During
2013, the U.S. Senate Environment and Public Works Committee Republicans and
ranking member U.S. Sen. David Vitter (R-La.), have been working to lift the
veil of secrecy from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), especially
regarding their use of hidden or otherwise dubious science.
Earlier
this year, Sen. Vitter led efforts during
the process of Gina McCarthy’s nomination to be EPA Administrator to
improve transparency measures throughout the Agency, especially focusing on the
secret science used to justify expensive new rules and regulations. On July 9,
2013, Sen. Vitter allowed Gina McCarthy’s nomination to proceed after extensive
negotiations with the Agency, regarding commitments from them on a number of 5 specific transparency requests, including:
As
well as having already providing certain requested data, EPA has initiated the
process of obtaining the requested scientific information, as well as reaching
out to relevant institutions for information on how to de-identify and code
personally identifying information that may be included in some of the data.
EPA
launched a process to convene an independent panel of economic experts with
experience in whole economy modeling to review EPA’s ability to measure full
regulatory impacts, and to make recommendations to the agency.
To
help address transparency issues, in particular the "sue and settle" practice,
EPA created websites to publish the Notices of Intent to Sue (NOI) and
Petitions for Rulemaking (PFR) upon receipt. Those websites can be found at http://www2.epa.gov/aboutepa/petitions-rulemaking
and http://www.epa.gov/ogc/noi.html.
A
commitment by EPA to mandate the re-training of the 17,000+ EPA workforce in
proper protocols involving Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, as well
as issuing new guidance on records maintenance and use of personal email
accounts pursuant to and upon completion of the audit by the Inspector General.
All
successes in these areas are integral steps in lifting the veil of secrecy at
EPA.
Below
are a few of the key actions Vitter took this year:
March 4: Sen. Vitter
and Rep. Lamar Smith reiterate call for transparency and release of EPA secret
data
March 12: Sunshine Week
– EPA’s Secret Science
April 5: Eye on the EPA
– A closer look at Gina McCarthy
April 8: EPA’s failure
to share scientific data with Congress & the American public
April 10: Vitter &
EPW Republicans release requests for Gina McCarthy nomination
April 11: How would Gina
McCarthy change EPA’s questionable transparency practices for the better?
April 18: Eye on the EPA
– Lifting the veil of secrecy
April 24: Eye on the EPA
– Transparency through data access
April 25: Eye on the EPA
– Snapshot approach toward economic analysis doesn’t work
April 26: Eye on the EPA
– Share ‘intent to sue’ notices with the public
May 6: Sen. Vitter
highlights Gina McCarthy’s unresponsive ‘responses’ ahead of confirmation
hearing
May 9: EPW
Republicans delay Gina McCarthy nomination vote
June 12: Sen. Vitter
reiterates request for release of EPA secret data
July 9: Sen. Vitter
& EPA Republicans get major agreements from EPA on 5 transparency requests
August 21: EPA takes
first steps in acquiring and releasing secret data
EPA’s Secret Science Behind Major Air
Rules
The science and data
supporting EPA’s new rules and regulations, which oftentimes lead to burdensome
and unnecessary economic struggles for American businesses, are rarely shared
with the public. Sen. Vitter
requested that EPA share the underlying data used to promulgate CAA rules
so that the public can independently examine the cost-benefit analyses
and other issues. This includes a full set of data files for the controversial
American Cancer Society Study; the Harvard Six Cities Study; HEI/Krewski et al.
2009; Lepeule 2012; Pope et al. 2002; Pope et al. 2009; and Jerrett 2009, and
the coding of Personal Health Information (PHI).
Status: During the
course of negotiations with then-nominee McCarthy, EPA delivered raw data to
the EPW Committee without any personal identifiers on the studies listed above.
EPA reached out to Harvard, HEI, and ACS to solicit ideas and possible ways to
access the remaining underlying data and code anything with identifying
information. While all three responded, ACS implied in their response that
Congress should not have asked for or receive access to the science in their
study, and HEI’s response was vague and unsatisfactory. Harvard said, "A great
deal of time has elapsed since data collection began in these long-term air
pollutions studies. Existing electronic data from the early years of the HSC
study may have deteriorated, or may be stored on media that cannot now be read
of deciphered by any available devices or software."
Essentially, the data supporting these
studies, which led to the creation and implementation of major CAA rules,
seemingly no longer exists, or otherwise has yet to go through
de-identification of the data so as to facilitate independent analysis.
This begs the question: If the data does not exist, or if the agency is going
to continue to fail to provide all data despite recommendations on how to
de-identify and make public, why is EPA using these studies?
EPA’s Shortsighted Approach Toward
Economic Modeling Does Not Work
EPA has failed on numerous occasions to
conduct the cost-benefit analyses on major rules that are required under
various executive orders and by law. As such, Sen.
Vitter requested
that EPA conduct those analyses, specifically through issuance of new guidance
mandating "whole economy" modeling on major rules.
Status: The EPA
committed to work with the Agency’s Science Advisory Board (SAB) to establish
an expert panel to advise the Agency on the use of whole economy modeling to
estimate the impacts resulting from the benefits and costs of EPA regulations.
The agreement is not to use any of EPA’s current economics panel members
(Environmental Economics Advisory Committee). The SAB is charged with
selecting a balanced panel, including members that have expertise in whole
economy modeling at the macro and micro level, including granular analysis of
regulatory impact and full causality/ripple effects. EPW is working with SAB in
this process, and also to develop questions and criteria for panel members. SAB
is expected to share a timeline for its economy-wide modeling review this week.
Notices of Intent to Sue/Petitions for
Rulemaking
In the ongoing legal battles with EPA
and various private sector groups and organizations, the Agency is responsible
for making public and regularly updating all notices of intent to sue,
petitions for rulemaking, and the promulgation of guidance received by EPA.
Unsurprisingly, EPA has done a poor job of tracking, listing, and updating its
website on these petitions and notices. Sen.
Vitter requested
that EPA fulfill its obligations, as well as share all comments received on a
consent order or settlement agreement with the presiding judge prior to the
Agency certifying and agreeing to support any such consent order or settlement
agreement, which is mandated by law.
Status: The EPA
committed to establish a website to post petitions for rulemaking received by
the Agency. That website, along with a separate website specifically created
for disclosure of notices of intent to sue, is now live and tracks petitions
received by the Agency starting at the beginning of 2013. This achievement is a
necessary first step in piercing the veil of secrecy on sue and settle, the
common practice of secretive, closed-door agreements between EPA and
environmental organizations friendly to this Administration that shut out
States and affected parties. Those websites can be found at http://www2.epa.gov/aboutepa/petitions-rulemaking
and http://www.epa.gov/ogc/noi.html.
Examples of the Costly Impacts of
Sue-and-Settle
Regional Haze: Individual
States are supposed to regulate regional haze. However, EPA is usurping state
control of the program in an attempt to shut down coal-fired power plants. EPA and
state officials have disagreed over which emissions controls were required at a
number of coal-fired power plants for compliance with the program.
Environmental groups have filed lawsuits alleging that EPA failed to meet
non-discretionary deadlines to act on the Regional Haze State Implementation
Plans (SIPs). Rather than litigate these cases, EPA chose to settle with the
environmental groups, and require Federal Implementation Plans (FIPs), which
are several times more expensive than the states’ SIPs. EPA’s plan for Oklahoma
would cost $1.2 billion more than the state’s SIP. In Arizona, the Navajo
Generating Station installed low nitrogen oxide burners at a cost of $45
million; yet EPA’s preferred system would cost more than $700 million. In
Wyoming, EPA’s FIP is projected to impose $96 million per year in additional
costs.
Cross State Air Pollution Rule: On July 6, 2011,
EPA finalized the Cross State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) requiring 27 upwind
States to sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions
that may contribute to downwind nonattainment for ozone and particulate matter.
Setting a compliance deadline of just 6 months later (January 1, 2012), the
final rule usurped cooperative federalism by forcing Federal Implementation
Plans (FIPs) on the States to comply with the cap established in their emission
budgets. It also added several States to the rule, which were not included in
the proposal. In response to the rule, multiple utilities announced that in
order to comply, the closures of facilities and mining operations would be
necessary, which obviously means jobs would be lost. Additionally, an
independent study based on the draft rule estimated an increase in consumer
power prices of as much as $514 million per year in 2012 and 2013.
Social Cost of Carbon – part of the
ongoing transparency challenge at EPA
The Social Cost of Carbon (SCC) is a
theoretical estimate of the monetized damages associated with an incremental
increase in carbon emissions in a given year, the purpose of which is so
agencies can attempt to justify theorized "social benefits" of reducing carbon
dioxide emissions into cost-benefit analyses of regulatory actions that impact
consumers and our economy. Most notably, the values take into account
speculative negative consequences while ignoring positive correlations
associated with increased carbon dioxide emissions. For example, economic
damages from climate change in the Dynamic Integrated Climate Change (DICE)
model are represented by a fractional loss of gross economic output in each
period. However, the economic benefits of increased crop production and
affordable, reliable energy are not factored into the model.
The increase in the social cost of
carbon is significant due to its potential effect on President Obama’s climate
change agenda. The model will be used to evaluate the costs and benefits of new
climate policy and as a justification of implementing such policy. For example,
the Department of Energy recently updated its energy- efficiency standards for
microwaves and the agency used a higher figure for the SCC in calculating the
benefits of the rule. A higher SCC means agencies could invent an analysis that
supports virtually any new regulations to curb GHGs because stricter standards
could more easily pass a cost-benefit analysis, such as new rules for existing
power plants. EPW Republicans are challenging the increase in SCC because it
could also give the Administration incentive to push for carbon tax
legislation.In February 2010, an Interagency Working
Group made up of 12 Agencies and Executive offices released a Technical Support
Document (TSD) on the Social Cost of Carbon for Regulatory Impact Analysis,
which requires agencies to "assess both the costs and the benefits of the
intended regulation and, recognizing that some costs and benefits are difficult
to quantify, propose or adopt a regulation only upon a reasoned determination
that the benefits of the intended regulation justify its costs." Except for the
general list of participating offices on the cover of the TSD, there has been
essentially no information on who was involved, at what level, what their
participation entailed, or anything about the process behind developing the
SCC. The TSD was updated in May 2013, and again in November, Howard Shelanksi
(OIRA Administrator) issued further updates following two errors.
Sen. Vitter lead
a group of Senators
in challenging a recent revision of the Administration’s estimate for the SCC,
which has since been used in developing new and costly regulations.
Status: It wasn’t until
November 5, 2013, when Sen. Vitter
questioned Sarah Dunham, Director of EPA’s Office of Atmospheric Programs,
about the SCC that any participants were confirmed. Dunham confirmed her
office’s involvement in the IWG, providing technical analyses and modeling for
developing the SCC estimates.
EPW
Republicans will be sending out additional documents recapping the committee’s
work during 2013 on various issues. Stay tuned for more in the coming days.
-30-