The U.S. Environmental Agency (EPA)
proposed a draft guidance in April 2011, defining the "waters of the U.S."
under the Clean Water Act (CWA) and giving EPA broad authority over regulating
bodies of water, even on private property.  Since the draft has been
proposed, there has been significant criticism surrounding the guidance’s
expansive interpretation of CWA jurisdiction.  Instead of clearly
abandoning the contemptuous guidance document outright, EPA has since
doubled-down on one of the most significant private property grabs in U.S.
history, with the development of a new rule that would give the federal
government outright permitting authority over virtually any wet area in the
country and would provide a new tool for environmental groups to sue private
property owners.

Local creeks, drainage ditches, farm
ponds, or puddles in a backyard could all fall under EPA’s heavy regulatory
hand because the Agency has determined their in-house science justifies taking
over property jurisdiction from farmers, small businesses, and families.

Multiple attempts by EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to implement
their federal intrusion have been struck down by the Supreme Court of the
United States.  Because of the increased scrutiny, EPA purported to
"withdraw" the draft guidance this year, but in a classic sleight of hand they
simultaneously introduced a new proposed rule – that says essentially the same
thing.  EPA also introduced a "connectivity report," which claims that
every body of water, no matter how small, is somehow connected.  And
according to the EPA, this report justifies the government’s intrusion onto
private lands.  Scientific peer review of the "connectivity report" is far
from complete, and numerous groups and individuals have already identified
significant flaws in the report.  However, EPA’s draft rule, which is
predicated on the "connectivity report," is already moving towards its final
stages of implementation and has been sent to the Office of Management and
Budget (OMB) for interagency review.


"Connectivity Report" is a real stretch
(pun intended)

The Connectivity Report would supposedly
justify a significant expansion of the Clean Water Act’s scope.  It ties
together every small stream and isolated wetland to larger bodies of
water.

EPW Republicans see this as a power grab
or "takeover" by giving EPA the authority to regulate every square foot in the
country that has water on it, including incidentals like rainwater, storm
runoff, and puddles.

In the coming weeks, OMB is scheduled to
review the draft rule which is based on the Connectivity Report.  EPW
Republicans intend to challenge EPA’s rushed rulemaking effort.


Real World Consequences

In New York, a landowner is seeking
redress against EPA officials after years of agency harassment and wrongful
assertions of CWA regulatory jurisdiction.  According to a federal
lawsuit, EPA retaliated against the landowner after he challenged EPA and the
Army Corps’ jurisdictional claims, in attempt to make an example out of
him.  See Huntress v. EPA.  Read
a letter from the landowner here
.  The lawsuit refers to an EPA
regional administrator’s 2010 statements regarding agency staff training and
how EPA staff should mimic the Roman practice of crucifying victims in order to
set an intimidating example for others and proposes that a similar tactic was
used against the landowner in New York.  The regional administrator
referenced has since resigned.

In Sante Fe, New Mexico, the U.S. Army
Corps of Engineers in 2012 attempted to label a dry creek bed on private
property as a "water of the U.S.," which would then be subject to CWA
regulations.  When the family who owned the land moved in, they began
clearing brush and vegetation to clean up their property. The Corps took issue
with this and sent the family a ‘Notice of Violation’ for conducting
unpermitted work in a "water of the U.S." and ordered them to desist the
cleanup and maintenance efforts, or else be subject to civil and criminal
liability.  The couple fought back and sued the Army Corps.  Click
here to read more
.

 

EPW Republicans
are challenging the vast expansion of EPA’s water jurisdiction

EPW Committee Republicans have a long
history of challenging the EPA’s egregious guidance. Recently, in February
2013, U.S. Sens. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.) and David Vitter (R-La.), EPW’s top
Republican, led a group of 30 senators urging the Administration to withdraw
the draft guidance.  Read more here.

In 2009 during an EPW hearing, Committee
Democrats attempted to pass a ruling to expand EPA’s authority through the
Clean Water Restoration Act.  Vitter and Barrasso offered multiple
amendments to prevent such an expansion of jurisdiction, yet one by one the
Democrats voted down each amendment. Click here for
more
.

This issue was seemingly resolved on
September 17, 2013, when EPA informed congressional staff that the draft
guidance would be withdrawn, but they refrained from making a public
announcement.  Then, on the very same day, EPA posted on their website
that the Agency and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, their partner on this
guidance, would proceed with the rulemaking.  Read more about
EPW Republicans calling on the EPA to clarify their confusion and ambiguity.

EPW Republicans believe that the EPA
should completely and unconditionally abandon the draft guidance in any and all
circumstances, especially now that the Agency’s rulemaking efforts are plagued
by uncertainty and distrust.


Legal History Behind Limiting
Jurisdiction:

Two important Supreme Court decisions,
otherwise referred to as SWANCC and Rapanos, were critical to
limiting federal regulation, including EPA and Army Corps jurisdiction.  
These two cases were pivotal in ensuring the EPA and Corps
jurisdictional/permitting authority did not extend to every remote body of
water, despite having no immediate connection to a navigable water of the
United States.  Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County (SWANCC) v.
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
, was decided in 2001, and Rapanos v. United
States
, was decided in 2006.   In SWANCC, the Army Corps
theorized that their jurisdiction could essentially be set on the wings of a
migratory bird.  The Corps attempted to claim that any body of water in
which a bird could land should fall under federal jurisdiction.  In Rapanos,
the EPA theorized that their jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act for
wetlands permitting of fill and dredge material was essentially limitless no
matter how remote the project was from a navigable water.  For the
radical-left, which has long pushed for federal jurisdiction of virtually any
water body, including intermittent ponds and streams, these two decisions have
frustrated their ability to file lawsuits against private landowners for any
action they deem inappropriate on that private property.


 

-30-