Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
In Case You Missed It . . .
E&E News
Reid gives Boxer green light for ‘nuclear option’
By: Darren Samuelsohn, E&E senior reporter
November 04, 2009
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) has given the chairwoman of the Environment and Public Works Committee the go-ahead to advance global warming legislation by Tuesday if Republicans have not ended their boycott by then, according to three sources close to the process.
Chairwoman Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) originally wanted to push forward tomorrow with debate and votes on amendments to the 959-page climate bill.
But the sources say Reid urged Boxer to wait until Tuesday, Nov. 10. The markup was originally scheduled to begin yesterday, but the committee’s GOP members are boycotting in an effort to force U.S. EPA to further study the climate proposal.
"Makes them look like the ‘party of no,’" one source said. "Makes them look frivolous."
As of press time, Boxer was huddling with EPW Committee Democrats to discuss their strategy on the climate bill over the coming days. As she entered the closed-door meeting, Boxer said she would remain in the Capitol into the evening for Republicans to return to the negotiation table.
Aides to Boxer and Reid declined comment on the schedule that Reid and Boxer discussed earlier this week. But Boxer earlier today signaled she was losing her patience with Republicans after they twice ignored her deadline for submitting amendments and also rebuffed two offers to publicly question a top EPA official about the models that the agency has already run on the House-passed bill and its Senate counterpart.
"Stay tuned," she said. "You’ll know very soon."
Senate aides say Boxer is weighing whether to proceed under a new interpretation of the EPW Committee’s rules that allows her to start and finish the markup so long as a majority of the panel’s members are present, rather than long-standing precedent requiring two minority members to be in attendance. Boxer and Democratic leaders also could use Senate Rule 14, which allows the majority to discharge legislation out of a committee and bring it directly to the floor. About 80 Democratic amendments have been submitted for the markup, but it is unclear how many will be brought up for consideration.
"Let me just say, we’ll follow the rules," Boxer said today. "The rules are written in the Senate committees for reasons. And the reasons are to make sure we can do our work. Can you imagine if, and regardless of who’s in charge, there’s never an ability to move a bill out? That would paralyze the nation."
EPW Committee ranking member James Inhofe (R-Okla.) warned Boxer earlier not to move the climate bill in violation of the long-standing committee precedent, calling it "the nuclear option" that could disrupt progress on other legislative items. Inhofe and the other GOP committee members stayed away from this afternoon’s staff-led briefing on the details of the climate bill.
But Inhofe’s spokesman did stop by the hearing room to circulate a letter sent today on their behalf to EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson from four critical Republican moderates seen as potential swing votes on the floor: Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, Judd Gregg of New Hampshire and Maine’s Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins.
"As senators interested in a bipartisan approach to addressing climate change and energy independence this Congress, we have a keen interest in ensuring that cost estimates, models and other data critical to the legislative process be made available to members of Congress and the public in a timely manner," the four senators wrote. "We cannot support legislation without this information."
The Republican senators’ letter urged EPA to deliver the economic models on the Senate bill "prior to any action in EPW."
Graham’s signature came within hours of his appearance at a press conference where he reaffirmed his role in working toward a bipartisan compromise on the climate proposal with Sens. John Kerry (D-Mass.) and Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.).
Graham told reporters he was "sympathetic" to the GOP boycott on the EPW panel, which builds off a 3-month-old request for information at EPA sought by Sen. George Voinovich (R-Ohio).
"I’d probably be where Senator Voinovich is at," Graham said. "I think he’s a pretty constructive guy, and I think he’s got some legitimate concerns."
But Graham also said he was trying to work with the Democrats and Obama administration on legislation that squeezes together both climate change and more supply-side energy production, including nuclear power and offshore oil and gas production.
"I hope my Republican colleagues will at least listen, come to the table as the chamber has, see where we’re going, give us input, and if at the end of the day they can’t support it, that’s OK," Graham said.
Kerry, Graham and Lieberman touted a letter sent yesterday to Boxer and Inhofe from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce that spelled out in greater detail where it stands on the climate bill. Kerry called the chamber’s letter "essential." And Graham said the group mirrors many Senate Republicans who are not quite sure where they stand on the issue.
"The chamber letter sort of reflects where a lot of people are," Graham said. "This sounds intriguing."
Senators, White House talk
The three senators also held a series of meetings today in the Capitol with Energy Secretary Steven Chu, Interior Secretary Ken Salazar and White House energy adviser Carol Browner — all aimed at gleaning where the Obama administration stands on the critical issues at the center of the climate and energy bill.
"Our effort is to try to reach out, to broaden the base of support, beyond the committees of jurisdiction," Kerry said. "We’re going to do that working very closely with the chairs of those committees, as well as members across the Senate. The key here is really to negotiate once, not negotiate with ourselves, and not negotiate just in the Senate and not have the White House also at the table."
Kerry insisted that the three senators would keep their focus on closed-door negotiations in an efforts to win over more than 60 votes on the proposal. "We’re just at the beginning stage," he said. "One thing I’ll say, we’re not going to negotiate this publicly, day by day, drip by drip. We’re going to do this in a way that maximizes the privacy of putting something like this together."
Ultimately, Kerry said he hopes to deliver a legislative package to Reid that includes input from leaders of the six Senate committees with jurisdiction over the issue, as well as members off the committees. Reid is scheduled to meet in the "next week or so" with the six chairmen, Reid spokesman Jim Manley said yesterday.
Lieberman, one of the original co-sponsors of climate legislation, said he expects the final climate bill to include significant backing for building new nuclear power plants. Nuclear industry officials are seeking several times the $18.5 billion for new plant loan guarantees that Congress has already provided and the Energy Department plans to divide among a handful of companies soon.
Lieberman declined to put a dollar figure on the new support he envisions.
Elsewhere, Lieberman cited increased streamlining of the new reactor licensing process, nuclear work force development and support for waste recycling technologies.
Compromise efforts on nuclear power will not be the subject of amendments in the EPW Committee but rather during the floor debate, he said. "I don’t expect that the work we’ve been doing will lead anyone involved to offer amendments," Lieberman said. "It will be more part of this process, or on the floor."
Click here to read the letter from the four Republicans.
Senior reporter Ben Geman contributed.
###