Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

Inhofe EPW Rapid Response :

EPA ‘Discussion Paper’ of Kerry-Boxer Is Incomplete

   www.epw.senate.gov/inhofeblog

 

EPA refers to its 38-page document as "a discussion paper." By contrast, Republicans provided Democrats in 2005 with 10,000 pages of analysis for the Clear Skies bill.

EPA’s paper fails to provide comprehensive analysis. There is no analysis of impacts on consumers, electricity prices, gasoline prices, food prices, households, different regions of the country, and industrial sectors of the economy.

EPA’s assumptions about CCS are seriously flawed. Kerry-Boxer could make CCS deployment less likely than Waxman-Markey. On page 14, EPA contends that fewer bonus allowances are available under Kerry-Boxer than Waxman-Markey because of its more stringent 2020 cap.

EPA ignores flaws in Waxman-Markey analysis. EPA states that, "Because of these many similarities and the relatively small differences between the two bills, it is likely that a full analysis of S. 1733 would show economic impacts very similar to H.R. 2454." But EPA’s analysis of Waxman-Markey is incomplete. EPA rejected a request from Senators Inhofe and Voinovich to model more realistic assumptions about the growth of nuclear power, the availability of offsets, and the prospects for international action to reduce emissions.

EPA says cap-and-trade brings flexibility, but doesn’t model cap with Kerry-Boxer’s mandates. EPA states, "The cap-and-trade policy often is carefully crafted to afford sources numerous flexibilities that further decrease the costs of compliance, such as the option to purchase offsets from non-covered sources." Yet Kerry-Boxer includes building and appliance efficiency standards, new source performance standards for coal-fired power plants and other sources. EPA failed to model the simultaneous adoption of cap-and-trade with command-and-control mandates.

EPA minimizes and glosses over key differences between Kerry-Boxer and Waxman-Markey. The most obvious is the 2020 emissions cap, which calls for a 20 percent reduction below 2005 levels, while Waxman-Markey requires 17 percent below 2005 levels. EPA ignores the fact that Kerry-Boxer allocates 1.46 billion fewer allowances between 2012 and 2030 because of its more stringent cap. Making up this shortfall would cost between $25.2 billion (EPA allowance prices) and $48.3 billion (NBCC/CRA allow prices). Similarly, K-B allocates 487 million fewer allowances to protect consumers from higher electricity prices. Making up this shortfall will cost electricity consumers between $8.3 billion and $15.8 billion.

###