Mr. Chairman, I would like to thank you for calling today’s hearing. I would also like to thank our witnesses for testifying before the Subcommittee on Water and Wildlife.

The title of today’s hearing invokes concepts with which few would disagree. There’s no question that the federal government should foster innovative wastewater and water management practices, and that local treatment facilities are and should be leaders in ensuring safe water supplies. Unfortunately, as in so many other areas, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is acting as an impediment to innovation in the water utility sector.

In fact, EPA’s hindering of effective water and wastewater treatment is symbolic of a larger, systemic problem throughout the agency. Many Americans view EPA as a rogue agency that imposes its regulatory will in a manner that harms local communities and is contrary to law. Too often creating unnecessary obstacles to technological improvements and progress, EPA’s policies serve as a disincentive for innovation throughout the public and private sectors. Water and wastewater management are routinely frustrated by such challenges.

For example, EPA has improperly restricted many wastewater utilities from engaging in a treatment practice known as blending. Blending combines biological, chemical, and physical treatment processes and is used by wastewater facilities to manage large flow variations during major rainfall events. Blending is sometimes necessary during major wet-weather events that would otherwise overwhelm treatment systems, and historically the practice has received support from EPA.

In recent years, however, EPA has enforced a new policy that declares wastewater plant blending operations to be illegal. According to John Hall, one of our witnesses today, the cost of this new prohibition was projected by EPA itself to exceed $200 billion, and the blending ban has "slowed down the ability of communities to safely eliminate untreated overflows, by eliminating a viable, cost-effective option that provided treatment and met permit limits."

Worse yet, EPA’s blending ban is an unlawful attempt to circumvent Congress and the agency’s own, previously-established rules. As the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals determined in March 2013, EPA violated the Administrative Procedure Act by promulgating blending rules without using the statute’s notice and comment procedures. The court also determined EPA’s "legislative rule" exceeded the agency’s statutory authority under the Clean Water Act.

EPA’s illegal blending policy was a demonstrable failure by EPA to work with local communities to manage important water treatment issues, underscoring several fundamental problems with the agency. First, the blending case confirms EPA’s disdain for transparency, having attempted to regulate in a manner that directly contradicted the Clean Water Act and established policies. Second, the case illustrates the red-tape and bureaucracy the agency seeks to impose on local communities, which rarely have the financial resources to take on the agency as the sewer systems did here. Third, it is worth noting that EPA has taken the position that this case only applies in the Eighth Circuit, and that the agency has authority to restrict blending on a "case-by-case basis." In other words, through its illegal blending regulation, EPA is now thumbing its nose at the courts, in addition to Congress and local communities.

It should also come as no surprise that EPA’s deeply-flawed proposal to revise the definition of "waters of the United States" under the Clean Water Act will make it even more difficult to effectively manage local water resources. The proposed rule would automatically designate "tributaries," impoundments of "tributaries," and "adjacent waters" as "waters of the United States," thereby forcing local communities throughout the country to obtain costly permits just so they can properly manage wastewater and stormwater conveyances. Under the proposed rule, these same communities will no doubt face increased and crippling citizen suit litigation if their regulatory officials do not accede to the relentless demands of hostile environmental NGO’s. Notably, for purposes of this hearing, waste treatment systems do not constitute "waters of the United States" under current regulations, but the proposed "waters of the United States" rule would create significant uncertainty about the scope of this long-standing exemption. Another of today’s witnesses Jeffrey Longsworth indicated in his written testimony that "EPA’s overly prescriptive and unjustified mandates and efforts to expand its Clean Water Act jurisdiction to drainage features within MS4s in contravention of the limitations set forth by Congress in the Act significantly hamper and threaten MS4 operators’ ability to efficiently protect local water resources."

EPA’s blending policies and its proposed "waters of the United States" rule both demonstrate why the agency’s credibility has diminished in recent years. Today’s discussion on innovation in water and wastewater management is important and provides a needed opportunity to examine how EPA is impeding local efforts. I appreciate the chairman holding this hearing today, and I look forward to hearing from our witnesses.

-30-