Sen.
David Vitter (R-La.), top Republican on the Environment and Public Works (EPW)
Committee, has launched the second phase
of his investigation

into the collusion between environmental activists, lawyers and lobbyists,
billionaires and their supporting foundations who use large sums of money to
influence environmental public policy.

Over
the coming weeks, EPW Republicans will be detailing exactly how these
coordinated efforts are destroying jobs and punishing industries and families
across America. From farmers to miners to rig workers to manufacturers and
fishermen, EPW Republicans will examine how their jobs and way of life are
being targeted by well-funded environmental activists whose primary goal is
maximizing government control, particularly over the land, water, and resources
utilized by private industries and individuals. Today focuses on recreational fishing.

The
Gulf States have an abundance of natural resources, from the vast supply of
fossil fuels and minerals to the diverse fisheries. One economic power house in
the Gulf is the recreational fishing sector, made up of private anglers and
charter boat captains. The industry is expected to contribute more than $9.1
billion to the Gulf’s economy over the next 18 years and currently supports
over 139,000 jobs.[1] The Gulf Regional Fishery
Management Council (Gulf RFMC), under the Department of Commerce, is
responsible for governing fisheries in federal waters.


Environmental
Collusion


Large
far-left environmental groups have long fought against the interests of
recreational fishermen in the Gulf. For decades now, national environmental
groups, including the Ocean Conservancy and the Environmental Defense Fund
(EDF), have been responsible for funding smaller grassroots operations in order
to influence policy decisions of the Gulf RFMC. Since 2009, the Ocean
Conservancy has received hundreds of thousands of dollars each from Tides
Foundation, the Rockefeller Brothers Fund, and Marisla Foundation, and over $1
million each from the David and Lucile Packard Foundation, and the Gordon and Betty
Moore Foundation.[2] Furthermore, since the
early 1990s, these national organizations have used traditional lobbying
efforts, litigation, as well as access to certain boards and councils that
manage fisheries, in order to limit the number of anglers on the water, as well
as the overall number of allowable catch.


The
Gulf Seafood Institute (GSI) is a prime example of this coordination. While the
GSI represents itself as an independent entity, its funding tells a different
story. The Ocean Conservancy gave GSI a $20,000 grant to help them launch the
organization.[3] Members of the GSI’s
board of directors are also prominent members of the Gulf RFMC. Some of the
Gulf RFMC members are working closely with EDF to push a shared agenda to limit
access of recreational anglers to the Red Snapper fishery in the Gulf’s federal
waters.[4] As a result of coordinated efforts,
the 2014 recreational fishing season was reduced from 40 days to 9 days.


Administration’s
Influence


EDF
has allies in important places. EDF was recently awarded a $225,959 grant
sponsored by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), as
well as Billionaire’s Club regulars
including Marisla Foundation, the Walton Family Foundation, and the Gordon and
Betty Moore Foundation.[5] The
purpose of this grant is to support research into the economic and conservation
performance of "sector separation," a rights-based management (catch shares)
pilot program for Gulf of Mexico recreational fishing businesses. In other
words, the grant pays EDF to study and build support for a position they are
already advocating for.


Environmentalists’
tactics were first deployed in the early 1990s when EDF pushed for the
implementation of an Individual Fishing Quota (IFQ) system. This limited
allocation system forced many smaller fishing operations to "sell their family
business."[6] As a result, only 393 commercially
licensed red snapper fishermen operate in the Gulf today, with only 28 in
Louisiana. The IFQ rewards the small number of commercial fishermen with the
right to fish 51% of the red snapper in the Gulf.  Essentially, these 393
individuals have guaranteed allocations, as they have the rights to these
resources in perpetuity. These allocation percentages were determined using
data from the 1980s.[7] 
All stakeholders, including commercial fisherman and the governors of
Louisiana, Mississippi, Florida, and Texas, agree that the federal management
system has led to inefficiencies that have produced inaccurate baseline numbers
underestimating the current stock.[8]


Commercial
Red Snapper

Shareholders
Per State

Florida

279

Texas

49

Louisiana

28

Alabama

20

Mississippi

9

South
Carolina

3

New
York

1

New
Jersey

1

Georgia

1

Iowa

1

Montana

1

Source: Southeast Regional Office of the National Marine
Fisheries Service

 

Lobbying
Influence


Anglers
have sought to redress the unfair allocations, most notably through an
amendment to current fishing regulations, known as Amendment 28. This amendment
would require Gulf RFMC to reallocate a larger portion of the Gulf’s red
snapper stock to the recreational sector, taking into account the growth of the
recreational industry and associated revenues. However, EDF and their allies in
the Gulf region have led a coordinated assault on this Amendment, going so far
as to file a lawsuit against NOAA for failing to adequately manage the
recreational side of the fishery,[9] a step
that garnered additional support to table Amendment 28.


In
their fight against Amendment 28, EDF was successful in luring boat captains to
their side by promising[10] them
the rights to half of the quota currently allocated for recreational fishing.
This proposal, known as Amendment 40, sits before the Gulf Council. While there
is virtually no public support for EDF’s push for sector separation,[11] the Gulf RFMC has failed to delay or
end further consideration and has scheduled a final vote on the proposal in
October. If implemented, the red snapper fishery would become 75% privatized,
assisting EDF’s campaign to end public access to the federal fishery.


Due
to EDF’s attempts to manipulate federal policy and limit public access, each
Gulf State has chosen to be noncompliant with federal regulations, opening
state waters for prolonged periods of time.[12]
In response, the Gulf RFMC proceeded to reduce this year’s recreational season
to 9 days.[13] The economic effects
of this decision are far-reaching. Gulf anglers and the vast array of
businesses that supply fishing gear, boats, and supplies will struggle to
maintain in the face of this vast federal overreach.


The
most astonishing realization is that the shenanigans surrounding the red
snapper fishery in the Gulf serves as only one example of how far-left,
national environmental groups are tampering with local economies and
lifestyles. EPW
Republicans will continue detailing exactly how these coordinated efforts are
destroying jobs and punishing industries and families across America. Click
here to read Collusion &
Coordination to Shut Down the Oil & Gas Industry
.

 


 


-30-

 


[1]
https://www.st.nmfs.noaa.gov/economics/publications/feus/fisheries_economics_2011

[2]
Tides Foundation IRS Form 990 for 2010, 2011, 2012; Gordon & Betty Moore
Foundation IRS Form 990 for 2010, 2011, 2012; Rockefeller Brothers Fund Grants
Database, search for "Ocean Conservancy" http://www.rbf.org/content/grants-search; Marisla Foundation IRS Form 990
for 2010, 2012; the David and Lucile Packard Foundation, search for "Ocean
Conservancy" http://www.packard.org/grants/grants-database/?grant_keyword=ocean+conservancy&program_area=All+Programs&award_amount=All+Amounts&award_year=All+Years.

[3]
http://gulfseafoodnews.com/2013/09/08/gulf-seafood-institute-becomes-reality-with-20000-grant-from-ocean-conservancy

[4]
[A] http://www.gulfcouncil.org/about/fishery_council_members.php

[B]
http://gulfseafoodinstitute.org/gsi-board-gulf-seafood-institute

[5]
http://www.nfwf.org/fisheriesfund/Pages/home.aspx#.VCGiJ_ldV_p

[6]
http://www.gulfcouncil.org/docs/amendments/Red%20Snapper%205-year%20Review%20FINAL.pdf

[7]
http://sero.nmfs.noaa.gov/sustainable_fisheries/gulf_fisheries/reef_fish/2013/am28/documents/pdfs/allocation_accountability_guide.pdf

[8]
http://s3.amazonaws.com/assets.clients/cca/ckeditor_assets/attachments/539/govletterfinal41613signed_2.pdf?1400255231

[9]
https://www.epw.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/media/image/0.pdf

[10]
http://www.newsherald.com/outdoors/anglers-divided-on-red-snapper-amendment-1.351054

[11] 
[A] http://www.gulfcouncil.org/fishery_management_plans/Public%20Comment/RF%20Amendment%2040%20-%20Sector%20Separation/Comments.pdf

[B]
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Atgbk2rxQkqhdFlHMXpBb2Zld2J1dlpOZHp2RjZrQmc&usp=drive_web#gid=0

[12]
[A] http://www.wlf.louisiana.gov/news/37583

[B]
http://governor.alabama.gov/newsroom/2014/06/alabama-open-red-snapper-season-state-waters-every-weekend-july/

[C]
http://www.myfwc.com/fishing/saltwater/recreational/snappers/gulf-red-snapper/

[D]
http://www.tpwd.state.tx.us/fishboat/fish/recreational/federal.phtml/

[E]
http://www.dmr.state.ms.us/index.php/news-a-events/recent-news/654-14-59-mms

[13]
http://www.nola.com/outdoors/index.ssf/2014/04/louisiana_bucks_federal_fish_m.html