Posted by Matt Dempsey Matt_Dempsey@epw.senate.gov

In Case You Missed It…

E&E News 

Greens see EPA-sized hole in Obama energy pivot

(03/31/2011)

Elana Schor, E&E reporter

Link to Article  

For environmentalists fighting to save U.S. EPA regulatory authority from the budgetary chopping block, the most pivotal part of President Obama’s energy speech yesterday was what it failed to mention.

Obama called for greater use of natural gas vehicles and advanced biofuels yesterday while touting his administration’s record on oil drilling and fuel efficiency. But nowhere in his 3,500-word address was a reference to the greenhouse gas emissions regulations facing threats on both sides of the Capitol this week in an epic battle for which many conservationists had hoped to see the White House suit up.

"[I]t is unacceptable that in a speech billed as being about ‘energy security,’ the president failed to recommit his administration to defending the Clean Air Act against rollbacks," Friends of the Earth climate director Damon Moglen said in a statement. "If the president is truly serious about energy security, he must be much more vocal in his support of this crucial law."

Dan Lashof, director of the Natural Resources Defense Council’s climate center, reacted to the speech by drawing a contrast between a White House seeking to "move American forward" and EPA critics "working overtime to move us backward." But Obama’s proposed "clean" standard for electricity from low-carbon sources "can’t be achieved if dirty power plants are allowed to continue indefinitely to emit unlimited amounts of carbon dioxide into the air," Lashof wrote yesterday on NRDC’s blog.

He urged Obama to "not waver" from the White House’s previous resistance to GOP budget provisions that would stop EPA from acting on greenhouse gases.

As of last night, Congress was pursuing anti-EPA plans on two separate but related tracks. The Senate is expected to take up as soon as today several competing amendments that would hamstring the agency’s greenhouse gas limits, although none is expected to win approval (see related story).

Meanwhile, the Associated Press reported last night that the administration had warned Democrats privately that "some of" the dozen-plus EPA restrictions in the House GOP budget plan "would have to make it into" any final spending compromise.

National Wildlife Federation Senior Vice President Jeremy Symons said, "It’s past time the president speaks out against these polluter riders and makes clear that he will stand up to the oil companies that hijacked the House budget. He should clear the air and put these anonymous reports to rest."

Speaking to reporters in the Capitol yesterday, Vice President Joe Biden said he and Obama are "not really big on any riders at all" and that some are "nonstarters," but declined to say publicly which of those were while the House and Senate appropriations committees negotiate.

"There are certain things we’re just not going to do on riders, even if you agree with everything else," Biden said. "We’re just not going to do it."

NWF spokesman Tony Iallonardo yesterday added that his group was "putting all of our resources" into the looming Senate showdown over blocking EPA’s greenhouse gas rules than to Obama’s speech. Nonetheless, he took note of the president’s silence on that singular issue for green groups.

"We’d like to see the president engaged, as he was in the State of the Union, in reiterating that he will do everything in his power to defend the Clean Air Act," Iallonardo added, describing Obama’s January defense of his administration’s regulatory authority over pollutants as "the most important thing he’s said this year on climate and clean energy policy."

The chief House Democratic appropriator for EPA and the Interior Department echoed environmentalists’ wary response to the speech. It was up to Obama "and his speechwriters" to decide if EPA merited a mention yesterday, Rep. Jim Moran of Virginia quipped before adding that calling the CR riders "totally unacceptable" should be a top priority.

"I hope he understands that promoting more energy — even more sustainable forms of energy — is not the same as protecting the environment in all cases," Moran said of Obama. "I just don’t see any room for compromise on those riders, and I would hope that he would take a definitive position in that regard."

Losing his base?

The omission of EPA emissions rules was not the only aspect of the Obama speech that left environmentalists cold.

Sierra Club executive director Michael Brune said in an interview yesterday that he was "surprised and disappointed" by the extent to which the president emphasized fossil fuels such as oil and natural gas. Brune warned that "the prospects for his re-election efforts" would hinge on Obama "getting back to his roots and rediscovering his passion for clean energy" — or risking dampened enthusiasm among the younger voters who helped elect him.

"It wasn’t the gas industry that helped Obama win in Iowa and helped him inspire millions of people around the country," Brune said. "It wasn’t, I don’t recall, activists from Big Oil going around and knocking on doors across the country."

Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-Ore.), among the lower chamber’s most ardent environmentalists, sounded a similar note yesterday. The Oregonian said he had hoped to see Obama focus more on "something that would have more impact sooner" than natural gas and drilling, namely the White House’s push for "building more livable communities and getting more out of resources."

Environment America’s Washington director, Anna Aurilio, released a statement praising Obama for outlining "some strong plans" to reduce domestic oil consumption. But she deemed the president’s continued support for nuclear power as "a disappointment" given the safety risks highlighted by the ongoing crisis in Japan.

Yet even as green groups held their applause for the president, some of his most ardent environmental allies in the House cheered the speech.

Rep. Henry Waxman of California, the Energy and Commerce Committee’s top Democrat, welcomed Obama’s attempt to counter arguments by the oil industry and its allies in Congress that the White House is stanching domestic production.

"Natural gas is an obvious transitional fuel" to emphasize as part of a shift away from oil, Waxman added in an interview.

Rep. Ed Markey (D-Mass.), who co-authored the 2009 cap-and-trade climate bill with Waxman, also praised Obama for aiming to close "an education gap" on the White House’s offshore oil production policies.

Asserting that the number of Gulf of Mexico offshore rigs is greater than "before the accident" in the Gulf of Mexico last year, Markey countered that Obama "emphasized renewables" as well as oil and natural gas: "It’s an all-of-the-above agenda, not an oil-above-all agenda, so he lays that on everything."

House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) offered a similarly upbeat response to the speech, deeming Democrats "a willing partner" on an Obama agenda that focuses on "producing more oil domestically, promoting efficiency and leading the way in developing new energy technologies and cleaner fuels."

Reporters Sarah Abruzzese, Jeremy P. Jacobs and Katie Howell contributed.

###