Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov
EPW POLICY BEAT: THE BUDGET
We kick off our series on the Obama Administration’s FY 2011 budget, paying special attention to those provisions affecting energy and environmental policies. One such is the proposed reinstatement of the Superfund Tax. The aim of the Superfund program-to clean up hazardous waste sites-is no doubt a worthy one, but the tax is punitive, its reach widespread, and its ultimate cost borne by consumers. This probably explains why the proposed reinstatement of the tax is buried in page 175 of the budget’s "Analytical Perspectives" document.
If you own a small business, take heed: the tax is assessed at a rate of 0.12 percent on corporate "alternative minimum taxable" income in excess of $2 million-regardless of whether a corporation is responsible for polluting a site. This "corporate environmental income tax" comes on top of a 40 percent corporate tax rate that is already nearly 15 percentage points higher than most corporate rates in Europe. And for consumers concerned about prices at the gas pump, prepare to pay more: the re-imposition of the Superfund tax would mean an excise tax of 9.7 cents per barrel on crude oil and imported petroleum products (which, incidentally, would come on top of other taxes the Administration wants to impose on the oil sector).
So in the end, consumers pay more, competitiveness declines, all with no demonstrable improvement to the environment. That’s because, according to EPA, "responsible parties"-as they are deemed under Superfund-already pay for more than 70 percent of clean-ups. And there’s simply no basis for the activist trope that re-imposing the Superfund Tax will mean more and faster clean-ups. Revenues from the tax do not go directly to EPA. Moreover, the level of expenditures from the Superfund trust fund is set annually by Congress through the appropriations process-regardless of whether the tax is reinstated.
Related:
EPA Needs to Provide Better Data to Congress to Make Superfund Program Work – GAO
###