Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In the News… 

E&E News 

‘Inspirational’ Democratic meeting yields no Senate game plan

(06/24/2010)

Josh Voorhees and Robin Bravender, E&E reporters

Link to Article 

Senate Democrats left their latest round of energy and climate talks with what they hailed as a renewed sense of unity — and little else.

Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) and other party leaders called this afternoon’s meeting "inspirational," "powerful" and even "thrilling" but conceded that Democrats had yet to rally around any of the legislative proposals currently on the table.

Instead, Reid will work to cobble together some sort of compromise legislation that senators promised would address the Gulf of Mexico oil spill, boost domestic clean energy production and address climate emissions with a system in which the "polluter pays."

"We’re going to write a bill that sets reasonable goals over reasonable time frames that will benefit both our environment and our economy," Reid said. "We’re going to write a bill that can pass the Senate … but we need the cooperation of Republicans that we’re hoping will put good policy over bad politics."

Democrats said they still hoped to bring a bill to the floor next month and that they were confident that they could pass a bill before the end of the year.

"Whatever form it takes, we’re going to move forward," Reid said.

Sen. John Kerry (D-Mass.) said Reid would ultimately take the lead in finding a compromise, but Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.) said there had been discussion of creating a committee of senators to recommend what should be in the final draft.

Despite the optimistic tone from Democrats, few could offer any specific progress that had been hammered out during the hourlong talks.

Sen. Frank Lautenberg (D-N.J.) said the only consensus was "to do some soul-searching to make sure that we know what it is that we want to do."

Democratic leaders have been scrambling for months to rally their caucus to embrace specific energy and climate legislation but have so far had little luck rounding up all 59 members — let alone the at least one, and likely several, Republican votes they would need to pass it.

The party’s more liberal members have held out hope for a bill that prices carbon in a number of a key sectors, while moderates have been slow to embrace a cap-and-trade system akin to the one backed by Kerry and Lieberman.

Those two sides appeared no closer to striking a deal after today’s caucus meeting, but several senators said that it appeared as though the majority of Democrats were in favor of passing a bill that dealt with climate and energy, as opposed to energy-only legislation.

"There was no discussion of a bill per se," said Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.). "I don’t think we have the shape of the table — the details of the bill. I think we had people saying, ‘Let’s try to get something more comprehensive than just energy-only.’"

"There was kind of an uprising of rank-and-file members in support of a strong comprehensive energy legislation that makes polluters pay," Lieberman said.

Still, lawmakers were mum on the details of exactly what "polluter pays" legislation would look like.

"We’ll have to see what we come to the floor with; that’s the principle that is going to guide us and was uniform within the caucus," Kerry said. "It’s also been the policy of our country since 1970 … all the way up to George [W.] Bush, who then negated it a few years ago."

Asked whether the caucus is in agreement that the bill needs to price carbon, Kerry said, "I’d say the overwhelming majority of the caucus is very much in favor of that."

Democrats also are eager to include legislation focused on the Gulf of Mexico oil spill as a way to attract more votes. "It will be an opportunity for senators to vote for oil safety," Lieberman said.

A ‘revival’ atmosphere

Democrats emerging from the meeting made a point to stress the caucus’s optimistic tone and the consensus for acting this year.

"As we said, we had a revival," said Sen. Kay Hagan (D-N.C.). "There was this atmosphere of a lot of people coming together on the need now to move forward."

Several senators called it the best caucus they had ever attended.

"This was without doubt one of the most motivating energized and even inspirational caucuses I’ve ever been a part of," Kerry said.

Lautenberg echoed those thoughts. "It was one of the best caucuses that I’ve seen, and I’ve been here over 25 years," he said.

Lieberman called the meeting "absolutely thrilling, and by that I mean it was an uprising of the rank-and-file members of the caucus speaking with passion and purpose in favor of enacting strong comprehensive energy independence legislation this year."

Still, Majority Whip Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) signaled some hesitancy among the Democrats. There was a question of "whether or not we should commit ourselves," he said. "It’s been a very busy two years. A lot of people are very fatigued, but there was a strong feeling that we should move forward."

Democrats used the opportunity to prod their GOP colleagues to support comprehensive energy and climate legislation.

"We’re going to challenge some of our Republican colleagues to do what I know they know is the right and necessary thing for America, and we’re going to get 60 votes or more," Lieberman said.

But several liberals said that they hope to move forward even in the absence of Republican buy-in.

"Republicans are not supporting virtually anything to transform our energy system," said Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.). "That’s not what the American people want, so I think you bring forth a strong bill, you rally the American people, and I think the Republicans will respond as a response to that."

Lautenberg said the Democrats must be cohesive in their presentation to the public "and stop waiting to see if we can coax a Republican or two or three over the finish line."

Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) said before the meeting that he is still optimistic a bill can pass this year. "The problem is, Mitch McConnell tells the Republicans, ‘Don’t cooperate on anything.’ It doesn’t mean we’re not trying to peel some off," he said. "They’re going to try to block everything, and that’s the mountain to climb."

Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) said today that the chances of an energy and climate bill passing this year depend "entirely on what it does. If it looks like it’s a national energy tax, which is what cap and trade is, I think it’s not going to pass," he said.

"What we need to do is think about what kind of legislation, if any, is appropriate in response to the oil spill," he added.

Sen. George LeMieux (R-Fla.), who is considered a possible swing vote on a climate and energy bill, said today that the goal is to "make sure that we do get something done and not have it be a political statement." He said he would support a bill that would increase alternative energy and address the Gulf oil spill.

Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), who dropped out of climate negotiations with Kerry and Lieberman earlier this year, said today that there may be Republican support for a cap-and-trade measure that capped only the utility sector but was skeptical that it could get done this year.

"This year, I don’t know," Graham said. "It’s a pretty weary Congress right now. Big items to be done between now and November, or a heavy lift after health care." He said it would depend in part on how utilities and the environmental community responded to the legislation.

"So I don’t know. It would be a new political dynamic, but I think that is where we are headed," he said.

Reporters Allison Winter, Elana Schor and Mike Soraghan contributed.

###