS, "states in the Northeast, Minnesota, Wisconsin, and possibly parts of other states appear to lack geological formations with potential for large-scale sequestration of the volumes of CO2 they produce. If national CCS policies are implemented, power plants and other CO2-producing facilities in these states may face more extensive, and more costly, pipeline requirements than other states if they are to sequester their CO2."
In addition to interstate pipeline networks, a large number of sequestration reservoirs may be needed, carrying an additional set of challenges. "If CCS moves to widespread implementation," CRS concludes, "government agencies and private companies may face challenges in identifying, permitting, developing, and monitoring the large number of localized sequestration reservoirs that may be proposed." Moreover, "even as viable sequestration reservoirs are being identified, it is unclear which CO2 source facilities will have access to them, under what time frame, and under what conditions."
CRS says that resolving the aforementioned issues will "require sustained attention and the input of many stakeholders to refine and address them." Yet, as noted, the two leading cap-and-trade bills pay mere lip service to the CCS web. CRS states that "many billions of dollars of capital investment" are on the line. And so, too, is coal’s future.
###