Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In Case You Missed It… 

Tulsa World  

Response to ozone proposal criticized

by JIM MYERS World Washington Bureau

Monday, June 14, 2010

Link to Article

WASHINGTON – Stances carved out by Oklahoma Gov. Brad Henry and his lead air-quality agency on the Obama administration’s push to beef up smog standards represent a lost chance to stand up for the state and weigh in on an issue with important economic consequences, some officials say.

As critics warned earlier this year that tougher ozone standards would force Tulsa County and at least a dozen others onto the dreaded dirty-air list, Henry and the Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality initially took a pass on commenting. Later, the state produced a softer response than one submitted when the Bush administration proposed tougher standards.

In the response, neither Henry, who endorsed President Obama in 2008, nor the DEQ, cited concerns the state spelled out in 2007 with the Bush proposal. DEQ took the unusual stance that it would not comment at all until the Obama administration made its decision.

The state agency did respond, however, in the public comment period and appears to have pulled back from where it was with the Bush administration’s proposal.

Neither Henry nor the DEQ commented on the handling of the response to the EPA.

U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Okla., a major player on environmental issues in Congress, expressed concern the state missed an important opportunity.

Inhofe is a vocal critic of the Obama approach on ozone and issued a warning concerning the serious consequences that Oklahoma could face for violating the proposed standard.

He had hoped to present a united front to EPA.

"I’ve always gotten along fine with Brad Henry, but I think we could have used him to be every bit as strong against the Obama (proposal) as he was against Bush,” Inhofe said.

"I think that would have been very reasonable. We could have used his influence there because he would have more influence over the Obama administration than, frankly, I would.”

He commented after comparing a letter DEQ submitted in 2007, under President Bush, to the letter DEQ submitted earlier this year to the proposal President Obama’s EPA put forward.

"It is a bit disheartening to see the change in response from the administration in Oklahoma,” Inhofe said.

Although the two DEQ letters cover some of the same areas of concern, certain wording has been omitted.

For example, the 2007 letter said that nine of 11 urban recording sites would indicate nonattainment if the standard was put at one level and all would be out of attainment if the standard was more strict.

It stated that Congress never contemplated an eight-hour ozone standard.

"Common sense also dictates that areas should not be punished for things beyond their control,” the letter stated as it discussed transport-related emissions.

Those references were not in the 2010 letter.

In that more recent submission to EPA, the state agency also stated that it lacks the expertise in health effects and would defer to the federal government on that issue.

That was not in the 2007 letter.

"I wish I had the answer to that,” Inhofe said, when offered a chance to explain the differences in the letters.

"They should have been stronger in opposition than they were on the Bush proposal for obvious reasons. It is a worse deal for Oklahoma.”

By contrast, letters submitted to EPA by the Indian Nations Council of Governments did follow that pattern.

INCOG Chairman John Selph, who submitted letters to EPA in 2007 and earlier this year, agreed it was important to promote the progress that has been made on ozone and spell out the consequences of the agency’s push to change the standards.

"I think it is a missed opportunity,” Selph said concerning the approach the state took.

"It is somewhat disappointing that our lead agency on air quality in this state didn’t take a strong stand.”

Selph’s 2010 letter took EPA to task for reconsidering the ozone standard only two years after adoption of the current standard and three years before a required review.

"INCOG is concerned that the unprecedented timing of EPA’s reconsideration of the standard sets up areas like Tulsa for failure and nonattainment status,” Selph’s letter states.

"In this period of nationwide economic hardship, national policies should focus on job creation.”

Selph calls on EPA to stick with its current standard.

"The Tulsa area currently meets the 2008 ozone (standards),” he said.

"We have accomplished this through a 19-year-old program that is based on voluntary efforts by the private and public sectors to reduce emissions.”

Selph also agreed that his 2010 letter could be viewed as a stronger response to EPA’s current proposal.

An EPA spokesman said the agency plans to issue the final ozone standards by Aug. 31.

EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson announced the push for tougher standards in January, adding that a stricter ozone standard was necessary to protect the health of Americans, especially children.

###