Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In Case You Missed It…

Inside EPA  

Inhofe Urges GOP Oversight On EPA’s Precedent-Setting Fluoride Proposal

By Bridget DiCosmo

Posted: January 18, 2011

Link to Article

Sen. James Inhofe (R-OK) is warning top EPA officials that he intends to conduct oversight — and will press House Republicans to do the same — on EPA’s precedent-setting proposal to pull longstanding food safety limits for a fluoride pesticide, a move Inhofe and others say could have significant negative economic implications and do little to reduce harmful fluoride exposure.

EPA’s recent proposal to revoke all tolerances, or allowable pesticide residues, for the fumigant sulfuryl fluoride in the wake of a new, more conservative risk and exposure assessment for fluoride, marks a "novel use" of food safety laws, one industry source says. The Jan. 10 proposal was preceded by the announcement that the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) was lowering the level of fluoride — a mineral long added to drinking water for its purported dental hygiene benefits — it recommends adding to drinking water. In conjunction, EPA announced it is undertaking a review of its current drinking water protection limit for fluoride.

Under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, EPA must review pesticides tolerances to ensure that cumulative exposures to a substance through other, non-pesticidal sources, do not exceed safe levels. EPA’s proposal to revoke tolerances on sulfuryl fluoride, which breaks down into fluoride, marks the first time the agency has proposed revoking tolerances on the grounds that people are already overexposed to the chemical under the law’s aggregate risk provisions, according to industry, hill and agency sources. EPA’s proposal stems from activist groups’ 2006 request urging EPA to revoke the sulfuryl fluoride tolerances.

But Inhofe, ranking member of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee (EPW), is raising concerns that the proposed decision on sulfuryl fluoride was a White-House-driven policy decision triggered by the threat of a lawsuit, congressional sources say.

In a Jan. 12 letter to EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson, Inhofe warns he will be conducting oversight on the process for revoking the tolerance, which includes a 90-day public comment period. Congressional sources say that he expects to see additional scrutiny on the pesticide decision from House Republicans, who have vowed aggressive oversight on costly EPA and other agency regulations.

Sources say EPA staff alerted Inhofe’s office prior to EPA’s Jan. 7 announcement on fluoride, concerned that the sulfuryl fluoride decision was being driven in a "very sort of top-down way," and was not supported by the revised exposure assessment, which concludes that sulfuryl fluoride contributions to overall fluoride exposure are "minor" compared to the amount of fluoride in drinking water. "Federal officials recently informed my staff of a serious debate among scientists, technical experts, and staff at EPA on the agency’s ultimate policy decision and supporting scientific rationale," Inhofe wrote in the Jan. 12 letter.

White House Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) emails indicate CEQ staff coordinated the various fluoride announcements by EPA and HHS to be made concurrently, rather than staggered. The emails also indicate that the agencies seemed poised to announce the fluoride actions on Nov. 4, and that the new risk and exposure assessments were completed and peer reviewed last April. The reason for their delay is not clear. A congressional source says that "CEQ was very clearly the driving force in trying to get this expedited."

Echoed By Industry

Inhofe’s objections to the proposed tolerance revocations have been echoed by industry sources, including Dow AgroSciences, which registers sulfuryl fluoride. "EPA acknowledges that public exposures to fluoride resulting from the use of [sulfuryl fluoride] are negligible compared to much higher exposures from drinking water and toothpaste," a Dow spokesman says.

Another industry source notes that EPA’s decision to propose revoking the tolerance rather than attempt to cancel the product’s registration dodges a much more extensive legal process, requiring EPA to also consider the pesticide’s benefits to agriculture and safe food supplies. A more appropriate response to the "perceived over-exposure" to fluoride would have been further limiting its use in drinking water, which accounts for a significantly larger proportion of exposure, the source says. "EPA is taking a precipitous action likely to have negative economic consequences simply because it has the power to do so under FIFRA [Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, & Rodenticide Act]."

In its Jan. 7 proposed order on sulfuryl fluoride, EPA acknowledges "Although sulfuryl fluoride residues in food contribute only a very small portion of total exposure to fluoride, when combined with other fluoride exposure pathways, including drinking water and toothpaste, EPA has concluded that the tolerance no longer meets the safety standard under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act and the tolerances for sulfuryl fluoride should be withdrawn."

In a Nov. 15 letter, attorneys for the Fluoride Action Network, Environmental Working Group and Beyond Pesticides reiterated objections that tolerances for sulfuryl fluoride should not have been established because levels of fluoride in drinking water mean that aggregate exposure to the mineral is unsafe, and threatened to sue if EPA did not render a decision within 30 days.

The Food and Drug Administration also appears to be weighing a decision to reduce the amount of fluoride that can be added to toothpaste and other oral hygiene products, according to the congressional source.

Inhofe and industry are also pushing back against EPA’s proposal with a risk-risk argument, suggesting that sulfuryl fluoride is the only existing alternative to methyl bromide. That fumigant has been partially phased out in the U.S. as a known ozone-depleter, banned under international treaty. Banning sulfuryl fluoride, which is used as a methyl bromide substitute in an estimated 40 percent of food processing mills for a wide variety of foods, including cocoa, cheese, walnuts, and dried fruit, "could create unintended consequences for public health, food safety, and the economy," Inhofe says in his Jan. 12 letter to Jackson.

EPA acknowledges the concerns about methyl bromide by proposing to phase out uses of sulfuryl fluoride over a period of three years rather than immediately revoking the tolerances, as the environmentalists sought in their petition. The agency says it will work with fumigant users to identify alternatives. In its proposed order, EPA indicates it is denying the petition’s request to immediately revoke the tolerances, because "risks from continued sulfuryl fluoride use in the short term is insignificant while the environmental and economic consequences from a sudden withdrawal of sulfuryl fluoride, a methyl bromide replacement, are considerable."

Jay Feldman of Beyond Pesticides — one of the three groups that petitioned EPA revoke the sulfuryl fluoride tolerances — said during a Jan. 11 teleconference that restricting use of sulfuryl fluoride could create an opportunity to further the use of integrated pest management methods without relying on toxic chemicals.

But the proposal is likely to rankle growers, especially because another methyl bromide substitute, the fumigant methyl iodide, is also under attack.

###