Posted by David Lungren David_Lungren@epw.senate.gov

Democrats Remain Divided on Cap and Trade – Reid: Please, Just Don’t Call It "Cap and Trade" – Roll Call: Dems Want to Avoid Talking About Cap and Trade

Inhofe EPW News Roundup

The Hill: Climate Unchanged on Energy Bill – Senate Democrats remained divided over whether to bring comprehensive climate change provisions to the floor next month as part of an energy bill, even as they celebrated Thursday’s defeat of a GOP resolution viewed as a test vote on global warming legislation. By a vote of 47-53, senators rejected a procedural motion – and thus shelved a resolution (S J Res 26) sponsored by Alaska Republican Lisa Murkowski that would have overturned an EPA finding that greenhouse gases endanger human health and thus should be regulated under the Clean Air Act (PL 101-549)…Six Democrats joined all Republicans in supporting the measure. But the vote suggested that backers of climate change legislation probably remain a few votes short of the 60 they would need to overcome a filibuster.

David Roberts, Grist: How Did Murkowski Effect Climate Bill? "Not Much" – After an extraordinary amount of political capital spent by environmental groups and a veto threat from Obama, 53 votes was the best they could do just to defend the basics of climate science. Now NGOs and Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) are out spinning it as a triumph. It’s quite a spectacle: Senators who oppose congressional effort on climate voting against an agency effort to address climate because they think Congress should address climate… What does it mean for the climate and energy bill that’s coming in July? Not much.

WashPost: "They’re All Over the Place, Which Tells You There’s No Clear Direction" – But the 47 to 53 vote showed that even in the wake of the massive oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, Congress remains divided over how best to address climate change. The contentious debate, in which some lawmakers suggested federal regulation would strike a devastating blow to the economy, suggested the Senate is far from decided on whether to put a price on the industrial emissions that stem from everyday activities such as lighting a home or driving a car… "They’re all over the place, which tells you there’s no clear direction," said Bruce Josten, executive vice president for government affairs at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. "How many energy bills are floating around just in the Senate right now? It’s very confused right now."

The Hill: Democrats Remain Divided on Cap and Trade: Rockefeller – who has long been worried about how emissions limits would affect his home-state coal industry – said some lawmakers expressed concern at the meeting about the viability of the Kerry-Lieberman plan."I think there is a dominant concern [which is] ‘What’s the point of doing anything without 60 votes?’" he told reporters after the vote on the Murkowski plan. "And I think that there’s some feeling that you don’t spend time on the floor trying to figure out if you have got 60 votes. You have to understand before you go to the floor that you have got 60 votes."Asked if he thought Kerry’s plan could get 60 votes, Rockefeller replied: "I don’t think so. But I think John [Kerry] does."

Greenwire: Reid: Please, Just Don’t Call It "Cap and Trade" – Senate Democratic leaders, with Obama’s help, are planning to push ahead next month with floor debate on that energy and climate bill. But they still lack 60 votes for a measure that includes carbon dioxide limits and are looking toward a special caucus meeting Thursday to discuss the road ahead. Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) said he has not decided whether the bill will entail mandatory caps on greenhouse gases or simply focus on the Gulf of Mexico oil spill, energy efficiency and a nationwide standard for renewables. But Reid insisted after a visit to the White House yesterday that he wants to follow the lead of the House, which adopted a broad climate and energy proposal almost a year ago. "The House has already done their job on energy; we have to do ours in the Senate," Reid said. Reid added he favors placing mandatory greenhouse gas limits on industry, just not using the controversial "cap and trade" name that has been demonized by Republican opponents. "We don’t use the word ‘cap and trade,’" Reid told reporters. "That’s something that’s been deleted from my dictionary. Carbon pricing is the right term."

Roll Call: Dems Want to Avoid Talking About Cap and Trade – But while Democrats were eager to talk about plans for advancing energy legislation, one issue they wanted to avoid talking about was cap-and-trade. Both Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer (D-Md.) bristled at a question about Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell’s (R-Ky.) declaration that the House’s cap-and-trade energy proposal is dead. The House passed a bill that includes the proposal last year, but the issue has stalled in the Senate. "That’s not the bill that they have in the Senate," Pelosi told reporters. "They don’t have a cap-and-trade bill. That’s not the bill they have in the Senate." She added: "Cap-and-trade was never mentioned. That term was never mentioned" at Thursday’s meeting. Hoyer sought to clarify that while McConnell has said he is against the energy tax, he has not said he is "opposed to the energy legislation per se."

CongressDaily: Effort To Stop EPA Costly Global Warming Regs Far From Over: Thursday’s vote is not expected to be the end of congressional efforts to try to either delay EPA greenhouse gas regulations or at least restrict what industrial sources would be affected. Sen. John (Jay) Rockefeller, D-W.Va., has a proposal to put a two-year timeout on EPA regulations the agency is looking to start implementing in January. Rockefeller voted for Murkowski’s resolution. One of Rockefeller’s co-sponsors — Sen. Byron Dorgan, D-N.D. — said he expects a vote on the Rockefeller plan but is unclear on timing. Murkowski has said she would support Rockefeller as well "if there is a path forward" for it, her spokesman said. One Senate Democrat speaking on condition of anonymity said Majority Leader Reid has explicitly said there will be a vote on Rockefeller’s plan.

MotherJones: Prospects for Cap and Trade Remain Dim: But very few of those voting for today’s resolution have expressed much enthusiasm about the Senate passing a new law this year. While Murkowski’s loss might make some folks optimistic, it still means that there are 41 Republicans and six Democrats who think that it’s okay to tell the EPA that science doesn’t matter, and neither does the Supreme Court.  It depends on how you want to look at it.

###