Today, the eight Republicans on the
Environment and Public Works Committee will not attend the nomination vote of
Gina McCarthy to head the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). On April
25, 2013 the Committee Republicans asked Chairman Barbara Boxer to postpone the
nomination vote because they had not received answers to their questions. That
request was denied. The Senators made the following statement today:
"For too long EPA has failed to deliver
on the promises of transparency espoused by President Barack Obama, former
Administrator Lisa Jackson, and by Gina McCarthy. Accordingly, the Republicans
on the EPW Committee have asked EPA to honor five very reasonable and basic
requests in conjunction with the nomination of Gina McCarthy, which focus on
openness and transparency. While Chairman Boxer has allowed EPA adequate
time to fully respond before any mark-up on the nomination, EPA has stonewalled
on four of the five categories. We ask and expect that Chairman Barbara
Boxer will follow the rules of the Committee and the full U.S. Senate."
Rule
2(a) of the EPW Committee rules require at least two members of the minority
party to be present to constitute a quorum, which is necessary for the
Committee to take action.
Rule
XXVI 7(a)(1) of the Senate rules require that a majority of any Committee be
physically present to take action. This is a requirement enforceable on
the Senate floor, a fact confirmed by the Senate Parliamentarian’s office.
On April 10, the EPW Republicans
released five transparency concerns (four of which remain unresolved) they have
with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Click
here to read the letter to McCarthy outlining their requests. Click on each
of these transparency requests to read about each in detail: FOIA Failures, Inconsistent E-mail Practices and Policies, Transparency through Data Access, Snapshot Approach Toward Economic Analysis
Doesn’t Work, Share ‘Intent to Sue’
Notices with the Public.
Below is the text of a letter from EPW Republicans to Chairman Barbara Boxer
today notifying her that no Republicans would be attending.
May 9, 2013
Dear
Madame Chairman:
As
you know, all Republicans on our EPW Committee have asked EPA to honor five
very reasonable and basic requests in conjunction with the nomination of Gina
McCarthy which focus on openness and transparency. While you have allowed
EPA adequate time to fully respond before any mark-up on the nomination, EPA
has stonewalled on four of the five categories.
Because
of this, no Republican member of the Committee will attend today’s mark-up if
it is held.
We
do not ask or expect that you will agree with this decision. We do ask
and expect that you will follow the rules of the Committee and the full U.S. Senate.
Rule
2(a) of the Committee rules requires that at least two members of the minority
party be present to constitute a quorum, which is necessary for the Committee
to take action.
Rule
XXVI 7(a)(1) of the Senate rules requires that a majority of any Committee be
physically present to take action. This is a requirement enforceable on
the Senate floor, a fact confirmed by the Senate Parliamentarian’s office.
In
addition, there is clear Committee precedent regarding this. In 2003,
Democratic members of the EPW Committee chose not to attend the scheduled
mark-up of Michael Leavitt as President Bush’s nominee to head the EPA, pending
the EPA’s responding more fully to their requests. Then-Chairman Inhofe
followed the rules cited above and scheduled an official mark-up for two weeks
later. We ask and expect that you do the same.
We
also ask that you read this letter at any Committee meeting held today and
place it in the record.
Thank
you for your leadership of the Committee.
Sincerely,
David
Vitter
James
Inhofe
John
Barrasso
Jeff
Sessions
Mike
Crapo
Roger
Wicker
John
Boozman
Deb
Fischer
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Interested members of the media
Fr: EPW Republicans Press Office
Contact:
Luke Bolar 202-224-6176, luke_bolar@vitter.senate.gov
Re:
Gina McCarthy Nomination Hearing // Boycott precedent
Da: Thursday, May 9, 2013
U.S.
Senate Environment and Public Works (EPW) Committee Republicans have been
completely unsatisfied with the lack of response or nonresponsive answers from
Gina McCarthy who is nominated to head the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA).
EPW Committee rules state, "at committee business meetings…one third of the
members of the committee, at least two of whom are members of the minority
party, constitute a quorum,…no measure or matter may be reported to the Senate
by the committee unless a majority of the committee members cast votes in
person…"
There
is precedent for abiding by these rules, especially in nomination situations.
In 2003, when the Republicans held the majority on the Committee, Gov. Michael
O. Leavitt of Utah was nominated to be the EPA Administrator. On October 1,
2003, Democrats boycotted the Committee vote on the nomination, citing concerns
that they had not received adequate responses to their requests. Republicans,
under the chairmanship of Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.), followed committee rules
and postponed the Committee vote for two weeks.
Furthermore
Gina McCarthy has served as the Assistant Administrator for the Office of Air
and Radiation for four years, the office which has crafted the most expensive
regulations issued in the Agency’s history.
Politico Pro 5/8/2013 7:26
PM EDT
"Boxer didn’t know whether a move by
Republicans to protest tomorrow’s vote would be unprecedented. "But I don’t
ever remember it," she said."
Reminder:
Leavitt
was scheduled for a committee vote on October 1, 2003. Due to the Democrat boycott,
the Committee vote was postponed until October 15, 2003. Leavitt received a
vote on the Senate floor on October 28, 2003.
I. Excerpts
from the Senate floor
October 28, 2003 CONGRESSIONAL
RECORD-SENATE S13329
Mrs. BOXER. Madam President, I rise as a
proud member of the Environmental Committee and the chair of the Democratic
environmental team. I will be voting no on the Leavitt nomination.
The reason is, while I am not pinning
all the terrible decisions of this administration regarding the environment on
Mr. Leavitt-clearly, he was not there for those-I was very distressed
that
the questions I asked him were simply papered over or, in some cases-six
cases-there was no answer at all.
October 28, 2003 CONGRESSIONAL
RECORD-SENATE S13331
Mr. JEFFORDS. Madam President, it has surprised me to hear some Senators use
the word ‘obstruction’ in the context of Governor Leavitt’s nomination to be
the new Administrator of the EPA. It was a surprise because that is exactly
what this administration has been doing-obstructing Congress and our legitimate
requests for information.
II.
News
clips
The Washington
Times
Democrats boycott Leavitt
hearing
October 1, 2003
http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2003/oct/1/20031001-113738-4126r/?page=all
Excerpts: "The
committee had planned to vote on Gov. Michael O. Leavitt’s EPA nomination
yesterday but was blocked because none of the eight committee Democrats showed
up to the meeting. To hold a vote, the panel must have 10 members present,
including two Democrats.
"…[Sen. Jeffords] said Mr. Leavitt and the Bush
administration must answer questions that he and Democrats have…"
New
York Times
Senate
Democrats Boycott Hearing on E.P.A. Nominee
October 02,
2003
http://www.nytimes.com/2003/10/02/us/senate-democrats-boycott-hearing-on-epa-nominee.html
Excerpts: "The boycott denied the majority a quorum and
threw another wrench into the nomination process, which Democrats have vowed to
use to publicize their complaints about the president’s environmental policies…
"…Senator Joseph I. Lieberman, Democrat of Connecticut
and a presidential candidate, said of Governor Leavitt, ‘His nonresponsive
responses to our legitimate questions show either his disrespect of the
nomination process and the public or a lack of knowledge…’"
Chicago Tribune
Democrats
boycott vote on Leavitt’s EPA nomination
Senators
say Utah governor failed to answer questions
October
02, 2003|By Michael Kilian, Washington Bureau.
Excerpts:
"Senate Democrats on Wednesday boycotted a scheduled committee vote on
President Bush’s nomination of Utah Gov. Mike Leavitt to be the new
Environmental Protection Agency administrator, contending that Leavitt has
refused to fully answer their questions on his and the administration’s
positions on the environment.
"The boycott
forced Republicans to cancel the vote and reschedule it for Oct. 14."
Environment & Energy Daily
Leavitt cruises
through Senate EPW panel vote, 16-2
Thursday, October 16, 2003
http://www.eenews.net/public/Greenwire/2003/10/01/1
Excerpts: "…while Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) skipped the
session in protest of the responses Leavitt recently turned in to the lawmaker
concerning his views on a range of environment and energy matters.
"…Boxer said today she would block the nomination
until Leavitt is more forthcoming with answers to her questions…"
-30-
Specific Transparency Requests
1. That the EPA issue new guidance
drafted by its Office of General Counsel that clearly outlines: a) standards
and procedures to ensure that all official business is conducted solely on
official government email accounts; and b) standards and procedures for
responding fully, truthfully, and timely to FOIA requests and Congressional
inquiries. The guidance document should also establish training regimes
in these areas for all appropriate EPA staff, as well as penalties and
procedures for dealing with deviations from the guidance.
2. That all private email accounts of
Gina McCarthy are exhaustively reviewed, and that all emails regarding official
EPA business are produced unredacted to the committee. If no such emails
exist, that an affidavit stating that fact by McCarthy be produced for the
committee. In addition, we’re asking for transparency on specific
documents, including specified documents sent or received from the Richard
Windsor alias account, the committee has previously obtained in redacted form.
An outline of specific emails requested has been provided.
3. That underlying data used to
promulgate Clean Air Act rules be made public so the public can independently
examine cost/benefit and other issues. That the EPA release a full set of
data files for the American Cancer Society Study; the Harvard Six Cities Study;
HEI/Krewski et al. 2009; Laden et al. 2006; Lepeule 2012; and Jerrett 2009.
This request includes the coding of Personal Health Information (PHI).
4. That written assurances be given the
committee that the EPA will conduct cost/benefit analysis as required under
various executive orders and as required by the CAA, Section 321(a),
specifically through issuance of new guidance mandating "whole economy"
modeling on major rules.
5. That all petitions for rulemaking,
notices of intent to sue, and proposed settlements be tracked and made public
via readily available links on the EPA website. The Agency shall issue public
notice of its intent to engage in settlement negotiations prior to the
commencement of those negotiations, and include intervenors in any such
negotiations.
April 25, 2013
The
Honorable Barbara Boxer
Chairman
Committee
on Environment and Public Works
410
Dirksen Senate Office Bldg.
Washington,
DC 20510-6175
Dear
Chairman Boxer,
We
are concerned by your recent statement that the Environment and Public Works
(EPW) Committee may vote on the nomination of Gina McCarthy to be EPA
Administrator as early as May 8th. Before scheduling a vote, it is crucial that
we receive the outstanding answers from both the nominee and the Agency to
Committee members’ questions for the record (QFRs) as well as the outstanding
five requests made by the EPW Republicans. Those five requests simply ask for the
Agency to conduct its work in a transparent and open manner as President Obama,
former EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson, and the nominee have all publically
committed to do.
EPW
precedent illustrates that without answers to questions and information requests,
it is not appropriate to move forward with the nominee. In a 2003 letter to the
Chairman, Committee Democrats objected to moving forward with the nomination of
Governor Leavitt as EPA Administrator in part due to their stance that, while
they had received Leavitt’s answers to their written questions, those answers
were incomplete and insufficient.
In
this context, we would note your recent decision to delay scheduling a
nomination hearing for Nuclear Regulatory Commission Chairman Allison
MacFarlane pending submittal of information that you requested from her
concerning a nuclear facility in your state. We ask that you give us the same
courtesy while we work through getting our questions for Gina McCarthy answered
as well as the information we requested.
Sincerely,
David
Vitter
James
Inhofe
John
Barrasso
Jeff
Sessions
Mike
Crapo
Roger
Wicker
John
Boozman
Deb
Fischer
-30-