Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov
In Case You Missed It…
National Journal
Why Limit A Safe, Effective Method?
September 23, 2010
By Sen. James Inhofe, R-Okla.
Hydraulic fracturing, coupled with horizontal drilling, is the key production method which has not only aided in the production of oil and gas from more than one million oil and gas wells over the past nearly 60 years, but it continues to aid the production from thousands and wells every year. In fact, in deep and tight formations, production is dependent on horizontal drilling, hydraulic fracturing, or both. Recent reports point to reserves of natural gas of over 2,000 trillion cubic feet (Tcf). At today’s demand, that estimate alone is enough natural gas to meet demand for the next 100 years. Only 1 Tcf of natural gas can heat 15 million homes for a year or fuel 12 million natural gas powered vehicles for a year. What is significant is that much of the increase noted in the report comes from estimates of shale gas found in formations throughout the U.S. However, shale resources are largely only economically and technologically available due to hydraulic fracturing.
Importantly, natural gas production from shale has benefited local and state governments, royalty owners, and overall local economies substantially. For example, production in the Barnett Shale is responsible for over 110,000 jobs, $4.5 billion in royalty payments, and over $10 billion in increased economic activity in north Texas. The Haynesville Shale in Louisiana has created 33,000 jobs, $2.4 billion in business sales, $3.9 billion in salaries, and $3.2 billion in royalty payments. The Fayetteville Shale has drawn business and capital investment in the area of $22 billion, the creation of 11,000 jobs, and estimates of new state revenues of more than $2 billion by 2012. In Oklahoma, exploration for natural gas accounts for 80% of the state’s energy production, and one in seven jobs in Oklahoma is directly or indirectly supported by the crude oil and natural gas industry. Oil and gas accounts for 25% of all taxes paid in the state.
The Marcellus Shale in Pennsylvania and New York reportedly contains 516 Tcf of natural gas which is enough to satisfy U.S. demand for more than 35 years. Pennsylvania State University issued studies in 2009 and May 2010. It reported that in 2009, Marcellus gas producers spent $4.5 billion just to develop gas resources. It estimates that producers will spend $8 billion in 2010 and $10 billion in 2011. The economic activity from this development simply continues to grow. The study estimates that it will generate $1.8 billion in local tax revenues in 2010-11 and employment of more than 88,000 jobs in 2010 and over 111,000 in 2011.
While States have been regulating oil and gas exploration and production for years, liberals in Washington now want the regulation of hydraulic fracturing to take place from Washington. The fact is however, Republicans and Democrats alike support State regulation. Democratic Colorado Governor Bill Ritter has recognized the value of the practice. In the Denver Business Journal, the Governor characterized the bills pending in Congress imposing new federal regulation on hydraulic fracturing as “a new and potentially intrusive regulatory program.” My colleague Senator Byron Dorgan has at least on a couple of occasions spoken at length on the Senate floor recognizing hydraulic fracturing as a crucial technique to production in the Bakken Shale.
Keeping regulation in the States is backed up by a number of recent studies. The Department of Energy and Ground Water Protection Council released a report in May 2009 titled, “State Oil and Natural Gas Regulations Designed to Protect Water Resources” where it described state regulations on all oil and gas production to protect against groundwater contamination. This DOE and GWPC report ultimately concluded that federal regulations on fracturing would be “costly, duplicative of state regulations, and ultimately ineffective because such regulations would be too far removed from field operations.” Equally interesting, the report also concluded that the “only alternative to fracturing in reservoirs with low permeability such as shale would be to simply have to drill more wells.”
These findings mirror EPA’s 2004 report of hydraulic fracturing in coal bed methane CBM production. In this report, EPA conducted a review of all 11 major coal basins across the country and of 200 peer-reviewed publications. It reviewed 105 comments in the Federal Register. It requested information from 500 local and county agencies in states where CBM production occurs. It interviewed 50 local and state government agencies, industry representatives, and 40 citizens groups which alleged drinking water contamination from hydraulic fracturing. After completing this 4 year study, EPA concluded that, “the injection of hydraulic fracturing fluids into CBM wells poses little or no threat to underground sources of drinking water and does not justify additional study at this time.”
Additionally, Penn State’s 2009 study commented that proposals to regulate hydraulic fracturing under the federal Safe Drinking Water Act pose yet another serious threat to the development of the Marcellus Shale and other unconventional gas sources. Why? Because it unnecessarily imposes federal regulation on top of regulation the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Quality is already demonstrating it is able to conduct.
America has tremendous natural gas reserves. When the U.S. is approaching 10% unemployment and when we want energy security and independence from foreign energy, why would we want to go out of our way to restrict the means to extract our own resources that has demonstrated effectiveness and safety for 60 years? Hydraulic fracturing is a safe production technique that is thoroughly regulated by the states. We have a 60 year history to prove it. This country cannot afford to limit the production of its domestic energy resources due to unfounded, anecdotal rumors of environmental damage and the usual hysterical claims from extremist environmental organizations looking for their next crusade.