Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
In Case You Missed It…
The Salt Lake Tribune
Op-Ed: Stopping another back-door tax on Americans
By Sen. Bob Bennett, Sen. James Inhofe, Sen. John Barrasso, and Sen. David Vitter
May 07, 2010
As the Senate considers yet another attempt to pass new global warming taxes on the American people, the Obama administration is busy imposing global warming taxes and regulation through the back door.
Activist groups, with the Obama administration’s help, are hijacking existing environmental statutes in the name of fighting global warming to block domestic energy production.
One such statute is the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), signed into law by President Nixon in 1970.
NEPA was never intended to regulate greenhouse gas emissions and climate change. NEPA is designed to ensure that federal agencies carefully consider significant environmental impacts that stem from major federal actions, such as permitting a power plant or building a highway, and make the relevant information available to the public. But activist groups have distorted NEPA’s original intent.
On March 10, the citizens of Montana were informed that 61 oil and gas leases, which would help the state produce jobs and energy, were suspended after green activists, including "Wild Earth Guardians," successfully sued to oppose them. The suit claimed that the federal Bureau of Land Management (BLM), the agency responsible for issuing oil and gas leases, violated NEPA (among other statutes) on grounds that the "climate change" impacts of the leases were not considered. Green activists have initiated a similar global warming legal battle in New Mexico, where activists are blocking 34 oil and gas leases for the same reason.
Of course the "climate change impacts" of these leases are meaningless. How can one meaningfully determine how building a highway will affect global climate change? But that’s not the point; this is not about saving the planet. The activist green crusade is primarily focused on stopping America’s ability to produce domestic oil and natural gas.
One way to do that is through cap and trade legislation, which the U.S. Senate may consider in the next few weeks.
Sens. John Kerry, D-Mass., and Joe Lieberman, D-Conn., are writing a "compromise" cap and trade bill, hoping to get the 60 votes needed to pass it.
But the odds are against them. The Senate has rejected cap-and-trade three times since 2003 — with bipartisan majorities growing with each vote.
The House just barely passed the job-killing Waxman-Markey cap and trade bill last summer. Once the American people quickly grasped the high costs of the bill, several members who supported it recanted their votes. If the bill were on the House floor today, it wouldn’t pass. In short, despite the Kerry-Graham-Lieberman effort, enacting costly cap-and-trade taxes won’t happen this year.
After failing to pass their agenda in the legislature, green activists have turned to the courts. Extremists are suing widely and repeatedly, and in many cases successfully (see the Montana case above). They argue that environmental statutes that Congress passed decades ago require various forms of global warming regulation. Green activists are using this legal gambit with other well-known environmental statutes, including the Clean Air Act (CAA).
Passed in 1970, the CAA was designed to address local and regional air pollution, not greenhouse gases that are dispersed globally. In 1999, environmental groups petitioned EPA to regulate greenhouse gases from cars under the CAA. Nearly 10 years later, following a terribly flawed Supreme Court decision, the Obama administration declared last December that carbon dioxide is a pollutant that endangers public health and welfare under the CAA. This finding empowers EPA to regulate nearly every aspect of the economy — and it can do so without approval from Congress.
Last month, we introduced the NEPA Certainty Act. This bill ensures that federal agencies implementing the requirements of NEPA won’t be used to determine the global warming impacts of building highways and clean energy power plants. It also would help reduce the flood of activist-inspired litigation designed to change NEPA into a global warming prevention statute.
The attempt to use NEPA to fight global warming won’t help achieve the purpose of NEPA.
Requiring federal agencies to assess the global climate change impacts from building a road is pointless. It will only block construction of the road and the jobs and economic activity — all with no discernable benefit for global climate.
Whether through the EPA or the federal Department of the Interior (among others), the Obama administration and its activist allies are trying to make domestic energy more expensive.
The NEPA Certainty Act will stop the Obama administration from imposing backdoor energy taxes upon the American people. It will also protect NEPA’s original intent and ensure that the law is used to provide meaningful environmental information to the public.
###