Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In The News…

E&E News 

EPA amendments may come to floor; ag community divided on Baucus approach

(03/29/2011)

Jean Chemnick, E&E reporter

Link to Article

Link to Inhofe-Upton Energy Tax Prevention Page

THE ROCKEFELLER AMENDMENT DELAYS JOBS AND ECONOMIC RECOVERY

BAUCUS AMENDMENT: NO PROTECTION FOR FARMERS, CONSUMERS, SMALL BUSINESSES 

Senate leaders last night were gearing up for a fight over three amendments to limit U.S. EPA’s power to regulate greenhouse gas emissions, though they had not announced by publication time when the votes might take place.

The Senate is expected to consider an amendment this week as part of a small business bill that would permanently strip EPA of its authority to regulate heat-trapping emissions under the Clean Air Act. The amendment is offered by Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) and tracks a bill sponsored by Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.).

Two Democratic alternatives to McConnell-Inhofe have also been filed. Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D-W.Va.) has said Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) promised him a vote on his bill that would delay EPA’s climate change rules for two years, and leaders have floated the idea of bringing it to the floor alongside McConnell’s proposal.

Sen. Max Baucus (D-Mont.), author of the third amendment, said yesterday he did not know whether his proposal would receive a vote but called it "good policy."

The Baucus amendment — the latest entrant in the Senate battle over climate issues — partly reinforces EPA’s own tailoring rule for greenhouse gases, and even Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.), a staunch EPA supporter, said yesterday she planned to consider it.

"I’m looking at it," she said. "Somebody said he had added some things, but I definitely support the tailoring rule."

EPA has not proposed direct carbon dioxide regulations for ranchers and farmers, and Baucus’ amendment would make that exemption permanent. It would also bar EPA from considering land-use changes abroad, which were possibly triggered by U.S. biofuels production to judge whether a fuel qualifies for special status under the 2007 renewable fuel standard.

Despite its farmer-friendly tilt, the agriculture sector is actually divided on whether the Baucus amendment would insulate farmers enough from the rising costs some say would accompany greenhouse gas regulations.

The American Farm Bureau Federation, which in 2009 and 2010 actively campaigned against cap-and-trade legislation then before Congress, said the amendment would not protect agriculture from a hike in operating costs, because it contains no exemption for other sectors.

"As utilities, refiners and manufacturers are regulated, their increased costs to comply are passed down to consumers like farmers," said Rick Krause, senior director of congressional relations at AFBF. "That increases fuel, fertilizer and energy costs to raise food. Baucus does not affect these costs."

Krause said AFBF is also confident that opponents of EPA regulation will triumph in the courts, knocking down EPA’s so-called tailoring rule that limits regulations to emitters of at least 75,000 tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per year. The Clean Air Act specifies a 100- or 250-ton-per-year threshold for traditional pollutants.

Baucus’ amendment would codify the 75,000-ton-per-year threshold. Krause pointed out that this would make legal challenges to the rule "moot."

The amendment would scale back some New Source Review requirements of the Clean Air Act but leave in place EPA’s authority to craft and implement New Source Performance Standards for utilities and oil refineries in 2011 and 2012. Similar standards could be put in place for other sectors in later years — though Baucus’ amendment would permanently exempt agriculture.

While these rules are expected to be substantially different from the cap-and-trade bill that cleared the House in 2009, Krause said AFBF has used an analysis of that bill to estimate the costs of Clean Air Act regulations. It shows, among other things, that the bill will drive up demand for natural gas, increasing the cost of fertilizer.

Chandler Goule of the National Farmers Union, which represents small to medium-sized family farmers, said while his group had not yet officially endorsed Baucus’ proposal, "our policy is definitely much more in the direction of this amendment."

"We’re always on the lookout with making sure that we’re not overburdening the small and medium and family-sized producer with little additional things that can really be the make-or-break point for farmers and ranchers," he said.

Goule said climate change mitigation could actually offer more of an upside than a downside for the agriculture sector, which produces about 6 percent of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions. This would have been especially true under the House-passed cap-and-trade bill, he said, because farmers could have benefited from its carbon offset program.

"We were definitely heading in the right direction, back when we were working on climate change," Goule said. Still, he said something like the Baucus approach would "alleviate some of the regulation that could come down the pipeline, not knowing what this administration fully intends to do or what administrations in the future will do."

Environmentalists have panned the indirect land-use change language, but Goule said farmers appreciated it.

"Making our producers reduce what they can put into production based on what another country is doing to their forests — we have big issues with that," he said. "Indirect land use is a really, really touchy issue. It really gets producers wound up."

###