Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

Regional Disparities Highlighted in EPW Hearing

 

Heartland to Pay the Price for Kerry-Boxer Bill

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

WASHINGTON, DC – Testifying before the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee today, Barry Hart, Chief Executive Officer of the Association of Missouri Electric Cooperatives and Dustin Johnson, Commissioner of the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission both raised serious concerns with regional disparities associated with the Kerry-Boxer cap-and-trade bill. Senator James Inhofe (R – Okla.) expressed his concerns that Oklahomans would pay a much higher cost and asked the two witnesses to respond.

Senator Inhofe:  “Since I’m also in the heartland, in the Midwest, I’d like to have both of you respond to this.  Because I’ve seen the same charts, I’ve seen how we’re going to be treated.  Oklahoma is right between you guys. So would you like to, can you help me understand why we still believe that our costs would be greater?”

Dustin Johnson, Commissioner of the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission:  “Thank you very much Senator. I do want to make it clear that regional disparities are some of the things that bother us the most.  No one on this panel has argued for inaction.  No one on this panel has said that carbon shouldn’t come with some price.  The concerns that have been raised have been primarily around regional disparities.  And I do think that’s a big problem.  When we start talking about a postage stamp a day, or we talk about a hundred dollars a year, those are national numbers and I think they gloss over the very real and the very problematic regional disparities.  You know, $5 from South Dakotans – I don’t believe it. Most of that analysis has been done on flawed presumptions that the energy that is created in South Dakota is used in South Dakota.  The federal government has not allowed us to do that.  We have a lot of hydroelectric facilities in South Dakota – 80% of that power leaves the state.  So all of the numbers I’ve seen about South Dakota are based on some very, very flawed presumptions.”

Barry Hart, Chief Executive Officer of the Association of Missouri Electric Cooperatives:  “Senator, in Missouri, I mean, that’s why, because there are all these different studies, the people that live in Missouri wanted to know from the people generating kilowatt hours – whether its wind farms, nuclear, natural gas, hydro – they wanted their professionals, the men and women generating kilowatt hours, to tell them this is what it’s going to cost us.  Now, the numbers I see under the different scenarios, one was $25 a ton for carbon, another was $50 a ton for carbon, various assumptions they made under different cases, but the rate increases you’re talking like 42-77%. And those are the people who are generating kilowatt hours every day, and I guess the regional disparity is what the people that live in Missouri are keying in on too.  They’re telling all of us that they don’t understand why utilities in California get 100% allocation of emissions and Missouri gets 68.”

###