Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

Dems Comment On Cap and Tax Prospects in 2010:

"Impossible to Pass" – "Drop Cap and Trade" – "Unlikely This Year"

Inhofe EPW News Round-Up

 

Politico: Dems to W.H.: Drop cap and trade – Bruised by the health care debate and worried about what 2010 will bring, moderate Senate Democrats are urging the White House to give up now on any effort to pass a cap-and-trade bill next year. "I am communicating that in every way I know how," said Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.), one of at least a half-dozen Democrats who’ve told the White House or their own leaders that it’s time to jettison the centerpiece of their party’s plan to curb global warming.  The creation of an economywide market for greenhouse gas emissions is the heart of the climate bill that cleared the House earlier this year. The creation of an economywide market for greenhouse gas emissions is the heart of the climate bill that cleared the House earlier this year. But with the health care fight still raging and the economy still hurting, moderate Democrats have little appetite for another sweeping initiative – especially another one likely to pass with little or no Republican support.

AP: Bingaman: Cap and Trade Bill Unlikely This Year  – ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. (AP) — The chairman of the U.S. Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee said Tuesday that it’s unclear whether Congress will be able to pass cap and trade legislation aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions this year. Sen. Jeff Bingaman, D-N.M., said there’s no consensus on what form a cap-and-trade system would take, but strong desire exists in both the Senate and House to pass other energy-related bills that would curb pollution blamed for global warming.

Star Tribune: Peterson flips on climate change  – Blue Dog Democrat Collin Peterson, who played a major role securing rural lawmakers’ support for cap-and-trade climate legislation this summer, now says he would vote "no" if a similar bill returned to the House for final passage. Peterson’s possible defection could prove fatal to the bill — if it ever passes the Senate — because he is an influential voice among rural Democrats. It also may reflect how much heat he has taken from his relatively conservative district for supporting the bill

National Journal: Peterson Revives Opposition to Climate Bill – House Agriculture Chairman Collin Peterson, who supported the climate change bill passed by the House last summer, now says he will vote against a conference report if it is similar to the House version. Peterson told Scott Hennen, a Fargo, N.D.-based conservative talk show radio host, that he believes the climate change bill "is not going anyplace in the Senate." "But if it did, and we ended up with a bill that was similar to what came out of the House and that was going to become law, I would vote no," he told Hennen in a program broadcast Friday.

Politico: Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell, a Democrat, called the bill "impossible to pass" – Moderates don’t like cap and trade. Republicans question climate change. And even some liberal Democrats say there’s little chance for a climate bill to pass the Senate this year… Prospects for Senate passage of the legislation – already approved by the House last summer – have dimmed in recent months, with the bruising health care debate and looming midterm elections. Last month was particularly brutal, as environmental advocates fended off criticism of climate negotiations in Copenhagen that failed to produce a strong international agreement. Even some supporters now publicly doubt that the bill will get done this year. Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee Chairman Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D-N.M.) told The Associated Press last week that passage of the legislation was unlikely. And Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell, a Democrat, called the bill "impossible to pass" in an interview with POLITICO.

Congress Daily: Several Factors Threaten Senate Climate Agenda – A midterm election, limited supply of White House political chits and a mixed review of the impact of last month’s Copenhagen talks have clouded predictions of the Senate acting on a broad climate and energy plan this year. Democratic leaders and other supporters remain hopeful a bill can be finished. But there is no clear end to the healthcare talks. And Senate Democratic leaders who have already lined up a jobs bill and a financial regulatory measure, under pressure from key Democratic interest groups, might also give immigration reform a higher priority than climate change on the Senate calendar.

Greenwire: Obama, Senate Allies Weigh Strategy in Face of Double-Digit Unemployment –Advocates for comprehensive climate legislation should look no further than the nation’s unemployment rate as they ponder their chances for success this year.With more than 10 percent of the country’s work force currently out of a job, experts say it won’t bode well for the climate bill’s prospects if that number gets any worse."It was already difficult to achieve agreement in the Congress on climate change, but in the presence of double-digit unemployment, which it appears we’ll have for the first two quarters of 2010 and beyond that, it’ll be even more challenging," said Robert Stavins, director of Harvard University’s environmental economics program.

WSJ: States Want Delay on Emission Rules  – A growing number of state regulators are urging the Obama administration to slow the rollout of proposed federal rules curbing industrial greenhouse-gas emissions, saying the administration’s approach could overwhelm them with paperwork, delay construction projects and undercut their own efforts to fight climate change. The concerns echo some criticisms that business groups — including the American Petroleum Institute and the National Association of Manufacturers — have voiced about the potential consequence of new regulations, though the states generally don’t challenge the legality of the proposed regulations, as some business groups have. Indeed, many state regulators continue to say they support the Environmental Protection Agency’s effort to regulate greenhouse gases.

WSJ: California Cap-and-Trade Revolt  – Could Californians finally be serious about turning around their sputtering economy? One hopeful sign is a ballot initiative that would repeal the Golden State’s version of a cap-and-trade carbon tax. This feel-good law to reduce the state’s carbon footprint was enacted with great hoopla by the Democratic legislature and Republican Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger in 2006 when the state’s economy was growing and the jobless rate was 5%.

Congress Daily: Group Unanimously Opposes Climate Bill – Delegates to the American Farm Bureau Federation convention in Seattle today unanimously passed a resolution in opposition to any cap-and-trade legislation and in support of legislation suspending EPA’s authority to regulate greenhouse gases under the Clean Air Act. The resolution said the potential benefits of agricultural offsets for carbon sequestration are outweighed by the costs, and that the bill would result in the planting of trees that would reduce food production and reduce jobs. As for EPA’s proposal to use the Clean Air Act to regulate greenhouse gases, the resolution said it "would significantly burden all sectors of the economy, especially agriculture." Rep. Earl Pomeroy, D-N.D., has introduced a bill to stop EPA from moving forward with a proposal to regulate greenhouse gas emissions under the Clean Air Act..

New York Times: Farm Bureau fires back against cap-and-trade bill’s ‘power grab’  – The largest U.S. farm group will "aggressively" fight back against any attempts to change the landscape of American agriculture — including the farm bill or animal rights campaigns, American Farm Bureau Federation Bob Stallman said yesterday. In a fiery speech that kicked off the powerful farm lobby’s four-day convention in Seattle, Stallman said farmers and ranchers must unite to respond to "misguided, activist-driven regulation.""A line must be drawn between our polite and respectful engagement with consumers and how we must aggressively respond to extremists who want to drag agriculture back to the day of 40 acres and a mule," Stallman said. "The time has come to face our opponents with a new attitude. The days of their elitist power grabs are over." Members are likely to vote on resolutions declaiming cap-and-trade legislation, according to members of the organization.

SF Chronicle: Climate change bill faces tough Senate fight – It took Democratic leaders weeks of negotiations, deal-cutting and floor debate before they could squeak a broad health care overhaul bill through the Senate last month. But that was nothing compared to the challenge facing Senate leaders this spring if they press forward with controversial legislation to combat global warming. The plan to cap greenhouse gases blamed for the Earth’s rising temperature is complicated by election-year politics and fears about exacerbating the nation’s economic woes. Cap-and-trade issue – It also is hindered by moderate Democrats’ wariness about the centerpiece of the leading proposals: cap-and-trade programs that would allow carbon dioxide emitters to comply with steadily tightening greenhouse gas limits either by cutting their emissions or buying and trading.

Greenwire: U.S. Chamber Urges Obama, Congress to Rethink Climate Push – U.S. Chamber of Commerce President Tom Donohue urged Washington lawmakers today to rethink proposed climate regulations and other policies that he charged would raise costs for businesses and slow recovery from the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression. "Congress, the administration and the states must recognize that our weak economy simply could not sustain all the new taxes, regulations and mandates now under consideration," Donohue said during his annual "State of American Business" speech at the chamber’s Washington headquarters. "It’s a sure-fire recipe for a double-dip recession, or worse."

Chicago Tribune: A Political-Risk Outlook for 2010  – The Copenhagen outcome makes it even less likely that the United States Congress will pass cap-and-trade legislation in 2010. Though Obama’s political advisers see a big push for cap-and-trade as a way to energize the base and sharpen distinctions with Republicans ahead of November’s midterm elections, they don’t have an international treaty to use as a pressure tactic to move votes forward in the Senate. Opponents of the legislation will use the absence of a substantive agreement with China as further reason to balk at American commitments. Moderate Democratic Senators in poor and energy-intensive states strongly oppose the climate-change measure and will not provide the votes that Obama needs.

The Hill: Grassley: Energy bill likely in 2010; cap-and-trade unlikely – The Senate will move on energy and environmental issues in 2010, but not cap-and-trade legislation, Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) asserted Tuesday. Grassley said that the Senate is likely to take up an energy bill, perhaps including a renewable electricity standard, but not the controversial emissions reduction system approved last year by the House but left undone by the Senate. "I think you can expect everything but cap-and-trade," Grassley said in a conference call with agricultural reporters. "I think it’s fair to say that there will be an energy bill taken up."

BNA – Dorgan Retirement Adds to Uncertainty Over Future Energy, Climate Policy in Senate – The surprise announcement Jan. 5 by Sen. Byron Dorgan (D-N.D.) that he will not seek re-election in November creates even more uncertainty for Democrats hoping to pass energy and climate legislation in the Senate. Dorgan’s decision to end his 30-year congressional career will leave his Senate seat as a real toss-up in a state that has voted Republican in recent presidential elections.

Guardian UK: James Hansen rails against cap-and-trade plan in open letter – Hansen’s letter advocates using the fee-and-dividend approach to reducing carbon emissions, rather than cap-and-trade. Fee-and-dividend is a "transparent, honest approach that benefits the public", he says, in contrast to cap-and-trade, which "is a hidden tax … because cap-and-trade increases the cost of energy for the public, as utilities and other industries purchase the right to pollute with one hand, adding it to fuel prices, while with the other hand they take back most of the permit revenues from the government. Costs and profits of the trading infrastructure are also added to the public’s energy bill."

###