Posted by: David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

"Blizzard of Lies" – "A Perfect Storm" – "The Edifice Falls"

Inhofe EPW Press Round-up

Washington Post:  Senators to propose abandoning cap-and-trade  – Three key senators are engaged in a radical behind-the-scenes overhaul of climate legislation, preparing to jettison the broad "cap-and-trade" approach that has defined the legislative debate for close to a decade. The sharp change of direction demonstrates the extent to which the cap-and-trade strategy — allowing facilities to buy and sell pollution credits in order to meet a national limit on greenhouse gas emissions — has become political poison. In a private meeting with several environmental leaders on Wednesday, according to participants, Sen. Lindsey O. Graham (R-S.C.), declared, "Cap-and-trade is dead." Graham and Sens. John F. Kerry (D-Mass.) and Joseph I. Lieberman (I-Conn.) have worked for months to develop an alternative to cap-and-trade, which the House approved eight months ago. 

The Hill: Senators rebrand, recast climate bill as ‘cap and trade’ becomes politically toxic – Senators trying to salvage a climate bill hope to put plenty of distance between themselves and cap-and-trade. It’s an acknowledgment that the term cap and trade has itself become a political liability."Cap-and-trade in conservative circles is widely considered a dirty phrase, right up there with abortion on demand," said Frank O’Donnell, president of the advocacy group Clean Air Watch. That leaves Sens. John Kerry (D-Mass.), Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) and Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.) moving on two fronts: Crafting a wholly different bill than last year’s House cap-and-trade plan, and continuing a re-branding campaign to revive the fortunes of climate legislation. Graham is quoted in Saturday’s Washington Post stating that "cap-and-trade is dead." But what he told New York Times columnist Tom Friedman for Sunday’s column is probably closer to the mark: "Cap-and-trade as we know it is dead."

Washington Post:  Climate scientists quizzed by British lawmakers  – But a former researcher at the University of East Anglia’s prestigious Climatic Research Unit admitted he had withheld some scientific data about global temperatures collected from around the world and written some "awful" e-mails to critics who asked to see his data. The academics were questioned by lawmakers because a cache of e-mails stolen from the research center and leaked online last year appeared to show that scientists stonewalled climate skeptics, tried to pervert the scientific peer review process, and discussed ways to dodge Freedom of Information requests. Their disclosure energized skeptics of man-made global warming, who seized on the e-mails as proof that scientists were conspiring to overstate the extent to which the earth was warming or making up the phenomenon entirely. Questioned Monday by parliament’s science committee on why the center did not make its raw climate data and methodology public, former UEA climate researcher Phil Jones said the data was withheld because it wasn’t "standard practice" to release it.

Nature Blog:  Climate-gate goes to Parliament  – British politicians got their turn to ponder the climate-gate incident today, as the House of Commons science committee held its inquiry into the email theft furore.  Today’s meeting is only one of several inquiries into allegations stemming from the theft and publication of a huge number of emails from and to climate researchers at the University of East Anglia. These allegations range from the university not dealing properly with freedom of information requests to the suggestion that the emails show global warming is a huge conspiracy. The star witness at the actually rather disappointing hearing was undoubtedly the scientist at the centre of the email web: Phil Jones, head of UEA’s Climatic Research Unit. However, people who have read any of the recent interviews with Jones (such as Nature’s) will probably not find any shocking revelations from today’s sparing.

Fox News: Gore Feels the Heat, Comes In From the Cold  – Despite an attention-grabbing appearance at an Apple shareholders meeting last week and a speech at a private IBM conference in Las Vegas, the politician-turned-Earth-advocate had been uncharacteristically silent on the topic of global warming. Meanwhile, Climate-gate has besmirched the science, scientists and politicians who back the theory of manmade climate change. Last week, Oklahoma Sen. James Inhofe — a prominent skeptic of global warming theory and the Republican leader of the Senate’s Environment and Public Works Committee — issued a request for Gore to come testify on global warming. In an interview with FoxNews.com, Inhofe said he wants Gore to appear because "it will be interesting to ask him on what science he based his movie," a film the senator considers "science fiction."

AP: Warming panel, under attack, seeks outside review  – One example of the criticism was a Senate speech earlier this month when Sen. James Inhofe, R-Okla., called problems with the IPCC "the makings of a major scientific scandal." "There is a crisis of confidence in the IPCC," Inhofe said Feb. 11. "The challenges to the integrity and credibility of the IPCC merit a closer examination by the US Congress." The panel shared the Nobel Peace Prize in 2007 with former Vice President Al Gore. The panel was created by the United Nations and the World Meteorological Organization.

Telegraph UK: A perfect storm is brewing for the IPCC  – The news from sunny Bali that there is to be an international investigation into the conduct of the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and its chairman Dr Rajendra Pachauri would have made front-page headlines a few weeks back. But while Scotland and North America are still swept by blizzards, in their worst winter for decades, there has been something of a lull in the global warming storm – after three months when the IPCC and Dr Pachauri were themselves battered by almost daily blizzards of new scandals and revelations. And one reason for this lull is that the real message of all the scandals has been lost.

Wall Street Journal:  Climate Group Plans Review  – The IPCC, which won a Nobel Peace Prize in 2007 for a report that called climate change "unequivocal" and "very likely" caused by human activity, now says it will ask a committee of independent experts to assess why the report contained some factual errors, and to make recommendations as to how the IPCC can prevent such mistakes in the future. Among the incidents that have cast doubt on the organization’s credibility: More than 1,000 emails hacked from an influential U.K. climate-research lab whose research has figured in IPCC reports suggested that scientists there were trying to squelch other researchers who challenged research linking climate change with human activity; and the IPCC expressed "regret" last month that its 2007 report erroneously claimed that Himalayan glaciers could melt by 2035.

Daily Mail UK: Head of ‘Climategate’ research unit admits sending ‘pretty awful emails’ to hide data –  The rebuke – the strongest yet from the scientific community – came as Professor Phil Jones, the researcher at the heart of the scandal, told MPs he had written ‘some pretty awful emails’ – but denied trying to suppress data.  The Climategate row, which was first revealed by the Daily Mail in November, was triggered when a hacker stole hundreds of emails sent from East Anglia’s Climatic Research Unit.  They revealed scientists plotting how to avoid responding to Freedom of Information requests from climate change sceptics.  Some even appeared to show the researchers discussing how to manipulate raw data from tree rings about historical temperatures.  In one, Professor Jones talks about using a ‘trick’ to massage figures and ‘hide the decline’.

Guardian UK: MPs’ grilling over climate emails    – Jones survives MPs’ grilling over climate emails  Gaunt and nervous, but with his ever-smiling University of East Anglia vice-chancellor beside him, Phil Jones survived his grilling by MPs – probably profoundly grateful that he did not have to face questioning from an earlier witness, the equally gaunt but far from nervous climate sceptic, Lord Lawson. Jones did his best to persuade the Commons science and technology committee that all was well in the house of climate science.

E&E:  U.N. global warming panel to seek outside review   – But the controversy has provided fodder for climate skeptics and, according to recent polls, appears to have weakened public trust in science. That’s a far cry from just three years ago, when the IPCC shared the Nobel Peace Prize with former Vice President Al Gore for creating "an ever-broader informed consensus about the connection between human activities and global warming. Now, officials announced Saturday, the panel will seek an independent review of its procedures — even as the IPCC begins work on its next assessment report, due in 2013.

Investor’s Business Daily : A Blizzard Of Lies From Al Gore – If hyperbole and chutzpah had a child, it would be the opening paragraph of Gore’s op-ed in Sunday’s New York Times. Gore surfaced from the global warming witness-protection program to opine that despite admissions of error and evidence of fraud by various agencies, we still face "an unimaginable calamity requiring large-scale, preventive measures to protect human civilization as we know it." Perhaps he’s trying to protect his investments as he knows them, for he is heavily involved in enterprises that deal with carbon offsets and green technology. If the case for climate change is shown to be demonstrably false, a lot of his green evaporates like moisture from the ocean.

NewsMax:  Al Gore Admits Errors in Climate Claims – Former Vice President Al Gore admits that mistakes have been made by the scientific community regarding the issue of climate change. In an op-ed piece for The New York Times, Gore said: "It is true that the climate panel published a flawed overestimate of the melting rate of debris-covered glaciers in the Himalayas, and used information about the Netherlands provided to it by the government, which was later found to be partly inaccurate. In addition, e-mail messages stolen from the University of East Anglia in Britain showed that scientists besieged by an onslaught of hostile, make-work demands from climate skeptics may not have adequately followed the requirements of the British freedom of information law."

NY Post:  Al’s latest global-warming whopper – Aside from clouds, water vapor accounts for as much as two-thirds of the earth’s greenhouse-gas effect. Water vapor traps heat from escaping the atmosphere — but clouds have the opposite effect (called "albedo") by reflecting the sun’s energy back into space. And snow on the ground from the IPCC’s predicted precipitation in high latitudes would have the same cooling effect as clouds. What the new research suggests is that changes in water vapor may well trump the ef fect of carbon dioxide (only a fraction of which is man-made) and methane (which has mysteriously slowed since about 1990).  This raises an intriguing question: Since the Environmental Protection Agency declared that it has the authority to regulation carbon emissions because of their presumed effect on the global climate, why hasn’t the EPA also attempted to regulate mist and fog?

The Foundry:  Morning Bell: The Edifice Falls – The latest attempt to force the U.S. economy to turn away from readily available, affordable fuels and leaving it to the tender mercies of untried, experimental and expensive technologies is a bipartisan effort by Sens. John Kerry (D-MA), Lindsey Graham (R-SC) and Joseph Lieberman (I-CT). A legislative package from them, according to The Washington Post on Saturday, would individually cap how much traditional energy the main pillars of the American economy would be able to use. This would of course cripple our economy and threaten our prosperity. Any doubts about how broad and deep this effort is are dispelled by reading the following paragraph in the Post:

Fox News:  What Gore Missed When He Broke His Silence –  Despite one Climate-gate revelation after another, Al Gore has been remarkably silent. Indeed, since the Copenhagen Climate Summit he hasn’t said anything. That is until now. He broke his silence on Sunday in the New York Times with his 1,900+ word op-ed piece. Although some of the piece responds to recent scandals involving the "e-mail messages stolen from the University of East Anglia in Britain" and the errors found in the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report, much of the response is filled with snide remarks about "climate deniers."

###