Contact:

Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov (202) 224-9797

David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov (202) 224-5642

U.S. Senator George V. Voinovich sent the following letter to EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson today questioning the need for, and motive behind, this afternoon’s repetitive EPA briefing of the EPW Committee:

Link to Letter  

 

Please see full text of the letter below:

Administrator Lisa Jackson

USEPA Ariel Rios Building

1200 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W.

Washington, DC 20004

 

Dear Administrator Jackson:

I understand that your staff will be briefing the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works today on the agency’s assessment of S. 1733, the Kerry-Boxer bill.  I assume the purpose of this briefing is three-fold: to allow EPA to explain why its work on S. 1733 provides enough detail for the committee to move forward with consideration of the bill; to allow EPA to explain that there are only minor differences between S. 1733 and H.R. 2454, the Waxman-Markey bill; and to allow EPA to explain why its analysis of Waxman-Markey addresses all of the concerns expressed by many of my colleagues and me.

I appreciate the Chairman’s willingness to provide additional time to deliberate over EPA’s work before proceeding to a markup.  Additionally, I appreciate your staff providing the committee with an explanation of its work.  However, I question the need for this briefing.  The issue before us is not whether we understand EPA’s 38-page discussion paper on S. 1733 and its current analysis of Waxman-Markey.  Rather, the issue is that the committee lacks a full analysis, with modeling runs, of S. 1733.  Having a briefing does nothing to change that. 

The briefing is unnecessary for another reason: EPA has already agreed to do full modeling of the bill with inputs and assumptions that provide a more comprehensive and accurate picture of how it would affect our nation’s economy, jobs, energy prices, and our energy security.  As you are aware, our staffs negotiated together with EPA’s modelers over several weeks to reach an agreement.  Subsequently, on a bipartisan basis, we should be able to secure EPA’s full analysis.  No more negotiation is needed.  In my view, should Chairman Boxer choose to give her consent, EPA can begin to work on this long-negotiated agreement immediately.  Once the results are made public, I would be more than happy to release my hold on the nomination of Mr. Persciasepe to be Deputy Administrator of EPA.  

As you know, EPA has agreed to modeling with the following inputs and assumptions:

Moreover, EPA has agreed that in future computer modeling analyses of climate legislation, the agency will include model scenarios that reflect potential constraints on the availability and deployment of clean energy technologies and the availability of offsets.  Such information will provide for better informed policy debates and allow the United States Senate to more accurately formulate amendments that are consistent with our respective policy goals. 

I appreciate your persistence and good faith in negotiation.  It is my sincere  hope that Senator Boxer will provide her consent and allow the time for you to go forward with the analysis we’ve agreed to so that the Environment and Public Works Committee, as well as the United States Senate is fully informed to debate this very important issue.

Sincerely,

 

George V. Voinovich

United States Senator

###