Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
Energy Bill Would Hurt Oklahoma
Inhofe Exposes Democrats’ Late-Night, Secret Anti-Natural Gas Provision
Hydraulic Fracturing Has Bi-Partisan Support in Congress
Watch/Read: Inhofe Floor Speech: Democrats Add Hydraulic Fracturing Provision into Spill Bill
Watch: Inhofe Exposes Late Night, Secret Add of Hydraulic Fracturing into Dems Energy Bill
Inhofe on KFAQ: Dems Secret Provision in Energy Bill Seeks to Kill Natural Gas Production
Inhofe EPW News Roundup: Fracking Debate Rages
In a surprise, last-minute, late-night addition to the Democrats’ energy bill, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid took the opportunity to include provisions explicitly targeting the use of hydraulic fracturing. Reid’s inclusion of the language comes despite the fact that the Senate has yet to hold a single committee hearing or markup this Congress on the issue of hydraulic fracturing. (For speculation on why Reid inserted the language, see here and here)
Senator Inhofe was the first to expose the Democrats’ attack on natural gas at a press conference Wednesday morning, pointing out that "if you do away with hydraulic fracturing, you do away with natural gas.” (See Tulsa World Coverage)
Senator Inhofe followed the press conference with a lengthy defense on the Senate Floor of hydraulic fracturing. Senator Inhofe noted:
– “Some Democrats may argue that this Section 4301 is only a disclosure provision of the chemicals used in the hydraulic fracturing process. That is not true. State regulators have safely and effectively regulated hydraulic fracturing for the past 60 years, as was stated by Carol Browner. State rules, such as in my state of Oklahoma, require disclosure of chemicals. What this provision is about is a new EPA federal control. Somehow this administration thinks that if the Federal Government isn’t running something—this is an obsession, where the Federal Government has to run everything. When I was mayor of Tulsa, we had a guy, a police commissioner, and he had a saying that “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” This hasn’t been broken once in 60 years. At a press conference, somebody talked about, well, didn’t this happen in Nevada once? Well, I have no record—neither does Carol Browner—that there has been contamination as a result of hydraulic fracturing.
– “Proponents of this language argue that it is needed because fracking contaminates groundwater. As the Ranking Member of the Environment and Publics Works Committee, I have asked the USGS and the EPA’s Assistant Administrators for both the Enforcement Office and the Water Office in testimony in front of the Environment and Public Works Committee whether they are aware of any documented case of water contamination due to hydraulic fracturing. They could not name one. That is because there isn’t any.
– “These officials are not alone in this opinion. President Obama’s Energy Czar agrees with me. In 1995, as EPA Administrator, Carol Browner wrote in response to litigation that federal regulation is not necessary for hydraulic fracturing. She correctly made the point that the practice was closely regulated by the States and that “EPA is not legally required to regulate hydraulic fracturing.” Most importantly, she further wrote that there was “no evidence that hydraulic fracturing resulted in any drinking water contamination” in the litigation involved. We are talking about something that is not broken. It clearly is necessary for us to get all of this out to run this machine called America. As we can see, this is not a partisan Republican issue; Democrats alike understand the importance of hydraulic fracturing.
– “When I spoke on the floor last July, as I mentioned, Senator Dorgan from North Dakota followed my comments saying that he agreed with my assessment that not only is fracking needed to access new reserves, such as the ones in the Bakken shale in North Dakota, but that he is not aware of any groundwater contamination from the practice. I appreciate the fact that he is outspoken in this area.
– “It is also extremely important to point out that Congress has already tasked EPA in law to study the effects of any hydraulic fracturing on water quality and public health. The EPA has already begun using $4.3 million for this effort, which is being led by Dr. Robert Puls, who works in EPA’s Groundwater Research Laboratory based in Ada, OK. I encourage this study. We know there has not been any problem. I want to make sure we can put the final nail in this coffin, that people somehow think hydraulic fracturing contaminates water. This is a way to do an independent study. Let the government study it.
– "This bill was drafted last night at 10 o’clock in spite of the fact that we do not have any results back from that study. Even if one wanted to believe so badly and did believe this is a problem, let’s at least wait for the study before composing new legislation. Natural gas development brings billions in private investment and millions of jobs to America. This country cannot afford to limit the production of its domestic energy resources due to unfounded rumors of environmental damage and the usual hysterical claims from extremist environmental organizations looking for the next crusade because cap and trade is dead.
Reaction from Oklahoma to the Democratic energy bill has been swift – and for good reason. As an Oklahoman editorial from July 24 noted, Democrat House members have been ‘obsessed’ with the issue from some time, writing, “No adverse impact from fracturing has been proven. Shaking up rock through fracturing is essential for releasing natural gas from shale formations; natural gas is essential for transitioning power generation away from coal. Gas is also key (along with offshore oil drilling) in reducing dependence on foreign supplies. Nevertheless, some poor players in Congress won’t let the fracturing issue die a dusty death. California U.S. Rep. Henry Waxman seems obsessed by it. Yet natural gas is a relatively green, clean and abundant fuel.”
The Journal Record, reported energy experts in Oklahoma feared the Senate bill would “hurt Oklahoma.”
The article cited Mike Terry, OIPA president, the state’s largest oil industry trade group, with more than 2,000 individual members and companies. Terry told the Journal Record: “Oklahoma is one of the nation’s largest natural gas-producing states, and any efforts to increase the use of the fuel in the U.S. will benefit the state’s economy and the nation’s drive toward energy independence. However, significantly increasing taxes on the industry that produces the fuel will push smaller independent oil and natural gas producers out of business and reduce the number of drilling rigs exploring for natural gas in Oklahoma.” The Senate bill is an immediate threat to the industry, Terry said.
The Journal Record article also cited Somerlyn Cothran, executive director of the National Stripper Well Association.
“We are fighting every day,” Cothran said. He explained that higher taxes impact the stripper or marginal wells because marginal well operators have razor-thin profit margins. A marginal well produces no more than 10 barrels or 60,000 cubic feet of natural gas daily. Oklahoma wells produce an average of 2.3 barrels of oil per day, according to the state’s Marginal Well Commission. There are 65,504 marginally producing oil and gas wells in Oklahoma, out of a total of 119,255 wells that are tracked by the Oklahoma Corporation Commission. “We are doing everything in our power to keep from having to pay these taxes, which would plug wells and cost jobs,” Cothran said. Liability provisions in the bill would make working in deep waters of the Gulf of Mexico a near impossibility for smaller, independent producers, he said.
In addition to the fierce reaction from Oklahoma, a Dow Jones article showed that the addition brought along plenty of opposition from the Natural Gas Industry. “A U.S. Senate energy bill drew opposition from natural-gas companies on Wednesday after the surprise addition of a measure that would force companies to disclose the chemicals used at each well being drilled in huge gas fields located across the U.S. The opposition, from the groups Energy In Depth and America’s Natural Gas Alliance, poses a new hurdle for the energy bill just days before it is due for a vote on the Senate floor.”
The Dow Jones article stated, “America’s Natural Gas Alliance said in a statement that ‘we fundamentally believe that regulation of hydraulic fracturing is best addressed at the state level and we have been unable to reach a consensus with congressional advocates on how this program would be overseen by the federal government. Therefore, we cannot support this language. ANGA does however remain committed to improving transparency, whether through state or individual company action, and will continue to work toward that goal.’”
– "The entire universe of additives used in the fracturing process is known to regulators and the public," Lee Fuller, the executive director of Energy In Depth, a group that represents oil and gas producers, said in a prepared statement. The Senate measure "has the potential to create a series of legal responsibilities that operators, and even service companies, might not be able to fulfill, especially under a scenario where folks are asked to post information that doesn’t even belong to them.
– America’s Natural Gas Alliance said in a statement that "we fundamentally believe that regulation of hydraulic fracturing is best addressed at the state level and we have been unable to reach a consensus with congressional advocates on how this program would be overseen by the federal government. Therefore, we cannot support this language. ANGA does however remain committed to improving transparency, whether through state or individual company action, and will continue to work toward that goal."
Could the battle over hydraulic fracturing sink the energy bill? As these press articles have demonstrated, one thing is certain: before Congress acts, the Senate should engage in a full discussion of this language and hear the impact of these actions before simply inserting a provision of this magnitude. Given the record of Democratic leadership this Congress, however, that may be too much to ask for.
###