Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In Case You Missed It….  

The Wall Street Journal

Editorial: Science and the Drilling Ban

An inspector general’s report shows science played little role in the moratorium.

SENATE REPORT: FAILURE OF LEADERSHIP: PRESIDENT OBAMA AND THE FLAWED FEDERAL RESPONSE TO THE BP DISASTER

Link to Editorial

President Obama famously declared in 2009 that under his Administration the "days of science taking a backseat to ideology are over." Except, apparently, when the Administration wanted to justify its Gulf of Mexico drilling ban this summer.

The White House dropped its deep water drilling ban last month, ending months of government-imposed pain on a Gulf region hit by the BP oil spill. But only last week did the Department of Interior’s acting inspector general, Mary Kendall, issue her findings on the moratorium’s controversial beginnings. Lackluster though her investigation was, the report confirms that the moratorium never had any basis in science or safety. It was pure politics.

The IG report examines Interior Secretary Ken Salazar’s May 27 claim that "The recommendations contained in this report have been peer-reviewed by seven experts identified by the National Academy of Engineering." Those experts soon claimed the Interior draft they had reviewed did not include a moratorium and that Mr. Salazar had inappropriately used their names "to justify his political decisions."

Ms. Kendall-who is waiting to see if the White House nominates her as official IG-contented herself with stating that White House energy czar Carol Browner’s office had edited the report in a way that "led to the implication that the moratorium recommendation had been peer reviewed by the experts." All officials had denied it was "their intention to imply" the moratorium had been peer-reviewed. They had merely meant to say the peer-reviewers had signed off on other safety measures, and the problem was, er, "rushed editing." Uh-huh.

The IG findings include no evidence the decision to shut down an entire industry-at a huge cost to jobs and long-term drilling safety-was done with input from engineers, scientists, economists or anyone with day-to-day oversight of U.S. drilling. S. Elizabeth Birnbaum, former head of the Minerals Management Service, which oversees offshore drilling, said she learned about the ban from a deputy, and only after the fact. Preparation for the Interior drilling report was tasked to Steve Black, a lawyer who is officially the Counselor to Mr. Salazar. Yet Mr. Black told the IG the ban was "a policy decision made by Secretary Salazar and President Obama." Though Mr. Salazar issued the report, the IG says final edits to the summary were done by Ms. Browner’s office.

As for the experts whose names were taken in vain, the IG says they still wonder why they weren’t consulted on the drilling ban. For example, Bob Bea of the University of California "questioned why [Interior] would not peer review such an important, far-reaching decision," given the attention paid to more minor recommendations.

Allow us to guess: White House aides knew a moratorium was unjustifiable, and they didn’t want to disclose their plans to peer-reviewers whom they knew would object. The Administration was by late May already taking political heat for its handling of the spill and perhaps it felt a moratorium would help make it look tough on the oil industry. In other words, thousands of Gulf Coast jobs may have been sacrificed as a way to deflect political blame from the White House and onto industry.

Congressional Republicans are demanding hearings on the report, and by all means call Ms. Browner to testify. But they should look beyond the narrow question of which experts were asked what and when to who made the decision to impose the moratorium. Maybe they can help President Obama put science back in the front seat.

###